Any political sub members born outside the USA?
in Close to Politics ·
"If someone picks up citizenship and moves to the States, they might technically be an American on paper, but can they ever truly reach that level of being American that I, as a native-born citizen, possess through both genetics and deep-seated socio-cultural roots? Certain things simply cannot be replaced by mere formal labeling, passports, or a sudden decision that says 'as of tomorrow, I am an American.' That isn't how it works.
You can't just declare yourself German tomorrow if you lack fundamental connections—German parents, mastery of the language, or a fully internalized German culture. There are numerous factors that define one's belonging to a nation; among them, you must share the destiny of the people you claim to belong to. It is tragic what happens with our emigration across the Atlantic and even with certain ethnic minorities in places like Austria or Vojvodina. Sure, in some sense, they maintain ties to the homeland and originate from there, but if they spend decades living elsewhere, that connection dilutes until it's practically non-existent. They don't live according to our way of life. So, what makes them part of the group? A surname? Some fleeting memories or occasional visits to relatives? All of that is far too flimsy to constitute a true pedigree.
That’s just how it is, kid. Listen to an older American.
You are nothing but an authentic American idiot.
🙂
You can't just declare yourself German tomorrow if you lack fundamental connections—German parents, mastery of the language, or a fully internalized German culture. There are numerous factors that define one's belonging to a nation; among them, you must share the destiny of the people you claim to belong to. It is tragic what happens with our emigration across the Atlantic and even with certain ethnic minorities in places like Austria or Vojvodina. Sure, in some sense, they maintain ties to the homeland and originate from there, but if they spend decades living elsewhere, that connection dilutes until it's practically non-existent. They don't live according to our way of life. So, what makes them part of the group? A surname? Some fleeting memories or occasional visits to relatives? All of that is far too flimsy to constitute a true pedigree.
That’s just how it is, kid. Listen to an older American.
You are nothing but an authentic American idiot.
🙂