Is spirit everything?
in Spirituality ·
Rachel Bishop said:Look, listen up...
The absolute core of this whole mess regarding matter versus spirit is this...
That split doesn't exist anywhere except inside our own heads.
There's no matter and spirit, there's no matter *or* spirit—there is just
one undivided reality.
You could call it whatever you want, but you gotta realize it is one single, indivisible thing.
This topic is tied heavily to how we perceive and interpret things,
because that’s basically what builds our entire worldview—this supposed split in reality between spirit and matter.
Your refusal to accept this is totally understandable, honestly. That feeling of losing your footing when you think about this stuff—that sense of having the ground ripped out from under you—is real. But the truth is, that "solid ground" was never even there. Until we learn how to stand on "nothing," we feel like we have to cling to it. Whatever. Eventually, you're gonna lose it anyway... might as well learn how to stand without a crutch sooner rather than later.
So, what does all this actually imply? What's the point?
It means an incredibly simple solution... and incredible freedom. That's what it means.😉
Man, you're at it again, just throwing stuff out there with zero backup! Not even the most old-school pantheists would claim they've got the whole concept of Spirit and matter figured out. But you? You act like it's no big deal, just flooding the feed with this New Age nonsense.
And don't even get me started on Immanence and Transcendence—you clearly haven't got a clue how they work in the grand scheme of things.
Spirit isn't nearly as material as you're trying to make it look, and matter isn't as spiritual as you think it is either.
"deus sive natura" isn't some empirical fact you can just toss around whenever you feel like it.
God transcends the human spirit, even if we talk to Him like we're on equal footing. Our little human ways of projecting onto Him don't mean anything, just like pantheism doesn't hold water here.
You can't pin God down with pantheism, and you can't reduce Him to some basic, conversational "You."
In the US, we see echoes of this kind of "reciprocal immanence" in religious texts involving the Father and the Son, but even through the Incarnation, you can't just simplify it into equality. Immanence and Transcendence are two sides of the same coin in God's battle—a thing we can't even begin to grasp or describe. It's a total mystery.
Our understanding will always be incomplete because everyone knows deep down that divine divinity exists far beyond our senses and our logic. God's battle is way beyond any "You" we can imagine.
M.