Lease agreements: Tips, questions, and experiences
in Banking, Insurance & Loans ·
George Wilson4 said:You make a fair point, though I’m running my own numbers here. I have some cash set aside specifically for a down payment on a vehicle, but when you look at the bottom line, the math ends up being pretty much identical. For me, an operating lease might actually be the smarter move for our credit profile. If my primary company acts as a guarantor for my other firm when we go to acquire a boat through an operating lease, having that guarantee in place should mean the new entity needs to put down a much smaller deposit.
That said, I’m still on the fence about applying that same logic to a car. It starts feeling a bit too much like a standard rental, especially considering our typical mileage—we usually clock in around 15,000 to 18,000 miles a year—so I’m just not entirely sure.
I honestly don't know how much a finance lease would actually weigh down the credit rating of the smaller firm.
Look, honestly, the best move is just to head down to the dealership and ask for quotes on both operating and finance Leasing. Then you can actually compare them properly. That's literally their job, and nobody is forcing you to sign anything later. As far as I know, most dealerships have connections with Leasing companies, so you should be able to get a quote for both the car and the financing right then and there.
As for the credit side of things, a finance lease hits your numbers pretty hard. That’s why I’m telling you to get those quotes. Take the monthly payment, subtract the interest (since that counts as a business expense), and multiply by 12—that's the amount of cash you need to have sitting there to cover all the payments out of your net profit. But then again, you could potentially write off the car using accelerated depreciation, though you might end up paying 30% in taxes on personal use (if it's a personal vehicle?)... man, what a headache. There is just so much to crunch. Basically, if the company has the cash, you could just buy it outright and skip the interest entirely. If the business can swing it—meaning they don't actually need that capital for day-to-day operations—then that’s probably the smartest way to go. I think you’re gonna have to sit down and actually map this stuff out on paper, because trying to figure out what's better for a specific business just by guessing is tough. Good luck.