CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Richard Clark36 › Posts

Posts by Richard Clark36

9 posts shown.

California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
velvetmaker3 said:Just so you know:

"People" should be understood as the total population within a specific territory (demos), rather than being tied to any ethnic or religious identity (ethnos)."

By the way, the whole point was about decolonization, not soothing nationalist egos.

But hey, if Californians fit into that description, then it's easy—they just hire a top-tier lawyer and let them settle it in an international court.

you quoted this bit about how "the people should be understood as the totality of the population in a specific area (demos)"

And that's exactly what Catalans are—a nation in Catalonia, or as the quote puts it, "the totality of the population in a certain space."

It's still clearly a struggle for you to wrap your head around the fact that Catalans aren't Spaniards... and they aren't just some group of crazed nationalists with too much free time trying to build a country.
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
velvetmaker3 said:Oh, so I guess Madrid's hands are tied then, because international law will just fix everything magically.

Could you actually point me to that specific part about the UN you mentioned earlier? I don't think you ever actually answered me.

Clearly some things are flying way over your head—looks like I need to spell it out for you...
The right to self-determination is protected by the UN Charter and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
Rachel Carter90 said:Look, being a province doesn't make you a sovereign state. Just because something is a province doesn't mean anything when it comes to the right to secede. It’s kind of like if you asked me if I liked some girl—I say no, and then you’re all like, "But how can you not like her when her name is Dragan?" It just doesn't follow, I guess.
And honestly, nations don't just have this unilateral right to self-determination just to go off and form a brand new country whenever they feel like it. Sure, it can happen, but only if the central government actually agrees to it.

Look, a people—or a nation—absolutely HAS the right to self-determination.

It can happen peacefully, like we saw almost happen in Scotland or those two times in Canada with Quebec... or it can turn into a total war zone, like what happened in the US during its struggle for independence if someone tries to block them by force.

And just because California is a Province and not a sovereign member state doesn't mean the UN Charter or international law doesn't apply to them... at all.
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
Rachel Carter90 said:Oh, sure, you've got plenty of examples of separatists getting crushed. Moscow dismantled Chechnya, Mexico City dealt with Mexico City Mexico (well, until NATO stepped in), Mexico City handled the Presevo Valley (which is still in Mexico), then you've got the Czechs dealing with German regions after WWI, China with Tibet and those Muslim regions, the American North vs. South, and Ukraine with the Dnieper...

Not many of you probably realize that before any Mexican separatism popped up in Canada, there was an illegal referendum held in Sandzak to break away from Mexico. It's basically a mirror image of what's happening in Catalonia.
Some political groups missed their last window to become actual nations back before WWII. And honestly, most of the new states since the end of WWII weren't formed by leaving a federation—they just appeared. Even if Catalonia were a federal unit (which it isn't), that doesn't mean they have an automatic right to break away.
International law is pretty clear: it sides with the central government unless the country's constitution explicitly allows for secession. So, bottom line? Catalonia has absolutely no right to independence.

California is just an autonomous province within Spain, and the international law you're bringing up says every nation has the right to self-determination...
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
velvetmaker3 said:Californians aren't occupied.

What "right to self-determination" are we even talking about?

Do you honestly think it works automatically? Like, you're a people, so suddenly you get a referendum?

Do Native Americans have a right to self-determination within the US? What about indigenous tribes in the Amazon? Or in Australia? It doesn't work like that.

The accuracy of this news is highly questionable. For all we know, those could be empty ballots pulled before the vote, or they could have manipulated the whole process themselves. This was a referendum in name only, basically a sham election similar to what happened in the breakaway regions of Eastern Europe.

Oh yeah, the "guaranteed right" by the United Nations. Real smooth.

It’s not automatic, sure, but a referendum is a pretty nice, peaceful way to express that self-determination. If you don't want a vote, I guess you can always go with armed conflict or brute force...

I've been reading your posts on this thread and honestly, you're just hating on everything constantley.
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
The whole massive wave of building modern nation-states didn't even really kick off until after WWII—and honestly, not even right when the war ended...

It’s definitely not some "ancient, dusty relic" or anything like that.
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
That whole economic argument for secession isn't exactly hitting the mark...

If you're loaded, you'll claim you're paying more into the federal budget than you ever see back...
But if you're broke? Then it's all about being exploited—the government is just bleeding you dry...
California Discussion Thread - All in one place in European Union ·
The Democratic Party really should've sent over a whole international brigade just to show some solidarity with the Californians 😁
...
Jonathan Mendoza17 said:Well, being irrational is quite human! And I do wish people would at least pause to think. This whole "pulling the handbrake, spinning 180 degrees, and reversing" vibe? That’s exactly what Trump represents—he is the pure product of irrationality. Just look at the US election cycle; it’s the ultimate proof. They focus so much on Hillary that they push her as the only alternative, seemingly forgetting to rationally evaluate who Trump actually is or if there’s any substance behind his promises. And frankly, many of those promises are nonsense that only lead us backward. Moving manufacturing to China made goods accessible to the masses, sure, but now things are shifting again. On top of that, pushing certain groups out of the country is totally counterproductive—it fuels racist thinking and drives away productive people. You have plenty of lawyers, doctors, and hardworking, exemplary individuals among the Mexican community and others. Meanwhile, you certainly find criminals among immigrants from Europe too. I read just yesterday that Germany has already employed 50,000 refugees. Most of them aren't criminals or extremists; they're just regular people who were pillars of their own societies and are fleeing war. They're simply trying to save their lives, much like people fled from here during the war years. Trump, Farage, and the rest are just reopening old wounds to exploit the situation. It almost seems like Trump doesn't even want to be President or know what he'd do with America; he just ran to prove he could.

Brexit is an even better example of irrationality. Literally the day after the vote, voters start changing their minds, claiming they were misled or fell for media misinformation. Their reasoning was that foreigners were taking their jobs, yet in the end, they won't actually kick the foreigners out—they'll just lose jobs because so many companies will pull out of the VB to stay in the EU.

Liberalism has brought so much benefit to the modern world, and the ideology is mostly sound. People forget that we have never lived this well before; the problems we face didn't spring from liberalism, they've always been here—liberals just haven't found the fix yet. The conservatives coming up now are just trying to drag us back to the end of the last century. We've seen all their ideas and methods before, and we rejected them with disgust. As for their economics? It's just throwing sand in people's eyes; conservatives don't offer anything truly different from the status quo. Their real program is just attacking human rights and pushing for isolation. Conservatives can't make a "step forward" because they never actually took one—that's the very definition of conservative, isn't it? Being against change. In fact, that's the crux of it: conservatives never accepted the changes liberals brought, and now they just want to dismantle them. That isn't progress; it's a retreat.

Man, where did the beginning go? 🤦
Are you planning on labeling everything you disagree with as "irrational"?? Someone who spent decades voting Democrat (like the working class in the Rust Belt) and saw zero benefits—or even direct harm—is now deciding to try Trump. For them, things couldn't get worse, so they're just trying something different. You're acting like it's written in the stars that everyone should aim for these specific liberal values, like it's some ultimate goal for humanity. It's definitely not a universal truth, not even in the West, let alone the rest of the world. And that liberalism "that gave us so much good"? It also brought us wars in the Middle East. This constant propaganda about "universal values" like freedom and democracy is nonsense. We've tried forcing Western-style democracy on countries where it clearly doesn't work using guns and bombs. The result? Failed states and massive migration waves.
We’ve been over this whole Trump and Mexican situation a million times already—he’s talking about the criminals hiding in the migrant groups who need to be deported, but those liberal media outlets just won't stop spinning it...
You’re out here talking about refugees "just fleeing war." Please. They wouldn't be running if it weren't for people like Hillary Clinton and that whole agenda of forcing liberal values on everyone under the guise of "saving" the Middle East.
And don't even get me started on your takes regarding conservatism—it’s honestly painful how little you actually know. Just curious, though... who were the biggest political heavyweights in 20th-century Europe? Which parties did they represent, what were their core values, or who gave the UK its first female Prime Minister and Germany its first female Chancellor? It definitely wasn't the liberals!