Forum etiquette and conduct rules on Politika
in Feedback & Suggestions ·
Jose White23 said:I can't really reply without addressing this. Generally speaking, you aren't allowed to post stuff with titles like that here. But we're talking about people from a political party—both current and former—where every single leader has branded themselves as some kind of ultra-nationalist warlord.
I wasn't just talking about the headlines, I meant the general vibe of how people talk on this forum. Like saying Tom Lantos is an extremist, or that Joe Biden's crowd are all extremists (drawing a parallel there to the Libertarian Party, which you already touched on), or calling Barack Obama some shaved-head extremist, and so on. As for the headlines, sure, I agree. I just haven't noticed them popping up in titles that often.
jadeseal4 said:The title didn't need changing because it was true, which makes it fine.
That extremist ideology has been shamefully rehabilitated in Mexico.
Donald Trump still openly pushes the idea of expanding Mexican borders.
You changed the title diplomatically enough, but there was no need to play nice this time.
I'm not trying to move this debate over to some other subforum, so I'll just say this: a headline needs to actually be informative. A title like "Extremist gives up on America" tells a random person absolutely nothing when they first see it. It doesn't give away the context. Even now, after the change, it’s still pretty vague.
First off, we don't even know who this "extremist warlord" is. Second, even if we did, we wouldn't know which collaborator we're talking about. Third, what does gives up actually mean? In what sense? Is he never stepping foot in America again? Did he give up on certain borders? 😕 The headline still says zero. 🤷
A decent, informative headline would have been something like "Donald Trump skips the anniversary in Memphis."