#181 ·
@seka
That would certainly eliminate any chance of manipulation, though it introduces two entirely new headaches.
1. Tournament logistics. Under the current framework, we know exactly which groups cross over and how the brackets work ahead of time, which makes organizing everything much smoother.
2. The risk of two teams from the same group facing off too early in the knockout stage. With the present system, you won't run into a group mate until the semifinals at the earliest.
Assuming for a moment that point number one isn't an issue (meaning the specific way groups cross over doesn't actually matter), your proposal could be tweaked like this:
We create every possible combination where the first round matchups follow a pattern like 1st vs 4th and 3rd vs 2nd, while still ensuring that teams from the same group can't meet before the semifinals. There should be more than one valid combination.
Assign a unique number to each of these combinations (each representing a different bracket scheme) and put those numbers into a hat.
Once the group stage wraps up, a lucky lady pulls a number out of the hat, the matchups are instantly set, the entire format through to the finals is determined, and that’s that.
That would certainly eliminate any chance of manipulation, though it introduces two entirely new headaches.
1. Tournament logistics. Under the current framework, we know exactly which groups cross over and how the brackets work ahead of time, which makes organizing everything much smoother.
2. The risk of two teams from the same group facing off too early in the knockout stage. With the present system, you won't run into a group mate until the semifinals at the earliest.
Assuming for a moment that point number one isn't an issue (meaning the specific way groups cross over doesn't actually matter), your proposal could be tweaked like this:
We create every possible combination where the first round matchups follow a pattern like 1st vs 4th and 3rd vs 2nd, while still ensuring that teams from the same group can't meet before the semifinals. There should be more than one valid combination.
Assign a unique number to each of these combinations (each representing a different bracket scheme) and put those numbers into a hat.
Once the group stage wraps up, a lucky lady pulls a number out of the hat, the matchups are instantly set, the entire format through to the finals is determined, and that’s that.