Dennis Hall41 said:Of course he is. Mann is a total master of atmosphere, especially when things get dark at night. Just look at those nighttime scenes in L.A. during Heat, or that general vibe in Manhunter.
One more thing—since you brought up his work with actors, I’d say he has this incredible knack for highlighting the beauty of his cast, or at least their most striking physical traits.
Think about Amy Brennemann and Diane Venora in Heat, or even how Al Pacino and Robert De Niro looked more glamorous in the 70s than ever before. Then there's Susan Sarandon and Daniel Day-Lewis in The Last of the Mohicans, the whole crew in Manhunter—especially that quirky wife and weird son from Willow—and the entire cast of Miami Vice, which is such an underrated flick...
Yeah, but look—he builds that atmosphere specifically by leaning on the actors and making sure the audience actually gives a damn about the characters.
Take Heat, for example. That movie would never have been as good or as atmospheric if he hadn't managed to flesh out and characterize every single person in that lineup. He pulls off this brilliant move where he shows the killers and robbers in these private moments, dealing with real problems and desires, and that's where the atmosphere comes from. You get atmosphere when you actually care about what's happening, not when the villains are just cardboard cutouts getting shot at the end of the movie.
Even that massive final showdown on the streets—it only works because you don't see just some robber, killer, or cop in every character; you see actual flesh-and-blood people with real personalities. If he had just focused on the technical side of things, it wouldn't have hit nearly as hard.
It feels like you and I are saying the exact same thing, just from different angles, Dennis Hall41. 🙂
True, I'm with you on Miami Vice. It feels like the movie paid too much homage to the TV show, so everyone assumed they were the same thing, when really, they aren't even close.