#41 ·
Daniel Ward87 said:That’s a total lie.
The guy got banned because he made a burner account just to stir the pot over in Politics. I told him straight up that he couldn't post here using that specific handle, so he's more than welcome to make a new one. But if he keeps posting the exact same stuff, he's going to get banned regardless of what his username is.
Nice makes a fair point; if he had picked a different name, he might not have been flagged immediately, but with posts like those, he would’ve caught a moderator's eye pretty fast anyway, and the result would be identical.
@Nicholas King - look, I don't owe anyone an explanation for everything. As an admin, I have certain tools at my disposal, and I use them when they make sense, in coordination with the rest of the mod team. It’s tough when so much of the actual conversation happens in private messages, leaving you guys seeing only half the story, which leads to a lot of wrong conclusions. I don't need to air all that out here, and even if I wanted to, I can't because I won't leak private info.
Personally, I couldn't care less about him; the actual issue here is the whole debate over prohibited usernames. I wouldn't even be chiming in if it weren't for your explanation for the ban—to paraphrase: "Using 'Marshall Party' as a handle is out, go study some American history from 1945 to 1995." Come on, guys, let's not play games. Just explain the ban to him clearly, the way Nice would, and call it a day, without all these unnecessary history lessons or banning people based solely on their handle (which is really the impression you give, thanks to your posts over at KZB).
@Byron — yeah, I’m not obligated to explain everything. As an admin, I have certain tools at my disposal that I use whenever I deem it appropriate, in consultation with the other moderators. It's a real headache when so much of the communication happens via private message, leaving us with only a fraction of the story visible here, which often leads to people jumping to the wrong conclusions. I don't have to air that data here, and even if I wanted to, I couldn't because I can't just leak private information.
To make a long story short, nobody is stopping (or are they?) new users from creating an account called "Marshall lives forever" and posting on the Forum, even in threads about Marshall. They could be the most polite and constructive members we have. They'll be judged strictly on their actions, just like everyone else.