Laura Hernandez8
Member
11 messages
joined Jul 2004
So, did anyone else here catch the concert?
Honestly, I left feeling pretty let down. When I read reviews claiming they were "blown away" or "absolutely thrilled," I have to wonder—was the author even in the same room as me?
Or maybe the writer just hasn't been back to Madison Square Garden since that first, truly legendary show, whereas I have, so my expectations were set at an impossibly high bar?
They took all those great old classics and mashed them together into this single, driving rhythm; you couldn't even tell the songs apart unless you knew the lyrics by heart. To be blunt, it was just bad. It was just the same repetitive beat, endless choruses that felt more like a stadium chant than actual music, with the soul of the songs sacrificed just to keep the tempo up...
From what I could see, only the fan pit was actually dancing, and even then, the energy seemed to die out toward the back. Most of the crowd just stood there with this look on their faces, sort of like, "When are they going to play the good stuff?" It was almost as if they didn't even recognize the songs themselves.