#1 ·
I figured I’d move this thread over from the old PBS forums and drop it here too—just wanted to see what you all think about it...
As someone who’s been obsessed with Formula 1 for what feels like forever—I mean, I’m staring down my 30th year of following this sport—the start of a new season always hits me right in the feels. It feels like the perfect moment to sit down and actually process my thoughts on where F1 stands today. Specifically, I want to talk about its relationship with the very people who make the whole thing worth watching in the first place... you know, us fans.
So, setting aside the fact that it was just the first race of the new season—which, mind you, was hyped up as one of the most spectacular events in history—what we actually got was (let’s be honest, just like most races over the last decade) a total snooze fest. It was boring from start to finish. Just a long line of cars driving in a procession, stuck in machines where overtaking feels almost impossible. Even if you're in the fastest car on the grid, trying to pass someone who's three or four seconds slower per lap is basically a lost cause. The only "exciting" moments were the usual suspects: the start, the first corner, and someone making a move through the pits. And all those new regulations? Including that rule about being forced to use two different tire compounds? They didn't do a single thing to actually improve the quality of the racing. And that's saying something, because this track actually allows for real racing! It makes me pretty nervous thinking about what the upcoming races in Malaysia, Los Angeles, Monaco, and especially Canada are going to look like... honestly, I can already tell they'll probably be just as unwatchable.
Let me circle back to what actually triggered me to write this whole thing in the first place. I have to be honest—the thing that gets under my skin more than anything else is that feeling of being totally ripped off. And lately, if I'm being real, I find myself linking that feeling almost exclusively to Formula 1.
I honestly cannot wrap my head around it—it’s just baffling. You’d think that what should be the absolute pinnacle of the sports experience, especially when you're watching everything through TV or streaming online, would be presented much better than this. It’s just... underwhelming, to say the least.
The race broadcasts lately have been absolutely terrible—and I’m not even talking about PBS here, I mean the actual Formula 1 management that owns the rights. It’s honestly frustrating how often they miss the most critical moments; sometimes the biggest moves happen and the cameras aren't even pointed in that direction. Then there's the issue with Friday practice sessions... good luck finding those on any decent satellite provider unless you're willing to pay those absurdly overpriced subscription fees. Thankfully, we have some absolute legends out there who basically sacrifice their own bandwidth just so we can catch bits of the action through various overseas streaming sites. And don't even get me started on the graphics. The technical analysis overlays during qualifying and the races themselves are so rare, and when they actually do show up? Man, they look straight-up embarrassing.
Some people will probably argue, "Hey, we have live timing right there on the official Formula 1 website." Yeah, well—the live timing during this race was anything but accurate. We had wrong sector times, wrong final lap times, and absolutely zero live commentary to actually explain what was going on. So, I figured, let's see what else this site can offer us. The latest news? Not really... Maybe you want to download a quick highlight reel or even a full replay of the race or qualifying sessions? No, of course not. You won't find that on the official site of this massive corporate giant. Because, heaven forbid, they'd risk losing a few million dollars just to cater to fanatics like us.
Anyway, the main thing is that we can check this page to see exactly how long we have to wait—it looks like there are 13 days, 2 hours, 5 minutes, and three seconds until the next race...
Like most other petrolheads out there—I’m guessing I'm not alone in that, right?—I follow quite a few different branches of motorsport. That includes the infamous NASCAR, which I want to focus on specifically here. Now, I'm not trying to get into a whole debate about whether NASCAR races are more "exciting" than Formula 1—that’s kind of an apples-to-oranges comparison if you ask me—but what I really want to talk about is the actual experience NASCAR provides for its fans...
After that massive viewership crash NASCAR dealt with back in the early nineties, they completely overhauled how they connect with their fans—because, let’s be honest, without an audience, the whole sport is pretty much pointless. And honestly? That’s exactly what we’re seeing play out with Formula 1 right now.
What on earth happened during those ten years? Seriously—where did the time go?
You can catch every single tiny detail of these races live on any of the major national networks—we're talking Fox, ABC, Speed, or ESPN... you name it. Honestly, the broadcasts are absolutely mind-blowing. If you haven't sat down to watch one yet, you are seriously missing out—you really have to see it for yourself (I actually have a list of upcoming races if anyone’s interested!). The graphics they use during the coverage are just fantastic, and the commentators? Truly incredible.
If you haven't checked out the official NASCAR website yet, do yourself a favor and head over there to compare it to the Formula 1 site. Honestly, I don't even feel like I need to weigh in here...
But, since I’m the type of person who actually travels to see these races in person, I figured I’d offer a little side-by-side comparison for those of you interested.
Formula 1:
The ticket prices are just absurd—it’s honestly no wonder half the races during the season look pretty empty. They also ditched that Sunday morning warm-up session I used to love so much... and if nothing else, for the price we pay, you’d expect better seating. I paid $270 for a seat and still felt like I was fighting for every second of sound and smell from the cars. As for fan activities? There’s basically nothing. Just a bunch of vendor stalls selling cheap junk and not much else.
Getting to the track is usually a total disaster, too. Back in 2005, I decided to take a bus to an event in a random US city—I can't even remember which one—and they had the bus parking organized about six miles away from the actual circuit. It was unbelievable. And getting near the drivers? Forget about it. Access is almost impossible because heaven forbid anyone actually tries to get an autograph or have a quick chat with one of those prima donnas...
NASCAR:
The ticket prices are way more reasonable, and the races are almost always sold out. For example, if you want a ticket for a small oval race in Bristol next week... you'd probably have to wait four years in line. I'm shocked!
At every single race (usually on Thursdays), they organize a pit walk where fans can actually stroll right onto the track and through the garages. The drivers are incredibly down-to-earth and friendly, too—you can actually meet them at every race since they schedule regular autograph sessions. Some people might say, "Well, that's because not many people attend live," but I won't get too bogged down in the numbers. Just look at this: last week in Las Vegas there were 140,000 spectators (just on Sunday!), Daytona had 170,000+, and Indianapolis saw over 250,000... essentially, just five NASCAR races equal the entire seasonal attendance of Formula 1 combined.
Anyway, sorry for the rant, but why not? I'm really curious to hear what you all think about the current state of Formula 1. How can they make it actually interesting again?
Because, let's be honest, with every new rule the FIA introduces, we'll soon find ourselves cheering for some 800cc four-cylinder go-karts cruising along at 75 miles/h in a pre-determined order on a track covered in speed bumps—all just to make sure our precious $50 billion ballerinas don't get a tiny little scratch on their paint jobs...
PS... I would actually love to hear what someone like a veteran TV producer would think about this, especially since they spent years working in high-level Formula 1 production if I remember correctly...
As someone who’s been obsessed with Formula 1 for what feels like forever—I mean, I’m staring down my 30th year of following this sport—the start of a new season always hits me right in the feels. It feels like the perfect moment to sit down and actually process my thoughts on where F1 stands today. Specifically, I want to talk about its relationship with the very people who make the whole thing worth watching in the first place... you know, us fans.
So, setting aside the fact that it was just the first race of the new season—which, mind you, was hyped up as one of the most spectacular events in history—what we actually got was (let’s be honest, just like most races over the last decade) a total snooze fest. It was boring from start to finish. Just a long line of cars driving in a procession, stuck in machines where overtaking feels almost impossible. Even if you're in the fastest car on the grid, trying to pass someone who's three or four seconds slower per lap is basically a lost cause. The only "exciting" moments were the usual suspects: the start, the first corner, and someone making a move through the pits. And all those new regulations? Including that rule about being forced to use two different tire compounds? They didn't do a single thing to actually improve the quality of the racing. And that's saying something, because this track actually allows for real racing! It makes me pretty nervous thinking about what the upcoming races in Malaysia, Los Angeles, Monaco, and especially Canada are going to look like... honestly, I can already tell they'll probably be just as unwatchable.
Let me circle back to what actually triggered me to write this whole thing in the first place. I have to be honest—the thing that gets under my skin more than anything else is that feeling of being totally ripped off. And lately, if I'm being real, I find myself linking that feeling almost exclusively to Formula 1.
I honestly cannot wrap my head around it—it’s just baffling. You’d think that what should be the absolute pinnacle of the sports experience, especially when you're watching everything through TV or streaming online, would be presented much better than this. It’s just... underwhelming, to say the least.
The race broadcasts lately have been absolutely terrible—and I’m not even talking about PBS here, I mean the actual Formula 1 management that owns the rights. It’s honestly frustrating how often they miss the most critical moments; sometimes the biggest moves happen and the cameras aren't even pointed in that direction. Then there's the issue with Friday practice sessions... good luck finding those on any decent satellite provider unless you're willing to pay those absurdly overpriced subscription fees. Thankfully, we have some absolute legends out there who basically sacrifice their own bandwidth just so we can catch bits of the action through various overseas streaming sites. And don't even get me started on the graphics. The technical analysis overlays during qualifying and the races themselves are so rare, and when they actually do show up? Man, they look straight-up embarrassing.
Some people will probably argue, "Hey, we have live timing right there on the official Formula 1 website." Yeah, well—the live timing during this race was anything but accurate. We had wrong sector times, wrong final lap times, and absolutely zero live commentary to actually explain what was going on. So, I figured, let's see what else this site can offer us. The latest news? Not really... Maybe you want to download a quick highlight reel or even a full replay of the race or qualifying sessions? No, of course not. You won't find that on the official site of this massive corporate giant. Because, heaven forbid, they'd risk losing a few million dollars just to cater to fanatics like us.
Anyway, the main thing is that we can check this page to see exactly how long we have to wait—it looks like there are 13 days, 2 hours, 5 minutes, and three seconds until the next race...
Like most other petrolheads out there—I’m guessing I'm not alone in that, right?—I follow quite a few different branches of motorsport. That includes the infamous NASCAR, which I want to focus on specifically here. Now, I'm not trying to get into a whole debate about whether NASCAR races are more "exciting" than Formula 1—that’s kind of an apples-to-oranges comparison if you ask me—but what I really want to talk about is the actual experience NASCAR provides for its fans...
After that massive viewership crash NASCAR dealt with back in the early nineties, they completely overhauled how they connect with their fans—because, let’s be honest, without an audience, the whole sport is pretty much pointless. And honestly? That’s exactly what we’re seeing play out with Formula 1 right now.
What on earth happened during those ten years? Seriously—where did the time go?
You can catch every single tiny detail of these races live on any of the major national networks—we're talking Fox, ABC, Speed, or ESPN... you name it. Honestly, the broadcasts are absolutely mind-blowing. If you haven't sat down to watch one yet, you are seriously missing out—you really have to see it for yourself (I actually have a list of upcoming races if anyone’s interested!). The graphics they use during the coverage are just fantastic, and the commentators? Truly incredible.
If you haven't checked out the official NASCAR website yet, do yourself a favor and head over there to compare it to the Formula 1 site. Honestly, I don't even feel like I need to weigh in here...
But, since I’m the type of person who actually travels to see these races in person, I figured I’d offer a little side-by-side comparison for those of you interested.
Formula 1:
The ticket prices are just absurd—it’s honestly no wonder half the races during the season look pretty empty. They also ditched that Sunday morning warm-up session I used to love so much... and if nothing else, for the price we pay, you’d expect better seating. I paid $270 for a seat and still felt like I was fighting for every second of sound and smell from the cars. As for fan activities? There’s basically nothing. Just a bunch of vendor stalls selling cheap junk and not much else.
Getting to the track is usually a total disaster, too. Back in 2005, I decided to take a bus to an event in a random US city—I can't even remember which one—and they had the bus parking organized about six miles away from the actual circuit. It was unbelievable. And getting near the drivers? Forget about it. Access is almost impossible because heaven forbid anyone actually tries to get an autograph or have a quick chat with one of those prima donnas...
NASCAR:
The ticket prices are way more reasonable, and the races are almost always sold out. For example, if you want a ticket for a small oval race in Bristol next week... you'd probably have to wait four years in line. I'm shocked!
At every single race (usually on Thursdays), they organize a pit walk where fans can actually stroll right onto the track and through the garages. The drivers are incredibly down-to-earth and friendly, too—you can actually meet them at every race since they schedule regular autograph sessions. Some people might say, "Well, that's because not many people attend live," but I won't get too bogged down in the numbers. Just look at this: last week in Las Vegas there were 140,000 spectators (just on Sunday!), Daytona had 170,000+, and Indianapolis saw over 250,000... essentially, just five NASCAR races equal the entire seasonal attendance of Formula 1 combined.
Anyway, sorry for the rant, but why not? I'm really curious to hear what you all think about the current state of Formula 1. How can they make it actually interesting again?
Because, let's be honest, with every new rule the FIA introduces, we'll soon find ourselves cheering for some 800cc four-cylinder go-karts cruising along at 75 miles/h in a pre-determined order on a track covered in speed bumps—all just to make sure our precious $50 billion ballerinas don't get a tiny little scratch on their paint jobs...
PS... I would actually love to hear what someone like a veteran TV producer would think about this, especially since they spent years working in high-level Formula 1 production if I remember correctly...