CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Lifestyle › Health › Meal replacement pills: Do they actually work?

Meal replacement pills: Do they actually work?

Started by Sophia Parker4 · · 👁 5 views · 37 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Sophia Parker4Ashley Moore8placidrangerMelissa Price6Larry Lewis2feralbadger8placidfalconcrimsonpuma48Dennis White9nimbledriver81Larry Cruz51Lisa Moore7silverharbor81steelsailor17Edward GreenmistybisonMatthew Ramirez3Douglas Ramos2quietpilot87Benjamin Richardson8Jeremy Carter3Christian Williams5swiftmason8stormyheron4 …
Lisa Moore7 Lisa Moore7 Member
35 messages
joined Feb 2007
#21 ·
Yeah, she’s kinda sketched out about it, and honestly, same. Could easily do more harm than good...
As for the workouts—it’s just building muscle at this point. She’s been running, I think, maybe jogging still, but she’s just getting super ripped while her weight stays the same.

silverharbor81, can you break down what these supplements actually are?
Edward Green Edward Green Regular
335 messages
joined Sep 2008
#22 ·
She’s got 20 or 30 pounds to lose and thinks weight loss pills are the answer? Maybe she should try some aspirin for that headache instead.
And look, sorry for being skeptical, but... if she's hitting the cardio regularly, watching her macros, and gaining muscle while the fat just sits there, then she needs to go see some doctors who would probably love to write a whole damn dissertation on her case.
mistybison mistybison Regular
495 messages
joined Aug 2008
#23 ·
I have my doubts about these quick fixes. A close friend of mine was always a bit heavier growing up, so around age 20, she decided to try some weight loss pills. She did lose quite a bit of weight, but because the drop was so rapid and wasn't paired with any exercise, her skin just couldn't keep up with her changing body shape. It left her with significant sagging, particularly around the chest area. They told her that plastic surgery would be her only real option to fix it.
I remember being at a local gym once when some women asked the trainers about those specific pills; the consensus there was that you should never take them without intense physical activity and strict medical supervision. Personally, I believe that any healthy individual—provided they don't have underlying hormonal issues—can transform their physique through disciplined nutrition and regular exercise. I've seen this work successfully many times. The general rule is that weight management is roughly 60% diet and 40% exercise, with cardio being the most vital component for burning fat—think cycling, the treadmill, running, brisk walking, or the elliptical. If someone stays active but continues to eat high-calorie meals at home, consuming more than they burn, they might build muscle underneath, but the fat will remain.
silverharbor81 silverharbor81 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jun 2006
#24 ·
Jumping in here regarding the L-carnitine question.
L-carnitine is an amino acid already in our bodies, just usually not enough of it. To put it simply, it helps burn fat for energy. You should take it at least thirty minutes before working out—liquid is better for this—so your muscles actually use that fat as fuel. It’s not harmful; you find the most of it in beef. I took 1000mg ampoules from MuscleTech for 30 days, dropped some fat, and didn't gain a single pound back. You can read more details at
Some people suggest taking 500mg twice a day, but in my experience, one 1000mg dose right before training works best—like hitting the stationary bike for half an hour before moving to the machines.
Just keep in mind your body adapts to the dosage, so if you don't take a break for at least two months, you'll end up needing higher and higher doses to see anything.
As for CLA, those are essential fatty acids used to pull energy from fat stores too. It's harder to pin down the perfect daily dose since it depends on your weight, age, and activity level; if you don't hit about 3000mg a day, you won't see any effect. Of course, you still have to work out, work out, work out—cycling is your best bet. Besides those supplements, try Tone 'N Tighten. It’s a blend of L-carnitine and herbs like uva ursi that help with weight loss and cellulite. You need to use it for at least three months alongside exercise. I used it for two years, along with three friends, and the cellulite vanished, plus we didn't regain the weight. You could drop up to 18 pounds by summer. So, pick one and see what works for you.
You can find all these supplements at .
Good luck with the weight loss. Later.
Matthew Ramirez3 Matthew Ramirez3 Newcomer
2 messages
joined May 2007
#25 ·
If anyone happens to have some actual intel on this weight loss supplement, I’d certainly appreciate it!
Douglas Ramos2 Douglas Ramos2 Active Member
79 messages
joined Jan 2011
#26 ·
Look, there’s no such thing as a magic weight-loss pill... seriously, people.😎 It really just comes down to eating less and moving more... basic math. I don't know why this is still such a debate.
quietpilot87 quietpilot87 Active Member
149 messages
joined Sep 2008
#27 ·
Honestly, if overweight people didn't exist, none of these weight-loss drugs would even be a thing.
Matthew Ramirez3 Matthew Ramirez3 Newcomer
2 messages
joined May 2007
#28 ·
So, I guess I misunderstood. I was actually expecting some actual experiences or maybe even a list of side effects...!
Douglas Ramos2 Douglas Ramos2 Active Member
79 messages
joined Jan 2011
#29 ·
Matthew Ramirez3 said:So, I guess I misunderstood. I was actually expecting some actual experiences or maybe even a list of side effects...!

But honestly, what's the point if they don't even work? You'd just be someone popping pills for nothing.🤣
quietpilot87 quietpilot87 Active Member
149 messages
joined Sep 2008
#30 ·
Maybe some big shot he knows is popping them, and he's just terrified of the fallout if things go south? 😁
Benjamin Richardson8 Benjamin Richardson8 Newcomer
1 message
joined Mar 2008
#31 ·
Has anyone here actually tried these weight loss pills? I’m curious if there’s any real substance to the results, and more importantly, what the actual mechanism behind them is... 😕 Generally speaking, which supplements would you recommend for a bit of extra help with weight management? For context, my diet is solid and I stay active with regular workouts 🙂 My biggest concern, though, is whether these—or any similar supplements—could actually be detrimental to my health in the long run 🤷 For instance, if we’re essentially forcing our metabolism to ramp up via stimulants, is there a risk that once the pills are out of our system, everything just crashes? I worry about the body becoming "dependent" on that artificial boost, potentially leading to even more weight gain once the supplement stops working its magic and things return to baseline...
Jeremy Carter3 Jeremy Carter3 Newcomer
1 message
joined Mar 2008
#32 ·
I am honestly so over these weight loss pills. I’ve tried every single gimmick under the sun, and let me tell you—nothing actually worked. If you’re serious about dropping pounds, just stick to a clean diet and hit the gym. I know, I know, I'm preaching to the choir here, but that is literally the only way to 😁
Christian Williams5 Christian Williams5 Newcomer
4 messages
joined Feb 2008
#33 ·
I’d really appreciate it if anyone who has actually tried those Tonalin CLA ULTRA weight loss pills
from DietPharma could share their experience. Thanks.
swiftmason8 swiftmason8 Newcomer
5 messages
joined May 2008
#34 ·
Christian Williams5 said:I’d really appreciate it if anyone who has actually tried those Tonalin CLA ULTRA weight loss pills
from DietPharma could share their experience. Thanks.

I haven't personally tried them, but I'm pretty sure they're just a waste of money...
I mean, don't get me wrong, they might work, but without a solid diet and some actual exercise? Nothing happens.
It would be nice if we could all just feast on greasy burgers and fries and then pop a pill to erase it all, wouldn't it?
But the reality is that losing weight always requires some level of sacrifice.
Good luck out there...
Christian Williams5 Christian Williams5 Newcomer
4 messages
joined Feb 2008
#35 ·
swiftmason8 said:I haven't personally tried them, but I'm pretty sure they're just a waste of money...
I mean, don't get me wrong, they might work, but without a solid diet and some actual exercise? Nothing happens.
It would be nice if we could all just feast on greasy burgers and fries and then pop a pill to erase it all, wouldn't it?
But the reality is that losing weight always requires some level of sacrifice.
Good luck out there...

Mladenkica looks great, especially in black and white.
stormyheron4 stormyheron4 Active Member
86 messages
joined Aug 2009
#36 ·
I’ve been stacking CLA with my running routine, and I managed to drop about 5.5 pounds in just a month. Obviously, you have to stick to a solid diet and stay consistent if you actually want to see results. To be real, CLA is just a little extra boost. The heavy lifting comes from cardio and eating right if you're trying to lean out. From what I’ve gathered, CLA helps preserve muscle mass and keeps the fat from creeping back on quite as fast, while giving your weight loss a tiny nudge. It’s honestly the only supplement I’ve ever heard of that actually does something, but don't go thinking you can just pop some CLA and magically melt away without doing the work.
Nathan Campbell4 Nathan Campbell4 Newcomer
7 messages
joined Sep 2011
#37 ·
I’ve tried both versions—the standard one first, then the Forte. To be clear, I was just carrying a few extra pounds from the winter months; nothing serious like blood pressure or heart issues, just some extra weight. I figured I’d try using this to slim down, but honestly? It did absolutely nothing. I barely lost a couple of pounds. And I was following the instructions to a T—eating light, staying active, getting fresh air, exercising, and taking the Tonalin Forte on top of it all, but it just didn't work out the way I expected.

So, I ended up doing what I think was actually the smartest move: mixing things up with yoga, some Pilates, and a bit of aerobics whenever I can. I take the stairs instead of the elevator or driving, I stay moving, I cut out soda entirely, and while I still eat sweets occasionally, it’s very rare. Now, with plenty of fruits and veggies in my diet, I feel like I'm finally in peak shape.😁

Somehow, the geniuses behind Tonalin claimed you get the best results after using it for several months. Yeah, right... don't bother. It's just a waste of money.

If someone is dealing with actual weight issues, like clinical obesity and stuff, they should stick to real medication and a diet prescribed by a doctor or whatever specialist handles that field.
stormyjackal46 stormyjackal46 Member
44 messages
joined Aug 2009
#38 ·
Look, just be careful if you're thinking about trying Tonalin. My aunt took it for about a month and ended up with these weird, painful lumps popping up all over her legs. They wouldn't go away, no matter what. Since she’s a nurse, she immediately started spiraling through a million different diagnoses, but it turned out they were definitely caused by the supplement. Even with medication, she didn't see much improvement. I think somewhere online it mentions that Tonalin can trigger this—I can't remember the exact medical term, but trust me, it's not a good time.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads