CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Lifestyle › Health › Help interpreting knee X-ray results?

Help interpreting knee X-ray results?

Started by goldenbadger8 · · 👁 4 views · 26 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants goldenbadger8Casey Palmer5brightmarlin44Hannah Ward11ASophia Barrett66Bradley Roberts5electricmarlin29wanderingcobra76hiddenlynx48Michael Newman18Richard Hernandez64Sean PhillipsJacob LongBryan Barnes2rustyowl4Tyler Fisher20Harold Sanders3Ronald Bailey32
goldenbadger8 goldenbadger8 MemberOP
29 messages
joined Aug 2004
#1 ·
Can someone help me make sense of this?

The X-ray of my right knee shows that the joint space width is normal.
There is significant subchondral sclerosis of the articular surfaces along with narrowing of the intercondylar
eminencces.
Casey Palmer5 Casey Palmer5 Regular
470 messages
joined Jan 2016
#2 ·
It’s nothing too serious, though I'm not sure how old you are exactly.

It's just those standard changes that come with getting older—basically just some mild cartilage wear and tear...
brightmarlin44 brightmarlin44 Active Member
52 messages
joined Dec 2005
#3 ·
Look, man, you know that feeling when your knee joint—which honestly should be smooth as silk—starts feeling more like there's a handful of gravel grinding inside? Yeah, that’s the vibe. I bet yours is creaking like an old floorboard and giving you those little stabs of pain every now and then... trust me, I feel it too. It's just what happens when you hit a certain age.😁
goldenbadger8 goldenbadger8 MemberOP
29 messages
joined Aug 2004
#4 ·
It’s my dad’s issue. He’s 56 and his knee has been killing him for about a month now—walking is becoming a real struggle. Could physical therapy actually make a difference here? I’ve also heard there’s some kind of surgery to smooth out the cartilage.
Hannah Ward11 Hannah Ward11 Newcomer
7 messages
joined May 2004
#5 ·
Could physical therapy actually make a difference here? I’ve heard people talking about some kind of surgery to smooth out the cartilage too...

Yeah, I'm wondering the same thing... I'm only 26, and my knees are already giving me hell.

Does genetics play a role in this? My grandmother couldn't walk for the last 20 years of her life, and my aunt can barely bend her knees at all... maybe there's a connection.
Casey Palmer5 Casey Palmer5 Regular
470 messages
joined Jan 2016
#6 ·
At the end of the day, shaving or smoothing out the cartilage should be the absolute last resort. You really ought to try physical therapy first, as that can actually make a huge difference...

From what I can tell, a pretty large percentage of people don't see much improvement even after they have the surgery done.
A Anonymous Veteran
3.6K messages
joined May 2005
#7 ·
Casey Palmer5 said:Bottom line is, shaving down the cartilage should be your absolute last resort. You really ought to exhaust all physical therapy options first—that stuff can actually make a massive difference.

From what I’ve seen, a huge chunk of people don't end up feeling much better even after they go through with the surgery.

Going for a bike ride
but just super slow
just enough to keep things moving
so the knees stay active without taking too much strain
Sophia Barrett66 Sophia Barrett66 Newcomer
1 message
joined Mar 2009
#8 ·
Knee X-ray results

The X-ray shows bilateral stress on the medial tubercle of the intercondylar eminence in both knees, though the tibiofemoral joint spaces remain intact. The bone structures themselves appear normal.

What does this actually mean in plain English? Can anyone break this down for me?

Thanks in advance for the help 🙂
Bradley Roberts5 Bradley Roberts5 Newcomer
1 message
joined May 2010
#9 ·
I've got the exact same diagnosis... if anyone has some insight or can explain what this all actually means, please let me know 🙂
electricmarlin29 electricmarlin29 Newcomer
1 message
joined Nov 2010
#10 ·
The lumbar spine imaging shows a mild rightward deviation of the spinal axis—the vertebral bodies remain tall, though there's an initial Schmorl's lesion at the L5 level. There is increased sclerosis in the small joints of the lower third. On the AP view, a more massive transverse process of the L5 vertebra extends to the left, making direct contact with the lateral mass of the sacrum. Overall, the bone structure and mineralization look age-appropriate, and the joint spaces are well-maintained. On the profile view, the tibial tuberosity is more pronounced on the left side. 😕Could someone break this down for me? I have an appointment with my orthopedic surgeon in three weeks, but I actually had the scans done about six weeks ago... 😠 Thanks in advance...........
wanderingcobra76 wanderingcobra76 Member
44 messages
joined Nov 2010
#11 ·
electricmarlin29 said:The lumbar spine imaging shows a mild rightward deviation of the spinal axis—the vertebral bodies remain tall, though there's an initial Schmorl's lesion at the L5 level. There is increased sclerosis in the small joints of the lower third. On the AP view, a more massive transverse process of the L5 vertebra extends to the left, making direct contact with the lateral mass of the sacrum. Overall, the bone structure and mineralization look age-appropriate, and the joint spaces are well-maintained. On the profile view, the tibial tuberosity is more pronounced on the left side. 😕Could someone break this down for me? I have an appointment with my orthopedic surgeon in three weeks, but I actually had the scans done about six weeks ago... 😠 Thanks in advance...........

It isn't anything major.
The report describes some early degenerative changes—which, honestly, are quite common even in people in their 30s.
As for that more pronounced tibial tuberosity in the knee, it could simply be a physiological variation in how you developed (after all, our bodies aren't perfectly symmetrical!) or perhaps a result of extra strain on that left knee joint.
Generally speaking, these bone changes aren't particularly striking or specific enough to point toward a particular pathology.
Once you see the orthopedist, they will perform a physical exam to see if your clinical symptoms align with these imaging results; from there, they might refer you for further testing if they suspect an issue with the meniscus, ligaments, or something similar.
hiddenlynx48 hiddenlynx48 Newcomer
1 message
joined Dec 2010
#12 ·
Radiologist report:
There is some initial asymmetric narrowing of the joint spaces in the femorotibial joints on both sides, along with early subchondral sclerosis, which points toward the beginning stages of degenerative changes.
On the left side, there is mild erosion of the patellar articular surface in the patellofemoral joint, with slight subchondral sclerosis visible underneath. In the area of the distal left femoral shaft, near the mediodorsal cortex, there is a focal structural change running along the cortex about 5 cm long and 2 cm thick. This looks somewhat mottled with smooth polycystic outlines, and while its structure seems identical to the cortex, there are some sponge-like pseudocystic formations within this area. A differential diagnosis might suggest this is just the aftermath of a bone infarct, but given the patient's age, I guess an orthopedic consultation is necessary to determine if further diagnostic workup is needed.

The patient is 17 years old.
I was wondering if someone could maybe explain what this finding actually means and give me an idea of how serious the situation is.
Thanks in advance.
Michael Newman18 Michael Newman18 Member
17 messages
joined Dec 2002
#13 ·
The left knee shows a narrow joint space fissure near the pinned intercondylar eminence, which points toward moderate osteoarthritis.

Could someone please make sense of this finding for me? (It's from a knee X-ray)

I mean, I know I could just Google it—which usually doesn't help much—but I'm trying to gauge how serious this actually is, what the treatment options look like, and all that sort of thing.

Thanks so much.😍
wanderingcobra76 wanderingcobra76 Member
44 messages
joined Nov 2010
#14 ·
Michael Newman18 said:The left knee shows a narrow joint space fissure near the pinned intercondylar eminence, which points toward moderate osteoarthritis.

Could someone please make sense of this finding for me? (It's from a knee X-ray)

I mean, I know I could just Google it—which usually doesn't help much—but I'm trying to gauge how serious this actually is, what the treatment options look like, and all that sort of thing.

Thanks so much.😍

The report describes some early degenerative changes—though they are quite mild (not exactly surprising for someone in their 20s, really).
Supporting this is the narrowing of the joint space—which happens when cartilage thins out—and the sharpening of the intercondylar eminence doesn't carry much weight on its own in this specific case.
A finding like this really needs to be looked at alongside other factors—like age, weight, symptoms, and a physical exam—to determine if you just need to work on muscle strengthening or if further investigation is required to rule out pathologies that an X-ray might miss.
Richard Hernandez64 Richard Hernandez64 Newcomer
1 message
joined Dec 2013
#15 ·
The scans of my left knee show some subtle degenerative changes within the joint, specifically noting some early-stage subchondral osteosclerosis on the tibial plateau. That said, the joint space itself appears to be well-maintained.

Could someone break this down for me in plain English?
I'm also trying to gauge how much of an emergency this actually is—I'm planning to book an appointment with an orthopedist today, but based on my past experiences with the local healthcare system, I know I won't be seen for at least a few weeks. Should I just bite the bullet, go to a private clinic, and pay out of pocket right away?
Sean Phillips Sean Phillips Newcomer
2 messages
joined Mar 2012
#16 ·
wanderingcobra76 said:The report describes some early degenerative changes—though they are quite mild (not exactly surprising for someone in their 20s, really).
Supporting this is the narrowing of the joint space—which happens when cartilage thins out—and the sharpening of the intercondylar eminence doesn't carry much weight on its own in this specific case.
A finding like this really needs to be looked at alongside other factors—like age, weight, symptoms, and a physical exam—to determine if you just need to work on muscle strengthening or if further investigation is required to rule out pathologies that an X-ray might miss.


I've got something similar: Early sharpening of the medial tubercle of the intercondylar eminence. There's also an oval sclerotic zone, 8x4mm, on the distal femoral shaft.

I'm getting pretty impatient because my doctor sent me off to test for rheumatoid factor??? She claims my bones look older than I am? I'm only 27, for crying out loud.
Jacob Long Jacob Long Active Member
88 messages
joined Oct 2007
#17 ·
I'm a total wreck right now
Can anyone make sense of my mom's knee X-ray results?

Wide lateral portion of the femorotibial joint space, early osteophytosis on the upper edge of the patella. Prominent eminence intercondilaris

It’s all in block capitals, so I can't tell where one thing ends and the next begins—anyone actually follow this stuff? 🤔
Is this something we should be worried about?

She was given some 5mg Valium and Ibuprofen
And then told to come back in 15 days for more tests... what kind of tests would they even be looking at?
Bryan Barnes2 Bryan Barnes2 Member
16 messages
joined Dec 2022
#18 ·
Jacob Long said:I'm a total wreck right now
Can anyone make sense of my mom's knee X-ray results?

Wide lateral portion of the femorotibial joint space, early osteophytosis on the upper edge of the patella. Prominent eminence intercondilaris

It’s all in block capitals, so I can't tell where one thing ends and the next begins—anyone actually follow this stuff? 🤔
Is this something we should be worried about?

She was given some 5mg Valium and Ibuprofen
And then told to come back in 15 days for more tests... what kind of tests would they even be looking at?

Are the changes limited to just one knee? No issues with other joints?

This looks like gonarthrosis—essentially degenerative knee changes resulting from aging and various factors (excessive body weight is often a culprit, as are past injuries).

Which tests? Perhaps something like a rheumatoid factor test or similar—standard procedure to rule out systemic arthropathies. It is difficult to speculate on what the doctor had in mind.
Jacob Long Jacob Long Active Member
88 messages
joined Oct 2007
#19 ·
Bryan Barnes2, thanks a ton
So it’s not some huge tragedy—just aging or maybe some arthritis stuff?
Right now, it's just that one knee acting up
Weight isn't even really an issue—he's pretty much middle of the road

And she actually thinks they're going to run all these arthritis tests on her...

Do you know if those tests are pricey? And do specialists usually cover them through insurance?

Is there any way to get ahead of rheumatic issues while we're still young? I'm low-key terrified of them—given my own autoimmune struggles...

Edit: Did a little Googling and it looks like osteoarthritis fits the bill perfectly. It mentioned a knee replacement as an option, too. She hasn't actually seen a specialist yet—her GP just gave her that diagnosis based on an X-ray, which is why we were all so confused
Bryan Barnes2 Bryan Barnes2 Member
16 messages
joined Dec 2022
#20 ·
Jacob Long As expressed by:
Bryan Barnes2, thank you so much.
It isn't exactly a tragedy—it’s more likely just a matter of aging—or perhaps an issue regarding the resume.

Yes—that appears to be the case.

And she actually believes—quite sincerely, I might add—that they’re going to run those rheumatoid arthritis tests for her...

Do you happen to know if those tests are expensive—and more importantly—do cardiologists typically order them through insurance?

If a specialist has recommended the search—and I tend to trust that kind of expertise—then I don't expect the FTC to raise any red flags. Even if the costs end up being high—though, realistically, they shouldn't be, even if I can't pinpoint the exact figures right now—it should be fine.

What steps can one take to preemptively address rheumatic conditions while still young? Given my own history with autoimmune issues—which is quite a weight to carry—I find myself feeling rather anxious about the future.

Not necessarily—if the underlying cause is autoimmune—which means you won't inevitably face joint issues, regardless of the specific autoimmune conditions you're managing.
🙂

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads