Religion classes in school - Megathread

Brenda Doyle5 said:Can you see the massive flaw in that logic when you look at religious studies, Christianity, and all that preaching? Setting aside whatever nonsense goes on inside a church for a second—this stuff is taught in public schools. It’s presented as absolute truth, the only right way to think.

I'm not even going to lower myself to the level of conversation in that last post...

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy A series using Reddit

It’s honestly hilarious watching Sunday school teachers tell kids that Santa Claus isn't real—all while being completely oblivious to the irony of the whole situation. 👏

Brenda Doyle5 said:Yeah, right... especially when it comes to those self-righteous types.☕

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy A series using Reddit

I don't get it.
What exactly do you expect a preacher to say when someone asks if Santa Claus exists?
Or when they start getting all hyped up about Christmas ????

shadowcrane91 said:I don't get it.
What exactly do you expect a preacher to say when someone asks if Santa Claus exists?
Or when they start getting all hyped up about Christmas ????

Let them prove Santa doesn't exist, then let them prove that God exists.

It's actually pretty simple.

Every single faith is built on BELIEF...
It’s pretty simple... religious studies isn't exactly a place where you look for Santa Claus... so there’s zero need for anyone to prove anything... and they're totally right about that... in our faith, he just doesn't exist... any kid sitting in a Sunday school class should already know that, because that's exactly how they ought to be raised.

silentraven6 said:Let them prove Santa doesn't exist, then let them prove that God exists.

It's actually pretty simple.

Oh yeah? Then you go ahead and prove God doesn't exist...

What am I expecting here?
Look, I’d expect them to make a connection in a way that actually makes sense for kids—something like, "As Christians, we believe God is real and exists, and someone else believes Santa Claus is real and brings gifts..." You state that neither belief is "wrong." Then throw in a line or two about imagination, childhood, and fairy tales.
Whatever you do, don't just say, "Santa Claus doesn't exist, period."
Don't lie, but tailor the truth to a child's age... just like we already do when we teach them about God or Jesus.

Is that really such a big deal?

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy using Reddit

It’s not just the whole "Santa isn't real" thing—it’s also the fact that parents are basically the ones sneaking the gifts under the tree and calling it a day.
Just in case the first part of that sentence didn't already completely kill the Christmas magic for you.

shadowcrane91 said:Every single faith is built on BELIEF...
It’s pretty simple... religious studies isn't exactly a place where you look for Santa Claus... so there’s zero need for anyone to prove anything... and they're totally right about that... in our faith, he just doesn't exist... any kid sitting in a Sunday school class should already know that, because that's exactly how they ought to be raised.

But if believing in Santa is BELIEF, then isn't Catholicism basically just the study of belief? (The word itself implies it). So, technically, you should be teaching about believing in Santa too. Or is this strictly limited to Catholicism? (And where does it actually say that?)

Actually, it says 😂 the subject is listed as "Roman Catholic Religious Studies" 😉

Sarah Hall53 said:It’s not just the whole "Santa isn't real" thing—it’s also the fact that parents are basically the ones sneaking the gifts under the tree and calling it a day.
Just in case the first part of that sentence didn't already completely kill the Christmas magic for you.

The magic you're talking about just isn't part of Christian doctrine or tradition.
I don't mind adding a little flair to things for the kids, but you can't seriously expect religious ed instructors to teach the Christmas season like it's Harry Potter.

In America, Christianity serves as a major cultural identifier alongside faith, so some families send their kids to parochial school classes even if they aren't particularly religious themselves. That’s their right, obviously, but you can't be surprised when they push back against certain activities planned by the teachers.

Religious education is strictly dependent on parental consent, which has to be renewed every single school year. Deciding whether or not to enroll a child shouldn't be taken lightly.

We’ve probably gone over this for ten pages by now—honestly, I think we have—but look: just move Catholicism into the same scheduling blocks as those other two electives, and you'll see that whole "cultural identity" argument melt away faster than an ice cream cone in a Chicago summer.
And besides, parents really only weigh in during that very first enrollment—usually back in first grade—and after that, kids just stay enrolled in whatever elective they took the year before, unless a parent actually goes through the trouble of filing a formal written request to opt them out.

Jessica Kelly4 said:The magic you're talking about just isn't part of Christian doctrine or tradition.
I don't mind adding a little flair to things for the kids, but you can't seriously expect religious ed instructors to teach the Christmas season like it's Harry Potter.

In America, Christianity serves as a major cultural identifier alongside faith, so some families send their kids to parochial school classes even if they aren't particularly religious themselves. That’s their right, obviously, but you can't be surprised when they push back against certain activities planned by the teachers.

Religious education is strictly dependent on parental consent, which has to be renewed every single school year. Deciding whether or not to enroll a child shouldn't be taken lightly.

Does decorating pine trees and putting up Advent wreaths on the table and the front door count as part of the tradition too? I've always wondered how far back those customs actually go.

I can definitely see where you're coming from, though I have to disagree on one specific point. In our school system, if you opt into religion classes at the start of the year, that’s a commitment you stick with through the end of the term. It isn't really a matter of being able to just drop out because someone told you Santa Claus isn't real before the holidays roll around. It's also not about wanting to skip weekly services to avoid those repetitive roll calls, or trying to protect your GPA because your grades are taking a hit since you aren't attending Mass. Once you make that choice, you're in for the duration.

Anyway, if she’s really set on bringing up Santa Claus, she might as well say something like this:
I've been thinking about this lately, and honestly, it’s such an interesting perspective to consider. It really makes you stop and reflect on things we often take for granted.

Brenda Doyle5 said:What am I expecting here?
Look, I’d expect them to make a connection in a way that actually makes sense for kids—something like, "As Christians, we believe God is real and exists, and someone else believes Santa Claus is real and brings gifts..." You state that neither belief is "wrong." Then throw in a line or two about imagination, childhood, and fairy tales.
Whatever you do, don't just say, "Santa Claus doesn't exist, period."
Don't lie, but tailor the truth to a child's age... just like we already do when we teach them about God or Jesus.

Is that really such a big deal?

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy using Reddit

By the way, I’ve noticed that the Christmas holiday logic is being handled directly on the PID controller.
At our local music school, we’ve already started getting into the spirit by singing Christmas carols. It got me thinking—how should we go about celebrating the Christmas season at the Nature and Society Club?
What should we do about "Snowflakes are Falling," that song they play at music class? The Christmas season is getting so close, and I can already feel that Santa Claus magic starting to kick in!

Are we really going to tailor everything just to fit Catholicism, or should other kids have the right to practice their own beliefs too?

I have to agree with the idea that Catholics shouldn't really be believing in Santa Claus. It’s pretty clear-cut when you look at it from a faith perspective—there is only one God, and we aren't supposed to have any other gods alongside Him.
If I remember correctly, back when they were first introducing Catholicism into the schools in places like Chicago, they actually rebranded Santa Claus as "Santa Claus" just to be different. It was their way of sticking to tradition and doing things their own way, I guess. 🥳
So, at the end of the day, does he actually exist or not?

Sarah Hall53 said:We’ve probably gone over this for ten pages by now—honestly, I think we have—but look: just move Catholicism into the same scheduling blocks as those other two electives, and you'll see that whole "cultural identity" argument melt away faster than an ice cream cone in a Chicago summer.
And besides, parents really only weigh in during that very first enrollment—usually back in first grade—and after that, kids just stay enrolled in whatever elective they took the year before, unless a parent actually goes through the trouble of filing a formal written request to opt them out.

I sign a consent form every single year, so your claim doesn't track with my experience.
I assume this policy is standard across all schools?
Once you sign up for a subject, you're stuck with it through the end of the school year.

Btw, my kids usually have Catholicism during their first or last period; somehow they managed to work that into the schedule.

If that's the case, then your school is actually breaking the rules. Honestly, there shouldn't be any need for signing a consent form every single year—once you enroll your kid in an elective during first, fourth, or fifth grade, you're basically giving your implicit consent for them to take that class all the way through the end of elementary school. If you want out, you just have to submit a formal written request to withdraw by August 15th, and then the school board makes the final call.

Susan James said:Does decorating pine trees and putting up Advent wreaths on the table and the front door count as part of the tradition too? I've always wondered how far back those customs actually go.

I can definitely see where you're coming from, though I have to disagree on one specific point. In our school system, if you opt into religion classes at the start of the year, that’s a commitment you stick with through the end of the term. It isn't really a matter of being able to just drop out because someone told you Santa Claus isn't real before the holidays roll around. It's also not about wanting to skip weekly services to avoid those repetitive roll calls, or trying to protect your GPA because your grades are taking a hit since you aren't attending Mass. Once you make that choice, you're in for the duration.

Anyway, if she’s really set on bringing up Santa Claus, she might as well say something like this:
I've been thinking about this lately, and honestly, it’s such an interesting perspective to consider. It really makes you stop and reflect on things we often take for granted.

By the way, I’ve noticed that the Christmas holiday logic is being handled directly on the PID controller.
At our local music school, we’ve already started getting into the spirit by singing Christmas carols. It got me thinking—how should we go about celebrating the Christmas season at the Nature and Society Club?
What should we do about "Snowflakes are Falling," that song they play at music class? The Christmas season is getting so close, and I can already feel that Santa Claus magic starting to kick in!

Are we really going to tailor everything just to fit Catholicism, or should other kids have the right to practice their own beliefs too?

I have to agree with the idea that Catholics shouldn't really be believing in Santa Claus. It’s pretty clear-cut when you look at it from a faith perspective—there is only one God, and we aren't supposed to have any other gods alongside Him.
If I remember correctly, back when they were first introducing Catholicism into the schools in places like Chicago, they actually rebranded Santa Claus as "Santa Claus" just to be different. It was their way of sticking to tradition and doing things their own way, I guess. 🥳
So, at the end of the day, does he actually exist or not?

It’s not ancient history; it definitely isn't tied to the early Church.
Eventually, it just became folklore, much like how Saint Nicholas and Krampus work.
People gravitate toward this stuff. There's no stopping them.
The issue arises when the actual meaning gets buried under all that folklore or consumerism.

Susan James said:Does decorating pine trees and putting up Advent wreaths on the table and the front door count as part of the tradition too? I've always wondered how far back those customs actually go.

I can definitely see where you're coming from, though I have to disagree on one specific point. In our school system, if you opt into religion classes at the start of the year, that’s a commitment you stick with through the end of the term. It isn't really a matter of being able to just drop out because someone told you Santa Claus isn't real before the holidays roll around. It's also not about wanting to skip weekly services to avoid those repetitive roll calls, or trying to protect your GPA because your grades are taking a hit since you aren't attending Mass. Once you make that choice, you're in for the duration.

Anyway, if she’s really set on bringing up Santa Claus, she might as well say something like this:
I've been thinking about this lately, and honestly, it’s such an interesting perspective to consider. It really makes you stop and reflect on things we often take for granted.

By the way, I’ve noticed that the Christmas holiday logic is being handled directly on the PID controller.
At our local music school, we’ve already started getting into the spirit by singing Christmas carols. It got me thinking—how should we go about celebrating the Christmas season at the Nature and Society Club?
What should we do about "Snowflakes are Falling," that song they play at music class? The Christmas season is getting so close, and I can already feel that Santa Claus magic starting to kick in!

Are we really going to tailor everything just to fit Catholicism, or should other kids have the right to practice their own beliefs too?

I have to agree with the idea that Catholics shouldn't really be believing in Santa Claus. It’s pretty clear-cut when you look at it from a faith perspective—there is only one God, and we aren't supposed to have any other gods alongside Him.
If I remember correctly, back when they were first introducing Catholicism into the schools in places like Chicago, they actually rebranded Santa Claus as "Santa Claus" just to be different. It was their way of sticking to tradition and doing things their own way, I guess. 🥳
So, at the end of the day, does he actually exist or not?

"Believing" is too strong a word. Santa Claus is just like Saint Nicholas—it's a message conveyed through a picture book.

Saint Nicholas being a bishop who helped and gave gifts to children is a message rooted in Christian social teaching; it's part of growing up in the faith.

Santa Claus essentially evolved from the story of Saint Nicholas. Most people know the path from the Netherlands to Coca-Cola, but today he's just the secular counterpart to Nicholas. He's become what Christmas holidays have become in a secular sense.

says:
but wait, if believing in Santa Claus is considered BELIEF, then isn't Catholicism basically just the study of belief? (I mean, that's literally what the word implies). So, shouldn't they be teaching about the belief in Santa Claus in religion class too? Or is this strictly limited to Catholic religion classes (and where exactly does it say that?)

Look, Santa Claus is all about marketing; he's got absolutely nothing to do with actual faith or any kind of theology😉
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Claus

Sarah Hall53 said:It’s not just the whole "Santa isn't real" thing—it’s also the fact that parents are basically the ones sneaking the gifts under the tree and calling it a day.
Just in case the first part of that sentence didn't already completely kill the Christmas magic for you.

Christmas and Santa Claus aren't even in the same universe; Christmas is a Christian holiday celebrating the birth of Jesus, whereas Santa Claus is just some character cooked up to drive consumer spending...
and honestly, once people stop trying to link every single little thing to Christmas, I doubt religious instructors are going to be out here ruining anyone's holiday vibes.
And speaking of "ruining someone's vibes"—what's that supposed to mean? Are we saying the police shouldn't step in when some unstable person starts attacking someone because it might ruin their "magic"?🤣

Sarah Hall53 said:We’ve probably gone over this for ten pages by now—honestly, I think we have—but look: just move Catholicism into the same scheduling blocks as those other two electives, and you'll see that whole "cultural identity" argument melt away faster than an ice cream cone in a Chicago summer.
And besides, parents really only weigh in during that very first enrollment—usually back in first grade—and after that, kids just stay enrolled in whatever elective they took the year before, unless a parent actually goes through the trouble of filing a formal written request to opt them out.

So, where is the actual issue there? Why should teachers and staff be bogged down every single year with unnecessary paperwork just because some parent finds it too much work to write a quick note to the school before the new semester starts, letting them know their kid won't be attending religion class anymore?🤣
Do you seriously think someone who signed their kid up for religion class just "because everyone else is doing it" is actually going to go out of their way to unenroll them?🤦

Susan James said:Does decorating pine trees and putting up Advent wreaths on the table and the front door count as part of the tradition too? I've always wondered how far back those customs actually go.

I can definitely see where you're coming from, though I have to disagree on one specific point. In our school system, if you opt into religion classes at the start of the year, that’s a commitment you stick with through the end of the term. It isn't really a matter of being able to just drop out because someone told you Santa Claus isn't real before the holidays roll around. It's also not about wanting to skip weekly services to avoid those repetitive roll calls, or trying to protect your GPA because your grades are taking a hit since you aren't attending Mass. Once you make that choice, you're in for the duration.

Anyway, if she’s really set on bringing up Santa Claus, she might as well say something like this:
I've been thinking about this lately, and honestly, it’s such an interesting perspective to consider. It really makes you stop and reflect on things we often take for granted.

By the way, I’ve noticed that the Christmas holiday logic is being handled directly on the PID controller.
At our local music school, we’ve already started getting into the spirit by singing Christmas carols. It got me thinking—how should we go about celebrating the Christmas season at the Nature and Society Club?
What should we do about "Snowflakes are Falling," that song they play at music class? The Christmas season is getting so close, and I can already feel that Santa Claus magic starting to kick in!

Are we really going to tailor everything just to fit Catholicism, or should other kids have the right to practice their own beliefs too?

I have to agree with the idea that Catholics shouldn't really be believing in Santa Claus. It’s pretty clear-cut when you look at it from a faith perspective—there is only one God, and we aren't supposed to have any other gods alongside Him.
If I remember correctly, back when they were first introducing Catholicism into the schools in places like Chicago, they actually rebranded Santa Claus as "Santa Claus" just to be different. It was their way of sticking to tradition and doing things their own way, I guess. 🥳
So, at the end of the day, does he actually exist or not?

Look, during Catholic school religion classes, the teachers honestly couldn't care less whether a kid actually shows up to mass or not, let alone if they're calling kids out or docking their grades for it...
if you actually know of a teacher doing something like that, you should totally report them.
Besides, that doesn't even happen in Sunday school because the whole point of religious education isn't to force some kid to sit in a pew, right? It's about introducing them to faith and the service if they're actually interested.

but if I recall correctly, back when they were pushing religion into the public schools, they renamed Santa Claus to "Santa Claus" as some sort of local, traditionalist twist, didn't they?🥳
so, does he exist or what?

This has nothing to do with local politics; the whole rebranding of Santa Claus was just a political move because under the old regime, it was always the old-school Santa giving gifts, so anything tied to the former government was automatically labeled "out," while everything Western was deemed "in."
Actually, back in the day, the old-school Santa used to give kids gifts for New Year's, whereas the Western Santa Claus shows up on Christmas Eve, or rather, at Christmas...

By the way... those four candles on the Advent wreath actually represent specific symbols... maybe try doing a little research once in a while.

Lawrence Torres56 said:

says:
but wait, if believing in Santa Claus is considered BELIEF, then isn't Catholicism basically just the study of belief? (I mean, that's literally what the word implies). So, shouldn't they be teaching about the belief in Santa Claus in religion class too? Or is this strictly limited to Catholic religion classes (and where exactly does it say that?)

Look, Santa Claus is all about marketing; he's got absolutely nothing to do with actual faith or any kind of theology😉
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Claus

Christmas and Santa Claus aren't even in the same universe; Christmas is a Christian holiday celebrating the birth of Jesus, whereas Santa Claus is just some character cooked up to drive consumer spending...
and honestly, once people stop trying to link every single little thing to Christmas, I doubt religious instructors are going to be out here ruining anyone's holiday vibes.
And speaking of "ruining someone's vibes"—what's that supposed to mean? Are we saying the police shouldn't step in when some unstable person starts attacking someone because it might ruin their "magic"?🤣

So, where is the actual issue there? Why should teachers and staff be bogged down every single year with unnecessary paperwork just because some parent finds it too much work to write a quick note to the school before the new semester starts, letting them know their kid won't be attending religion class anymore?🤣
Do you seriously think someone who signed their kid up for religion class just "because everyone else is doing it" is actually going to go out of their way to unenroll them?🤦

Well, technically I disagree because kids—and honestly, people in general—are taught to believe that some guy named Santa actually shows up with presents. So yeah, it definitely ties back to faith and belief systems. With all these myths and legends, it really just comes down to what you personally choose to buy into... (honestly, if you look at it strictly, there isn't much difference between believing in Jesus and believing in Santa—both stories are built on teaching people to believe in these figures and their (magical) influence)

btw. All religions fall under the umbrella of marketing too (the whole point is to convince everyone that *their* specific way is the only right one), so it’s really just a competition to see whose marketing works better.

Sarah Hall53 said:If that's the case, then your school is actually breaking the rules. Honestly, there shouldn't be any need for signing a consent form every single year—once you enroll your kid in an elective during first, fourth, or fifth grade, you're basically giving your implicit consent for them to take that class all the way through the end of elementary school. If you want out, you just have to submit a formal written request to withdraw by August 15th, and then the school board makes the final call.

At my kid's school, we just give consent every year like clockwork, no special paperwork required. My kid just stopped attending this year, and honestly, nobody even blinked.

The law itself is a bit of a mess:

Article 27, paragraph 2 states that electives are chosen at the start of every school year, while paragraph 3 says you can stop taking them after submitting a written request. It’s all pretty vague if you ask me.