#1 ·
Greetings!
I hope I haven't posted this in the wrong section of the forum 😁
I am looking for some clarity regarding the third-person plural—specifically the word "sie."
When we want to ask "How are you?"
Wie geht es dir? (2nd person singular)
Wie geht es Ihnen? (2nd person singular, formal version)
Wie geht es euch? (2nd person plural)
Now, what interests me is how one would inquire about someone else's parents—for instance: "How are they?" (3rd person plural)
Logically, one would assume the question should be: Wie geht es Ihnenn, right?
But that is identical to the formal second-person singular version used for politeness. 😕
How is the listener supposed to know whether I am asking them directly how they are doing, or if I am actually asking about their Parents? 🤷
My second question also concerns the third-person plural:
In American English, we have different ways to distinguish gendered groups, but in German, there is just "sie."
So, how does one structure a question such as: "How are those girls?" or "How are those children?" 😕
This has been bothering me for quite some time now—please help.🙏
I hope I haven't posted this in the wrong section of the forum 😁
I am looking for some clarity regarding the third-person plural—specifically the word "sie."
When we want to ask "How are you?"
Wie geht es dir? (2nd person singular)
Wie geht es Ihnen? (2nd person singular, formal version)
Wie geht es euch? (2nd person plural)
Now, what interests me is how one would inquire about someone else's parents—for instance: "How are they?" (3rd person plural)
Logically, one would assume the question should be: Wie geht es Ihnenn, right?
But that is identical to the formal second-person singular version used for politeness. 😕
How is the listener supposed to know whether I am asking them directly how they are doing, or if I am actually asking about their Parents? 🤷
My second question also concerns the third-person plural:
In American English, we have different ways to distinguish gendered groups, but in German, there is just "sie."
So, how does one structure a question such as: "How are those girls?" or "How are those children?" 😕
This has been bothering me for quite some time now—please help.🙏