Reddit Trading: Part 2

I felt the need to start a fresh thread here—it seems we’re talking past one another...

1. If everyone else on this site can buy and sell on Marketplace, I don't see why the users over on Reddit shouldn't be allowed to do the same.

Honestly, after witnessing the sheer amount of special treatment you all seem to be angling for, I have to ask:

What makes the Reddit crowd so incredibly unique that you require privileges no other users enjoy?
Why should your chatter be tolerated?
Why shouldn't your casual chat threads be moved to OFF, just like the mountain of other chat topics from across the entire site?
And why is it that the women from Reddit think they're somehow above posting their celebratory threads in the Greetings section, where every other user posts them?
Why are your classified ads supposedly more "special" than everyone else's, necessitating that they stay on Reddit?

1. Not the whole site uses Marketplace,
2. I'm not asking for anything special compared to the rest of the community; I am specifically interested in this one, single topic.
3. I couldn't care less about the OFF topics.
4. And frankly, I don't care about the greeting threads either.
5. Our ads aren't any more distinct than, say, the ads over at Cosmetics, which remain exactly where they've always been.

I truly don't see the issue here.
After such an extensive cleanup of the main boards, could you perhaps "step in" and provide a service for the entire site?
Especially considering those threads were clean and weren't causing any kind of clutter or congestion...

I feel like I’ve already covered this, but here goes again: selling or buying baby clothes, maternity gear, or school textbooks isn't happening on Reddit. It just doesn't belong here.

What can I even say about this...

Isn't it actually better to have everything in one spot instead of scattered across a bunch of different PDFs? 🤷

The only thing you can really do is ask the Reddit mods if they'd be willing to meet you halfway by creating separate threads for buying and selling just to keep things organized. If you approach them normally and explain your reasoning, I doubt they'll give you any trouble.

Maybe it’s just me... but I found it a bit surreal to be scrolling through a PDF dedicated entirely to child development, only to stumble upon a thread about buying and selling kids' clothes right there in the 🤷
.
The MOD gathered everything into one single thread, adding a little disclaimer that we’re officially in the Off-Topic section now and that we should probably go ahead and read the rules first.☕.

I wouldn't (maybe) be making such a fuss if it weren't for this other thread—you know the one—that hasn't moved an inch, even though it clearly doesn't belong there either... right?
But fine, whatever. If it doesn't belong there, it belongs somewhere else, and that's that.😁