Robert Cooper41 said:I mean, Steven Soderbergh was on the jury too... but I just don't get why they'd include Meg Ryan and those Bollywood stars. The whole program seems geared toward these high-brow "art house" films, so how does it make sense to have a mainstream actress and a massive Indian movie star deciding the awards?!? I get wanting publicity, but still... 🙄
From what I can gather, the real issue was the disastrous selection process rather than the jury itself. Besides, what's your logic for assuming that Meg Ryan or an Indian actress wouldn't be qualified to judge what they've watched? At the end of the day, everything comes down to a subjective impression anyway—unless, of course, you think they just "don't get movies," haha.
Mike Leigh mentioned in an interview once that he always used to view a jury as this untouchable authority on what's good and what isn't, at least until he actually sat in that seat himself. That’s when he realized it's really just a small group of nervous people, all stressing out over whether their decision is actually right and how much heat they're going to take for it.