Tip or Bribe?
in Health ·
Susan Martin24
You claim you wouldn't take even a glass of water from "certain people here," even if they begged. That implies you're perfectly willing to accept from others—perhaps those who are less rebellious or more submissive—and judging by the sheer fury of the reaction, it's clear you view this as some sort of inherent right. Well, it might be healthy to occasionally hear what patients actually think about that "right" of yours!
If patients were forced to choose whether
a) they want for themselves, or for their children in the future, a society where any public sector service (taxpayer-funded)—provided we are satisfied with it—would be met with a simple smile and a polite thank you, making such an interaction the standard, normalized way of life
or
b) they would rather continue the mental gymnastics of deciding whom to "thank" with what (a gift card or cash), how much to give (enough to be respectful but not excessive), how to keep it professional without being cliché, or whether to offer anything at all...
If such a choice could truly be exercised and function smoothly—without any repercussions for the person seeking the service (be it a doctor or a government official)—I suspect that "spontaneous" gifting would evaporate almost overnight.
I realize achieving this is an impossibility, but surely it isn't too much to ask to admit that it should be our goal.
At the end of the day, so many people perform their jobs with immense dedication and sacrifice (from retail workers and engineers to civil servants and artists), yet it never occurs to anyone that they need special "rewards" for doing so; it is simply seen as the natural order of things. Why is it considered standard to bring gifts to doctors, even just a box of chocolates, yet it supposedly offends them when those same chocolates or perfumes are treated as a mere "polite formality" by someone at the local DMV?
Furthermore, my issue with healthcare workers isn't based on the idea that they represent the most corrupt sector of our environment—some studies suggest the legal system is actually worse—but rather because we all encounter medical staff several times a year, whereas most of us will never have a reason to deal with a lawyer in our entire lives.
My question to the "good citizens": to the quiet, diligent, competent, and patient "ants" who ask for nothing (and refuse anything offered, politely setting it aside) other than a sincere "thank you"—why do you remain silent and allow yourselves to be lumped into the same category as corrupt officials? I believe, and hope, that there are far more of you than there are "bad guys." And I am equally certain that among yourselves, you know exactly who is who...
You claim you wouldn't take even a glass of water from "certain people here," even if they begged. That implies you're perfectly willing to accept from others—perhaps those who are less rebellious or more submissive—and judging by the sheer fury of the reaction, it's clear you view this as some sort of inherent right. Well, it might be healthy to occasionally hear what patients actually think about that "right" of yours!
If patients were forced to choose whether
a) they want for themselves, or for their children in the future, a society where any public sector service (taxpayer-funded)—provided we are satisfied with it—would be met with a simple smile and a polite thank you, making such an interaction the standard, normalized way of life
or
b) they would rather continue the mental gymnastics of deciding whom to "thank" with what (a gift card or cash), how much to give (enough to be respectful but not excessive), how to keep it professional without being cliché, or whether to offer anything at all...
If such a choice could truly be exercised and function smoothly—without any repercussions for the person seeking the service (be it a doctor or a government official)—I suspect that "spontaneous" gifting would evaporate almost overnight.
I realize achieving this is an impossibility, but surely it isn't too much to ask to admit that it should be our goal.
At the end of the day, so many people perform their jobs with immense dedication and sacrifice (from retail workers and engineers to civil servants and artists), yet it never occurs to anyone that they need special "rewards" for doing so; it is simply seen as the natural order of things. Why is it considered standard to bring gifts to doctors, even just a box of chocolates, yet it supposedly offends them when those same chocolates or perfumes are treated as a mere "polite formality" by someone at the local DMV?
Furthermore, my issue with healthcare workers isn't based on the idea that they represent the most corrupt sector of our environment—some studies suggest the legal system is actually worse—but rather because we all encounter medical staff several times a year, whereas most of us will never have a reason to deal with a lawyer in our entire lives.
My question to the "good citizens": to the quiet, diligent, competent, and patient "ants" who ask for nothing (and refuse anything offered, politely setting it aside) other than a sincere "thank you"—why do you remain silent and allow yourselves to be lumped into the same category as corrupt officials? I believe, and hope, that there are far more of you than there are "bad guys." And I am equally certain that among yourselves, you know exactly who is who...