Nathan Morris3 said:devgirl, thanks for the help 😉.
I'm trying to compare a part-time retiree employment contract versus an independent contractor agreement. The deal for the retiree would be $4,000 for half-time.
For the contractor route, I'm using this calculator:
https://www.indeed.com/calculators...n=263&type=n2g
(since 2017 net = $4,002, total cost = $6,480)
For the employment contract:
https://www.indeed.com/calculators...eff=0&type=n2g
(since 2017 net = $4,000, gross 2 = $5,976)
Based on this, it actually looks like hiring them as a retiree might be cheaper than a contractor (if we want their net to stay at $1.25). But you mentioned the tax deduction shouldn't apply to an employment contract. Does that mean I need to remove the "Total Deduction = $3,800" line from this calculation, which would change the taxes? So my gross 2 would go up by ($3,800 * 24%) = $912, making the contractor option the winner after all: $6,480 < $6,888?
Since the employment contract contributes to a 401(k), does that mean their retirement savings grow more if we go that route? And if so, when would they actually see that benefit?
It’ll actually jump up by about $359, since you missed the local state tax.
He’s already retired, so he isn't contributing to a secondary pension fund—instead, through a standard contract, he'd just be paying into Social Security. I think there's some rule where they can request a benefit adjustment after hitting a certain income level or number of years... I read something about it recently, but honestly, don't kill me because I can't remember the exact source... maybe someone else here knows.
But hey, I just thought of something... if he has a pretty small pension...
The updated tax code says:
Section 24
(5) Income tax withholdings for non-self-employed work from items 2 and 3 shall be reduced by 50% for retirees based on their earned pension income.
So, if we could pull his tax withholding info from his Social Security statement (need to check, haven't dealt with this specific case!) so they calculate his tax on the full pension amount without the personal credit (while still using that 50% reduction!), and then you apply your full personal credit to his wages, the math might totally flip in your favor...