Posts by Nancy Young31

I am sorry, but you insulted me with that—it was an entirely unnecessary and excessive reaction on your part (specifically regarding those instructions about "venting your frustrations on someone in real life"—which were crude). I believe it was perfectly obvious that my only intention was to reach an agreement where we could all discuss things together and attempt to create something for the PDF that was highly frequented and eagerly read, rather than dragging this out painfully for days or weeks. Unfortunately, that simply didn't happen.

I stated that it makes logical sense to me that Geomancy, along with Recommendations, falls under magic and mysticism; they should simply go into the same "box," as someone else put it. It's cleaner, more sensible, and so on. I have every right to express that opinion. Kenneth Price72 wrote a very good and quite extensive post on the other thread just the other day regarding geomancy and its history, so if that isn't enough to make it clear how much it belongs under magic and mysticism, then I truly do not know.... 😕 🤷 😕

Now you have claimed that geomancy has indirect ties to astrology—well, why then, if not under magic and mysticism, would it be placed under Astrology? But no, it can't go there either; it must go under All Sorts, because apparently no other place can be found for it within the Alternative category? Strange. Is there really no way to handle Recommendations, such as how recommendations are handled on other PDFs?

But fine. Since those who have spent years bombarding tarot masters, Ren, and others with hundreds of their inquiries are now, quite wisely, remaining silent and presumably waiting for someone else to fight for their interests, I don't see any point in wasting any more of my time on this.

I will no longer participate in this thread, nor any similar one, because I find that there is a palpable, visible preponderance of hatred and disparaging remarks directed toward the forum members who participated in the threads for tarot, Geomancy, Recommendations, and so forth.

Warm regards to everyone who participated in this thread and previous ones!

Ryan Wilson2, just who exactly are you picking a fight with, and what on earth could possibly be the reason?

I am in total agreement.
(First off, I have to say, I was absolutely floored to see that Geomancy hasn't been reinstated either!)

The Magic and Mysticism section just isn't the same without Geomancy; it’s lost its essence—and I am referring to the positive aspects here, not the lack of discipline from certain questioners that ultimately led us down this path—nor does it reflect what the section could truly become. Geomancy was such a cornerstone of the Magic and Mysticism PDF!

Kenneth Price72 did a wonderful job in his post explaining exactly what Geomancy entails.

It belongs right there alongside tarot; separating them is like splitting up a family. It simply makes no sense, and frankly, there is zero common sense applied here. 🤷

I believe we are all exhausted by these games of one-upmanship, so I won't ramble on too long, but surely this is a matter of elementary logic: why on earth would Geomancy be (or remain) categorized under All Sorts of Things instead of being in Magic and Mysticism? Please, I beg you, do not take advantage of the fact that Kenneth Price72 is such a polite individual—a true gentleman, really—who clearly has no desire to get dragged into petty bickering, arguing, or trying to outsmart everyone else!

Personally, I feel compelled to suggest that Tarot Master Recommendations should also stay within Magic and Mysticism (unless perhaps we should request a brand new topic for that specifically? 🙄), because logically, it fits perfectly there. It’s not as if recommendations for psychiatrists and psychologists were stripped from the Psychology section and tossed into All Sorts of Things or some other corner, nor were hair stylists, estheticians, or dermatologists evicted from the Cosmetics section to be dumped elsewhere... Everything falls into the same logical "box."

Good grief, people—moderators, admins—can we please put an end to this infantile tug-of-war!