The whole reason kids end up in after-school programs should be simple: parents are at work and the local roads are dangerous enough. That’s it. Nothing else.
A friend of mine had this experience where her kid was getting extra homework assigned during first grade. Now they're in third grade—and since everyone in this district goes to the after-school program now—the kid actually gets the work done there instead of bringing it home.
Back when she was in first grade, the instructor would just tell her in the afternoon, "I'm exhausted, I can't even look at you right now."
That kind of apathy is contagious. If the staff doesn't care, the kids won't either.
Think about the contrast. You have some kids whose grandparents act like a private shuttle service, dropping them off and picking them up perfectly on schedule. Then you have the rest of us. You crawl through the door after a brutal shift at the office, completely drained, only to realize the kid still needs help with homework or just needs your attention because they haven't learned how to work independently yet.
My take? You have to carve out dedicated time for that. It’s an obligation, just like everything else waiting for you once the workday is over.

→ go to post

Extended stays - what are your experiences? in Students & Teens · Apr 27, 2015

Ha. Well, everyone has their own unique "philosophy" when it comes to starting the first grade...
Maybe it actually works out better for the kid in the long run, just like you described... they get that head start on independence... who knows...
No hard feelings... 👍

→ go to post

Extended stays - what are your experiences? in Students & Teens · Apr 27, 2015

Susan James said:Homework is an assignment given by the teacher to the student, not to the parent or the after-school instructor.
The whole point of homework is to practice what was covered in class that day or to finish something that didn't get completed during school hours. The goal is to encourage independent learning.
As for whether the homework is finished, that’s for the person who assigned it to check.
Why do we need two extra layers of supervision? What kind of message are we sending to the kid? 🤔

Based on the forgetting curve, homework really should be done as soon as possible after the lesson. It’s perfectly fine if a parent who works until 1:00 or 2:00 PM picks their child up after lunch and encourages them to tackle their work at their study desk (maybe even sitting with them).
However, most parents who rely on after-school programs work until 4:00 or 5:00 PM. It would be completely unreasonable to expect them to force their child to wait until late at night to do homework after they've already spent five exhausting hours at school.
And if parents are being "called out" or made to feel guilty for not micromanaging their child's assignments, 🥱
then doing homework during after-school care isn't a benefit at all🤦—it's just part of the curriculum. Why shift that entire responsibility onto the parents?

As for the school system itself, with the current curriculum, I might consider it a necessary evil, but I have never been against the idea of gaining knowledge or studying.
Quite the opposite.
And I am not an uninterested parent; I just care about things beyond my own child. I don't feel the need to recite every single reading passage or obsess over specific dates in American history that don't affect my daily life.

A parent who is truly engaged in their child's life will stay informed about their progress without needing to flip through every drawing or scrutinize every single assignment every single day.
On the other hand, a parent who is genuinely indifferent won't suddenly become interested just because a teacher tells them they have to check the homework—and that's usually when the kid starts hating school.
There are also parents who simply don't have the bandwidth to sit down and study with their kids. For these children, after-school programs can be a huge win because they get dedicated time to actually finish their homework.
(Though, let's be honest, working parents usually pick these programs more often, and sometimes they’re the only ones who can even snag a spot if there's a waitlist.)

For years now, social services and various non-profits have been organizing supervised study sessions—often through community centers or youth outreach programs—for kids in families facing real hardships. These are situations where the kids haven't been removed from the home, but it's clear the parents either can't help with the schoolwork or just don't have a quiet place for the child to focus at home.
The goal is to support the child without pointing fingers at the parents. Instead of blaming them, social workers, speech therapists, or specialists step in to guide the child through the learning process and help them become more independent.
To me, it doesn't really matter who provides that guidance. What matters is that by the time a kid hits third grade—or fifth at the latest—they understand that school and homework are their own responsibility. They need to know they have to show up, do the work, ask for help when they're stuck, and take ownership of their results, even if things are tough at home or their parents aren't able to step in.
At the end of the day, school is the student's job and their responsibility.

That’s precisely the point. A parent steps in when necessary, and the child learns that stepping up is their responsibility. But you don't expect a first grader to grasp that overnight. It requires actual engagement, not just adopting a "couldn't care less" attitude.

Quoting Cattley: "Up until yesterday, they were just playing around aimlessly, and then suddenly, we're expected to have them possess time management, a sense of duty, self-discipline to meet deadlines, and the focus to actually remember their homework."

I'm with Frupy on all counts. ☕

→ go to post

Extended stays - what are your experiences? in Students & Teens · Apr 23, 2015

Sure, I agree that homework is ultimately the child's responsibility. But as a parent of a first grader, it’s my job to look over their shoulder—at least during this initial stage—and provide some basic guidance on whether they're actually on the right track. Eventually, you have to step back and let them manage their own schoolwork.
I honestly have no idea where you all got the impression from my posts that I’m suggesting parents should constantly hover over their kids.
And frankly, the whole system seems flawed. It makes zero sense to leave textbooks at school when the kid is expected to study from them. If the books stay at the classroom, what exactly are they supposed to be studying?

→ go to post