Look, since I’m the one who kicked this whole thing off, I guess I’m the one who has to set the record straight—even though there isn't really anything to "fix" here. It’s just that people are misreading what I said and jumping to the wrong conclusions, and honestly, that's how you end up in these ridiculous arguments... but whatever. All I actually said was that Roth is one of my favorite actors, right alongside Penn.
Raymond Palmer8 That's what I'm saying.
Comparing some leftist hack to Sean Penn is honestly just plain disrespectful.
Look, I wasn't out here trying to compare anyone—I was just stating facts. And even if I had gone there? It wouldn't have been rude, not by a long shot. 🤣
I guess you could even bring up Michelle Hall9 in this conversation—though, obviously, I don't agree with her on anything.
Michelle Hall9 Personally, I think Sean Penn is pretty much a non-entity when it comes to acting. I’ve sat through more than two of his movies now—enough to form an actual opinion—and honestly? He’s way overhyped. It’s just my take, though—everyone's got their own taste—but for me, Tim Roth is easily the much better actor.
And there goes Roth again, back at it with the praise... 😂
Nicholas Chavez70 Susan Mendoza71 said:Honestly, that part in Pulp Fiction totally turned my stomach—watching those poor people get robbed by that psycho woman.
Jerry Martin19 Look, what Susan Mendoza71 is getting at is that those two actors come from completely different worlds. They’re fundamentally different beasts—you can't even put them in the same conversation. It’s like trying to compare a stand-up comedian to some heavy-hitting dramatic actor who only does prestige stuff. It just doesn't work.
Look, I see you’re being pretty reasonable here, but that example you threw out? It was a bad call. I’m gonna have to disagree—I know they aren't even in the same league of actors, but honestly, acting is either good or it sucks. It doesn't matter if you're the lead or just some guy in a supporting role; you're either nailing it or you're failing. Period.
Jerry Martin19 Sean Penn basically just forces his roles at this point—he keeps hitting the same notes over and over again.
I don't buy that for a second... If that were true, it would mean that the scuzzy lawyer from Carlito's Way and the ex-con from Mystic River—both absolute legends in my book—were just forced, cookie-cutter archetypes based on the same thing. That claim just doesn't hold water for me... unless they're leaning hard on that "mostly" qualifier. 🤣 ?
Man, this is already drifting way too far off-topic... we gotta get back to the point here. Look, Roth is killer and that's all there is to it. Period.