Canada discussion: Strict border control and entry rules
in Feedback & Suggestions ·
With all due respect, you guys are just contradicting yourselves now.
First you say nothing about emigration is allowed, then you say it actually is (?!)
How am I supposed to know I won't get banned if I do end up asking something?
That's just not how it works, considering immigration rules shift almost every single year—think Working holiday visas, provincial programs, and all that jazz. When you deal with the Embassy, you get these incredibly brief, half-baked answers; they don't seem to have any interest in giving a meaningful response, they just parrot the URL of the official website like some kind of automated script.
Do you honestly believe that the rules for moving to America aren't going to change again?
Do you think the situation as it stood back at the end of 2012 is somehow final?
Where am I supposed to go to hear from people who are actually planning to move this year?
The one solitary thread about Canada has such a pathetic turnout, and frankly, it’s because of all your bans. The level of interest speaks for itself—you've got a whole thread dedicated to bans and strictness within the Canada topic... meanwhile, my thread, which was strictly about emigration, was shut down expressively fast, even though I had support from everyone who showed up there... I just don't get it.🤷
I went through all thirteen pages of your CHAT thread, and honestly, only one person on the forum is openly complaining—she's clearly annoyed by anything remotely American now that she’s settled in Canada, and she made it very clear she can't stand people asking her anything related to the moving process. (Though, I highly doubt she felt that way when *she* was the one scrambling for info back home—it's that classic mindset: "everyone help me when I need it, but don't bother me when I'm the one being asked"... but anyway, that's off-topic, so I'll stop!) A much larger group of people (including Canadians themselves) told you guys that this setup doesn't make sense, to which your response was basically that you don't know what to do or how to please everyone. Here's my suggestion: let this CHAT thread stay exactly as it is, but unlock my thread and let it be exclusively for emigration, just like I laid out in my opening post. That way, those of us still planning our move to Canada can access fresh information, while those who find immigrants annoying can stick to their own chat thread about the weather, nightlife, echoes, and other "vital" topics. (My blood pressure is starting to rise a bit as I type this, and I'm pretty exhausted, so bear with me.)
Henry Moore2 said:This thread is strictly for socializing.
Any trolling will be dealt with—strictly speaking—and if you have questions about moving, please look for info here.
(A big thanks to our resident gentleman for gathering all these links!)
Any questions regarding emigration in this thread will be deleted and/or result in a ban.
Enjoy!
Skatte
ambermason16 said: The thread is open to anyone who wants to join in, whether they're Canadian or not. But the goal here is just hanging out and swapping casual info. Since the main topic is packed with links useful for anyone looking to move to Canada—plus two other massive threads that cover basically every question imaginable in extreme detail—we feel like the Canadians have officially done their part in keeping everyone informed.
At the same time, we're reiterating—this thread isn't meant for questions about emigration, immigration, visas, paperwork, jobs, or anything else that usually makes up 90% of the Canada-related chatter. Please read the PDF rules and use the resources already provided. Any "technical" questions posted here will be deleted and/or lead to a ban. It’s probably time for everyone to put in a little effort themselves. You have all the material right there.
Thanks.
rustydrifter10 said:I was actually chatting with Henry Moore2 about this exact thing, and she told me that on this Canadian social thread, you can totally drop questions even if they've been answered a million times before, or if they're super specific, or if you just can't find a single shred of info on Google or from the Embassy.
First you say nothing about emigration is allowed, then you say it actually is (?!)
How am I supposed to know I won't get banned if I do end up asking something?
Henry Moore2 said:It’s been months, maybe even years, that I haven't seen a single fresh question that hasn't already been answered in one of the last three threads. Or, if it's something really specific, you could just call the Embassy and talk to someone who actually works there.
If anyone ever does run into a real curveball, feel free to just drop it in the thread for the diaspora living in New York City.
That's just not how it works, considering immigration rules shift almost every single year—think Working holiday visas, provincial programs, and all that jazz. When you deal with the Embassy, you get these incredibly brief, half-baked answers; they don't seem to have any interest in giving a meaningful response, they just parrot the URL of the official website like some kind of automated script.
Do you honestly believe that the rules for moving to America aren't going to change again?
Do you think the situation as it stood back at the end of 2012 is somehow final?
Where am I supposed to go to hear from people who are actually planning to move this year?
The one solitary thread about Canada has such a pathetic turnout, and frankly, it’s because of all your bans. The level of interest speaks for itself—you've got a whole thread dedicated to bans and strictness within the Canada topic... meanwhile, my thread, which was strictly about emigration, was shut down expressively fast, even though I had support from everyone who showed up there... I just don't get it.🤷
I went through all thirteen pages of your CHAT thread, and honestly, only one person on the forum is openly complaining—she's clearly annoyed by anything remotely American now that she’s settled in Canada, and she made it very clear she can't stand people asking her anything related to the moving process. (Though, I highly doubt she felt that way when *she* was the one scrambling for info back home—it's that classic mindset: "everyone help me when I need it, but don't bother me when I'm the one being asked"... but anyway, that's off-topic, so I'll stop!) A much larger group of people (including Canadians themselves) told you guys that this setup doesn't make sense, to which your response was basically that you don't know what to do or how to please everyone. Here's my suggestion: let this CHAT thread stay exactly as it is, but unlock my thread and let it be exclusively for emigration, just like I laid out in my opening post. That way, those of us still planning our move to Canada can access fresh information, while those who find immigrants annoying can stick to their own chat thread about the weather, nightlife, echoes, and other "vital" topics. (My blood pressure is starting to rise a bit as I type this, and I'm pretty exhausted, so bear with me.)