Taylor Kelly3 said:After reading through all your posts, I figured I’d jump in, share some of my own experiences, and toss a few tips your way!
So, look—I play in a band, and after playing a ton of weddings and various gigs, I can give you the real scoop. I’ll mostly stick to the music side of things, though, since—well, I’m not a videographer!
Before you go running off looking for help or advice, you’ve gotta realize that everyone is different. Seriously, people don't think alike! One person might love a certain venue, while someone else totally hates it—everyone’s got their own vibe! For example, back in my hometown, there’s this one hall (and it’s not just one, by the way) that most people can't stand, but someone walks in and goes, “That’s the spot!” Some folks don't care about decor at all and will leave a place looking totally bare as long as the party is killer. There aren't any hard rules here, and the absolute worst thing you can do is try to "copy" a wedding you attended where you had a blast. If you try that, it’ll probably blow up in your face! You can have the perfect venue, the perfect band, the right decor, the best photographer, caterers, and parking, but if you don't hire the right *people*, the whole thing won't be unforgettable. You have to remember that when an older lady hears some heavy hitters, she’s gonna say “Goodness gracious, this crowd has gone totally crazy! Jim, let’s get moving!” Meanwhile, the younger crowd might just fall asleep during the slower stuff. Every guest matters!
I’ve been to plenty of "great" and "terrible" weddings. As a musician, I look at it this way: did we actually entertain the GUESTS? Did everything run smoothly? Was the banter tasteful? (Quote: "Hey, Best Man, spin us around a little more"... Good grief... you can take the country out of the rural South, but you can't take the South out of the country!). Most importantly, did everyone working the event respect each other just for YOUR sake? (And hey, if someone thinks it’s fine for a band to play for two hours, take a 15-minute break, then play another two hours, well, they should decide if they want a wedding or a rave!). At the end of the day, steak is best when it's hot, and we all know how bad cold risotto can be!
For some people, the band's sound is everything... (Don't just listen to DVDs—I know, others have mentioned this, but people film with all kinds of cheap cameras. Talk to the band and ask to hear them live). For others, it’s the song selection, the atmosphere (and we all know what happens when you've had a few drinks), or maybe it's the food—steak, risotto, or just a massive spread. Basically, you need to respect all of it!
I know a huge amount of venues, capacities, photographers, videographers (I've seen their work), agencies, bands, and so on in my area, but since I can't exactly plug myself, I'll stay anonymous!
I get asked for recommendations for photos, video, venues... all the time. But I won't give them! How am I supposed to know if our tastes even align?
If the pay is right, I’d even fly to Switzerland to play a wedding, but obviously, the price would go up to cover costs. Just a heads up, though: don't expect a band from California to throw the exact same kind of party as a band from Georgia, and vice versa! ...Maybe I'm exaggerating a bit, but that's basically how it works!
Ask whatever you want. Negotiate with the people you hire, but always keep in mind that they are there for one night specifically for YOU. You're paying them, so they "have" to listen to you—otherwise... why would you even hire them in the first place???????
But seriously, feel free to ask us for advice too, because we can really help you out! We're happy to help however we can!!!
Alright, I'll go first. Since you're offering to give advice, how about 😉
The thing is, everything in your post is just really broad, high-level stuff. What those of us here—specifically me—actually want to know is: what are the specific things we can or should negotiate with a band when making a deal, and which questions are just a total waste of breath? 🤷
Basically, how far in advance do we finalize the setlist?
And which questions are considered useless or redundant from your perspective? 🙄 because they either make no sense or aren't even necessary.
And so on...
I'll try to think of more 😉
Anyway, I have a ton of respect for anyone from any professional background who takes the time to chime in like this, so cheers to you 👍