1. The first thread has been permanently closed—it basically devolved into people throwing diagnoses at the author and bickering with one another, which wasn't the point at all. The goal was to share experiences and talk about those "gray areas," but instead, it turned into a discussion about rape and other forms of sexual violence that don't actually fall into that gray zone. In the meantime, we’ve opened a second thread—we decided to rename it so it can serve as a space to discuss sexual violence more broadly, covering the whole topic properly.
2. We couldn't get to it immediately, but as soon as Sabaa and I arrived, we went through the thread together and cleared everything out according to the Women's Corner rules.
3. That third thread was just pure provocation. Even if it wasn't, there was really no reason to start a new one when a similar topic already exists. We made it clear in that other thread that any closure would only be temporary while we moderated it—which we did that very same day. You actually started this new thread right after the previous one was closed.
4. That’s exactly what the first thread became—closing it was the only logical move, otherwise, almost every single post would have ended up being deleted or flagged.
5. Look, that's my call as a moderator. Those posts were written at the exact same moment I was typing out the warning. In cases like this, I always delete them if there are just one or two posts that slip in right after a warning—you can tell they were posted simultaneously. Unless, of course, they're specifically commenting on the moderation itself.
7. I don't really follow the question. What is the purpose of any thread, anyway? 🤷
Grace Sullivan42 said:1a) Is repeatedly lecturing about reducing the risk of rape considered off-topic or flaming?
b) Is mourning the victims of false accusations off-topic or flaming?
c) Is diagnosing mental health or intelligence issues against the rules?
d) Is it allowed to deny the Penal Code of the United States and create your own definitions of rape?
a) Yes, and we flagged those posts accordingly.
b) I'm not sure I follow—what are you getting at here?
c) No, it isn't; we flagged those too.
d) Could you please provide some examples of posts like that?