vivideagle7 said:Zimmer is fine, but he’s probably the most overrated film composer ever.
There are some pretty heated debates online regarding Zimmer. You have people who view him as the modern-day Beethoven, pitted against those who think his work is total garbage. Personally, I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle.
In today's landscape, there really isn't a more sought-after, commercial, or perfectly suited composer for Hollywood blockbusters than him. A lot of people wonder why he gets the job instead of, say... them. 🤣
I think the thing is, as a film composer, Zimmer is, above all else, truly Effective—and that is the deciding factor. He is someone who works incredibly hard to achieve the specific result he wants. He’s surrounded by a massive team of musicians and technicians who help him execute his vision. He knows how to craft a score that fits the film perfectly, even if it doesn't necessarily hold up as a standalone listening experience (which, let's be honest, often isn't the case, but it works brilliantly within the movie). Technically speaking, he's so progressive that many people today actually follow his compositional approach. You could almost say Zimmer himself pioneered what we now recognize as Epic Music. He has managed to evolve with every decade, staying right on trend... he follows the trends just enough to create and refine them. What many people criticize him for most is that his musical motifs have increasingly started to rely on just two notes, which he then modifies in countless ways throughout the entire film. He has admitted himself that this is his way of composing because it’s the most effective method. He has an incredible instinct for knowing exactly what will work in any given scene. Some argue that he doesn't write "film music," but rather "soundtracks" in the sense that his music blindly follows the action... and there's a bit of truth to that.
Unlike Morricone, his music often struggles when played on its own, but I personally feel that most great film scores can function quite well as standalone pieces, provided you aren't dealing with high-tension sequences and things like that. However, Hollywood over the last 20 or 30 years has "evolved" toward a style where films mostly demand cold, restrained, distant, and unobtrusive scoring. I honestly don't know if Zimmer has ever been able to create something light enough to truly touch someone emotionally... I highly doubt it. He’s essentially a high-tech, precision-oriented German technician at heart.
Again, Zimmer's obvious inspiration from Morricone's work is evident in what he did for Interstellar, especially regarding the use of the organ, which he executed masterfully. Yet, even then, some modern listeners found it distracting because they were hearing something that wasn't just sterile background filler. But Zimmer pulled it off beautifully, likely drawing inspiration from the film Mission to Mars—which didn't exactly break the box office, but features a scene where Morricone uses organ sounds. People criticized him for that too, despite the fact that those moments were made even more powerful and engaging specifically because of the music.
But it's precisely because of scenes like these that it's hard not to respect Zimmer... this is arguably one of the most visually and musically moving moments in cinematic history, yet even here, some critics found fault with the music, even though it wasn't just appropriate, but elevated the scene to a whole new level:
On one hand, Zimmer occasionally tries to be more creative, but then he gets criticized for that, too. Some people are happiest when they don't even realize music is playing in a film. A composer like Morricone wasn't built for those kinds of movies; he was built for the kind of cinema directed by people like Leone, who turned film into true art, which is what cinema is meant to be at its core. His scenes felt like music videos, unlike that damn "mickey mousing" technique seen in older films, which is a style John Williams used to make things feel a bit duller.
On the other hand, Zimmer really understands what modern audiences are looking for. He often takes the path of least resistance, yet somehow manages to make it feel perfectly appropriate for the moment. Technically speaking, he gives you nothing less than the absolute maximum, while hitting that musical sweet spot that feels just right.