I just finished watching this and honestly, I’m torn between tearing it apart or giving it credit (though I definitely won't be doing the latter). 😛
So, is the movie actually complete trash like I anticipated, or have my standards just hit rock bottom? Here is what I will say: if you watch this entirely on its own, without any prior knowledge of Donnie Darko, it definitely deserves more than its current 4.2 on IMDb. In that vacuum, I’d probably give it a solid 7/10.
But let’s be real—90% of the people watching S. Darko are going to know all about Donnie, so that low 4.2 rating makes perfect sense, maybe even lower. You can't really view this as a Sequel; it feels more like a cheap, low-budget rip-off of the original. The whole thing relies on pale, poorly executed imitations of tropes from Donnie (the sky, the countdown, the waking up, the rabbit, that weird thing coming out of the body, the party scenes, the cinema screen, the camera speed ramps, several identical lines of dialogue, and a truly terrible attempt at an ending), yet it adds almost zero originality. What’s worse is that the few new things they added just end up making the copied parts look even more blatant. ☕
When I add it all up, I really do have plenty of reasons to bash this film, and I’m not even sure why I tried to find a silver lining in the first place. I have no intention of revisiting this, and hopefully, after a few more viewings of Donnie Darko, this unnecessary mistake will fade completely from my mind.
So, is the movie actually complete trash like I anticipated, or have my standards just hit rock bottom? Here is what I will say: if you watch this entirely on its own, without any prior knowledge of Donnie Darko, it definitely deserves more than its current 4.2 on IMDb. In that vacuum, I’d probably give it a solid 7/10.
But let’s be real—90% of the people watching S. Darko are going to know all about Donnie, so that low 4.2 rating makes perfect sense, maybe even lower. You can't really view this as a Sequel; it feels more like a cheap, low-budget rip-off of the original. The whole thing relies on pale, poorly executed imitations of tropes from Donnie (the sky, the countdown, the waking up, the rabbit, that weird thing coming out of the body, the party scenes, the cinema screen, the camera speed ramps, several identical lines of dialogue, and a truly terrible attempt at an ending), yet it adds almost zero originality. What’s worse is that the few new things they added just end up making the copied parts look even more blatant. ☕
When I add it all up, I really do have plenty of reasons to bash this film, and I’m not even sure why I tried to find a silver lining in the first place. I have no intention of revisiting this, and hopefully, after a few more viewings of Donnie Darko, this unnecessary mistake will fade completely from my mind.