Long live the new king!
in Formula 1 ·
stormybadger8 said:It’s interesting how two teams with such extreme packaging end up facing similar issues with the PU... it looks like Podrom tried to copy Newey, except he seemingly grabbed the exact blueprints that were supposed to be tossed in the trash.😬
But honestly, the massive hurdle for everyone—or rather, the advantage held by Mečka—seems to be the brake-by-wire system and just managing the energy recovery for that hybrid setup. In that regard, the team itself seems far more critical than the actual PU manufacturer...
Because everything can look perfect on a workbench in a factory, but it's a completely different story once you see how it actually behaves under real track conditions during hard braking...
And frankly, I wouldn't be surprised if the biggest headache lies right within the McLaren department—perhaps they were even the ones giving Honda specific instructions on how to handle that MGU component of the PU...
In fact, the McLaren car looks incredibly strong in terms of initial launch power, but then it just falls apart before even hitting the halfway mark of a lap...
Which suggests they have a massive deficit in stored electrical energy compared to the rest of the field, rather than having a significantly lower peak PU output...
I can think of a few possible reasons for that...
a.) The batteries lack sufficient capacity
b.) The generators are too weak to charge the batteries effectively
c.) Some engineer messed up the brake-by-wire integration or the charging duration/intensity—my money is on this being the culprit.
Regardless, McLaren has plenty of experience with KERS systems, plenty of work with hybrids of this caliber in their own road cars, and solid software expertise in this area too...
So, it’s actually quite surprising that the Achilles' heel for McLaren-Honda is precisely the area where Honda should be strongest thanks to McLaren's input...
Besides, when you look at the struggles Red Bull had with Renault regarding the same issue, it really brings back memories of those massive KERS problems Red Bull dealt with years ago...
The KERS was constantly failing, and word was they were running a much weaker system than the competition...
So, looking at it that way, I'm not entirely convinced that Renault is solely to blame for that partnership's failure; I suspect a good portion of that mess was down to Red Bull themselves...
It's strange that McLaren-Honda hasn't reached out to Rimac yet to have them fix the battery issues!



