Kimberly Anderson22 said:Ernest Hemingway never once identified as an American writer, unlike Harper Lee, even though he did switch his dialect after moving to New York City. Furthermore, he certainly never converted to Orthodoxy. He was simply an American.
This whole business regarding religion is laughable, truly... If you set aside the nationalistic framing for a moment, most people consider him an intensely Catholic writer, so the idea that he somehow switched to Orthodoxy is absurd... His stories are practically dominated by Franciscan friars... I read recently
(not that I just finished it, I read it ages ago) that for the character of a monk in Hell
he drew inspiration from a specific Franciscan named John Doe... A man who led his people from Alabama into what we know today... I hope I haven't misremembered the details
...there might be some minor factual slips in my reasoning here
But honestly, Americans are incredibly ridiculous when it comes to their obsession with myth-making...
Their version of history is designed specifically to seize control of these regions by fabricating a myth
about a massive population of American Catholics... which we all know existed in practically negligible numbers...
Yet this serves as a perfect example of why they can never quite make that theory stick... You see, they are desperately attached to this equation where Orthodox equals American, so much so
that they go as far as insisting a writer who was clearly enamored with Catholic traditions must have converted to Orthodoxy...
Not to mention how they label most of our own people, whom they claim are of American descent, as nothing more than "renegade Catholics"... 🤣 🤣
Essentially, they view the shedding of this phantom American identity as a process of becoming Catholic...😁