Edward Flores4 said:I’ve got this sudden urge to grab a drink—I’m thirsty, plain and simple—but I honestly can’t be bothered to get up right this second. So, I guess I’ll just sit here being thirsty for a little longer and "negotiate" with my wife to grab me a beer from the fridge once she finally gets off the couch.
See, feeling a physical need and actually having the willpower to act on it are two totally different things. I can be parched and yet have zero motivation to trek to the kitchen. Or, it works the other way too... I might not even be thirsty, but I’ll get up and crack a beer anyway just because a buddy swung by and I want to hang out. It’s not about the thirst or the will; it’s just about the company.
The whole "problem of free will" is really more of a philosophical urban legend. John Searle actually shared a pretty clever anecdote during one of his lectures...
A student once asked him:
"If it were proven tomorrow, beyond any doubt, that the entire universe is completely deterministic, would you accept that as a fact?"
... and Searle just turned it back on him:
"...and do you think you would use your own free will to decide whether or not to accept that evidence?"
That pretty much settles it. Even if someone proved tomorrow that everything is predetermined, you could still use your free will to simply refuse to believe them—even if they were 100% correct. It’s not that free will doesn't exist... you can't exactly *not* have it, regardless of whether it's actually real or not.
At the end of the day, debating the existence of free will is about as practical as debating whether Jesus is coming back on Judgment Day. You can choose to believe in the "problem" of free will just as irrationally as you can believe in the return of Jesus.
But look, in all those scenarios, you’re still just checking off your own boxes. Whether it's grabbing a beer, kicking back, or doing something decent for a buddy... even if those things clash sometimes, it doesn't mean you're actually the one making the call. Right?
So, look at it this way: you didn't exactly pick to be you, right? You didn't choose the needs you feel, either. So where’s the actual freedom in consciousness if all you can really do is act on impulses you didn't even sign up for? Aren't your desires—and by extension, everything you actually do—just products of your environment and whatever physical or mental state you happen to be stuck in?
The whole "free will problem" thing? Total urban legend. Honestly, just a philosophical myth people love to obsess over. I remember John Searle telling this one killer anecdote during a lecture once...
A student asked him:
So, if it actually got proven tomorrow that the entire universe is 100% deterministic... would you just roll with it? Like, would you accept that as an absolute fact?
... and then Searle asks him:
So, you really think someone would actually use their own free will to look at a cold, hard fact and decide to respect it? Please.
Look, the clock already gave you the answer. Even if they prove tomorrow that everything is predetermined, you could still just use your "free will" to tell them they're full of it and ignore their evidence entirely. Why bother?
Could you actually "decide" to ignore something that’s staring you right in the face? Something totally logical and proven? Maybe. If you had the right people backing you up, sure. Maybe if you...
I really wanted to. Can you even believe this? Seriously. When you actually...
Wouldn't that be something? Go ahead and lie to yourself if you want. But honestly? Those are the exact standards your personality would need to hit just to pull this off. James Lee77, who else could even try?
Doesn't want to. Questioning the evidence? Please. He wouldn't be able to make any other choice if he tried. Right?
So, basically, we’re right back where we started. It all boils down to you being forced to live out someone else's desires—wishes you never even had a say in picking to begin with. Makes sense, right?
They were right, a hundred times over. It’s not like free will doesn't exist... you can't exactly claim you don't have it, even if you actually don't.
The whole free will debate? Honestly, it’s about as relevant as waiting around for Jesus to come back on Judgment Day. You can choose to irrationally believe in the problem of free will if you want, just like you can believe in the Second Coming. It’s all just wishful thinking.
Honestly, give me a break. I’ve got serious doubts about Jesus coming back, but then again, I’m pretty skeptical about free will too.
Nah, if my doubts are actually irrational, they’ll clear up pretty fast anyway. Because...
I want in. Just find an answer to the free will question. I don't care what it is. Any answer will do. 🙂