CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › IT › Hardware › Desktops › Fix this old junk or just scrap it?

Fix this old junk or just scrap it?

Started by Grace Wood5 · · 👁 4 views · 143 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Grace Wood5Bryan Taylor6crimsonstag84mellowtiger83Robert Rodriguez2analogtiger19Kimberly Gomez34blueheron24ruggedbison40fadedorca66Linda Smith5wiredotter14Alexander Moore67electricbadger9wearymason4Kenneth Jones70
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#1 ·
Alright, I’ve got a boot issue. It’s telling me I need to replace the "spark plugs and platinum"—basically, some hardware component is shot. 😉 It takes about forty minutes just to get the thing to start up. During that whole wait, the only thing happening on my monitor is the power LED blinking on and off.
I don't need anything high-end, so I’m wondering if this is even worth fixing, or if I should just scrap it and look for a cheap new or used rig for around $3,000.
Intel Core i3 3.07GHz, socket 1156 LGA
ASUS (Intel) H55M-LE motherboard
4 GB RAM
NVIDIA GeForce GTX series 2GB
500W power supply

Punching the wall and praying "why now, when I'm broke" hasn't done much to help. If you guys have any ideas, lay them on me.

Edith: To save you all from asking about the GPU, here it is:

image
Bryan Taylor6 Bryan Taylor6 Active Member
179 messages
joined Oct 2017
#2 ·
If it’s taking 40 minutes to boot, something is definitely wrong... You need to check your BIOS settings, monitor your temperatures, and look at your CPU clock speeds. Run some diagnostic tools to see what's actually happening. It could be a memory issue, a motherboard problem, or maybe your hard drive is just dying and struggling to keep up...

Reinstalling the OS would make a huge difference. Grab Norton and run a scan—it has options to speed things up by cleaning out junk you don't need... Actually, that might be the best first step. Just scan the whole thing and download some free antivirus software like Norton...

If you decide to buy new parts, grab a 400W power supply from something like Corsair $107 and an SSD... Try that first to see if performance improves. If not, then you're looking at a full rebuild. For a setup with an Intel Core i3, a Gigabyte motherboard with a 320 chipset, and 8GB of DDR4 RAM—though 4GB might suffice if you aren't doing heavy work—you could probably get away with $733
...
Roughly speaking, the CPU is $500, the motherboard is under $500, the power supply is $300, and you can find an SSD for about $450. Add in 4GB of RAM for $133, use your old case, and keep the old hard drive for storage if it's still healthy... Total should be around $717
...
Sell off your old CPU, motherboard, RAM, and graphics card to offset the cost
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#3 ·
Hey, man. 🙂
I’m not going to waste my breath talking about stuff I don't understand, so I'll just drop this rig off at a shop in Downtown (right by my place) and see what they quote me. 😳
Back when I cleaned out all the dust two months ago and swapped the CPU cooler, I did a fresh install of 64-bit Windows 7 Pro—miraculously a legal 😁 version—and I ran the latest Norton straight from a thumb drive, so the machine was already protected before I even hopped online. I've got an automatic scan running once a week.
It’s running two drives, a 500 GB and a 320 GB, both Western Digital and both working fine. Honestly, that 320 GB one came out of an old tower, and for the price, it's a steal.
crimsonstag84 crimsonstag84 Regular
518 messages
joined Jun 2010
#4 ·
Something is definitely off if your boot times are that slow. If the drives aren't hitting bad sectors or anything similar, you're probably looking at a motherboard issue. It could be the power supply, though based on the symptoms, I wouldn't bet on it.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/example-listing

I’d probably throw a 120GB SSD and an old GPU into this build... unfortunately, it'll likely sell before you even figure out what's broken with yours 😁.
mellowtiger83 mellowtiger83 Regular
466 messages
joined Aug 2014
#5 ·
Joseph Allen71 said:So, I am having some issues getting things started. It seems I need a "spark plug and platinum" replacement. 😉 This computer takes about forty minutes just to boot up. During that entire window, the only thing visible on my monitor is the power LED blinking on and off.
I don't need anything high-end, so I am wondering if it is worth fixing this, or if I should just look for something new or used for around $3,000.
Intel Core i3 540 3.07GHz, socket 1156 LGA
ASUS (Intel) H55M-LE motherboard
4 GB RAM
NVIDIA GeForce GTX series 2GB
500W power supply

Staring at the wall and chanting "why now, right when I'm short on cash" hasn't helped much. If you have any ideas, please share them.

Edith: To prevent too many questions regarding the GPU, here it is:

image

Of course there will be questions about the graphics card. We all know the 5670 chip, but there are massive speed differences between the DDR3 and DDR5 versions. Yours is basically the 95% slower version with an absurd amount of VRAM for no reason!🙂
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#6 ·
crimsonstag84 said:Something's definitely off if your boot times are that slow. If you've already checked the drives and there aren't any bad sectors or hardware errors, you're likely looking at a motherboard issue. It could technically be the power supply, but based on the symptoms you're describing, I wouldn't bet on that.

I’ve seen some junk lately, but this listing is a special kind of mess. Someone is trying to move a PC that belongs in a museum, not on a desk. The specs are a joke. We're looking at an old Intel Core i3 paired with an NVIDIA GeForce GTX series card. If you think this thing can handle anything modern without choking, you're dreaming. It’s basically a glorified paperweight at this point. They’re running Windows 7 Pro, too—which, let's be honest, is a massive security nightmare waiting to happen. You'd be better off running Norton on a toaster than trying to browse the web safely on this setup. I remember back when I was building my first rig in Chicago, I learned the hard way that you can't just slap together outdated parts and call it a "gaming PC." You end up wasting money on hardware that can't even open a Chrome tab without stuttering. This seller clearly doesn't get it. Save your cash. Don't fall for the "good deal" trap. This isn't a bargain; it's a headache.

I’d probably just slap a 120GB SSD in this thing and throw an old graphics card in there to get by. But honestly? It’ll be sold before you even figure out what the hell is actually wrong with it. 😁

I'm going to try and patch this mess up. Right now, I've got 1,600 pieces scattered everywhere—it's like trying to organize the entire Appalachian Mountains. 🙂

mellowtiger83 said:Look, man, it’s totally normal to have questions about a GPU. We all know what chip is under the hood, but there's a massive performance gap between DDR3 and DDR5 memory that people tend to overlook. The card you're talking about is basically running at 95% slower speeds, just loaded up with a ridiculous amount of VRAM that doesn't actually do anything for you.🙂

I picked up this rig about five or six years ago as a pre-built budget build. It was basically just some kid's hand-me-down that he used to scrape by playing World of Warcraft on the lowest settings until he finally saved up enough for something decent. Now, I’ve inherited the thing. Honestly, for what I actually do with it, the graphics card is complete overkill—I''m just talking the occasional game of chess, watching YouTube clips, or a quick round of Solitaire.
Robert Rodriguez2 Robert Rodriguez2 Regular
353 messages
joined Jul 2015
#7 ·
mellowtiger83 said:Man, obviously there's gonna be questions about the GPU. We get the chip itself, but the speed gap between DDR3 and DDR5 is massive. Yours is basically 95% slower just because of the memory, even if it has a ridiculous amount of VRAM!🙂

For what he's doing, the card's memory doesn't matter at all, especially since he isn't gaming.
As long as it puts an image on the monitor, nothing else matters.

Listen, Joseph Allen71, regardless of whether you fix this or buy a new PC, you need an SSD. I picked one up about two months ago and it’s a game changer.

And getting three sticks of RAM is pointless. For your needs, don't bother with used gear when you can grab a decent new setup for that kind of money. 🙂

Obviously, we're talking web browsing, movies, music—that stuff. If you were gaming, which I don't think you are, it'd be a different story. 😛

Your current rig is perfectly fine for those tasks. The problem is you can't find new motherboards anymore, and buying used ones is just asking for trouble. It's throwing money away.

You might still find some new CPUs that fit your current RAM, so if you just swap the processor and the board, you can pretty much reuse everything else.
analogtiger19 analogtiger19 Active Member
134 messages
joined Dec 2016
#8 ·
Let's try to figure out why his PC is lagging so hard.

Can you pull up the specs or just read the label on the power supply? Need to know exactly what model we're looking at and roughly how old the thing is.
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#9 ·
Robert Rodriguez2 said:For what he's actually doing, the amount of VRAM on the card doesn't even matter—especially since he isn't playing games.
When I'm trying to push an image to the screen, nothing else matters. Period.

Look, Joseph Allen71, regardless of whether you decide to fix this thing up or just cut your losses and buy a new rig, there is one thing I’d absolutely recommend: get an SSD. I picked one up for my own setup about two months ago, and honestly, it’s been a total game-changer.

Buying a rig with only 3 sticks of RAM is just a waste of time. For what you're looking to do, there’s zero point in hunting down used parts when you can take that same amount of cash and walk away with a decent, brand-new PC. 🙂

Sure, if you just want to browse the web, watch movies, listen to music, and stuff like that, it's fine. But if you actually plan on gaming—and I'm assuming you don't—then we're talking about a completely different story. 😛

Look, your current setup is perfectly fine for the tasks you mentioned. My only issue is that you won't find any new motherboards like that on the shelves anymore. You’d be forced to hunt down used parts, and honestly, buying secondhand gear that could be a total lemon is just throwing money down the drain.

You can still find plenty of new motherboards that support your current RAM, so if you’re planning on upgrading, you might just want to swap out the CPU and the board. Honestly, you can probably hang onto most of your other gear.

If I can scrape together about $100 to $120, I’ll get it fixed. If not, I'll just let it run until it dies, then pick up a replacement after New Year's. Something like this....or something like that, honestly.Insane. Regarding Intel. 😳
That SSD really should have just waited for better times.

analogtiger19 said:Let's see if we can actually figure out why his PC is lagging so much.

Can you open up the case and read exactly what power supply is in there from the label? And how old would you say it is, roughly?

The power supply is an MS PRO 550W ATX P4, and it’s been running for five or six years now. If you're going to kill me, I can't remember exactly when the warranty expired—I had to scramble through all my old paperwork just to check. Either way, once it starts screaming at me, I'm planning on "selling" it to the local scrap yard.
crimsonstag84 crimsonstag84 Regular
518 messages
joined Jun 2010
#10 ·
Don't bother with those pre-built desktops, especially if they're running an older generation processor 😛

You usually just end up with a junk power supply (again), a bottom-of-the-barrel motherboard, and a measly 4GB of RAM... I guess it’s actually much easier to put something better together in about 5 minutes.
mellowtiger83 mellowtiger83 Regular
466 messages
joined Aug 2014
#11 ·
Look, man, an MS power supply that's been running for five, maybe six or even more years? It’s just not going to be reliable anymore.

I'm not talking about modern MS units, which have actually improved quite a bit lately🙂.

Back then, the only decent thing they made was their 400W platinum model; nothing else really held up.

It's highly probable your PC is acting up specifically because of that power supply.

By the way, try resetting your BIOS to default settings! Sometimes that does the trick, though there's a slight chance the motherboard itself is faulty (not that I'd bet on it).
mellowtiger83 mellowtiger83 Regular
466 messages
joined Aug 2014
#12 ·
OrangeTurtle said:The Q6600 is actually a solid processor. With 4GB of RAM, you can get quite a bit done. 😉

You’re just as bad as I am when it comes to hijacking threads😁, that Q6600 belongs in the other thread. This one has an i3 540, if my memory serves me correctly.

One quick side note regarding starting new threads: if you think a faulty motherboard is why things are slowing down, you're in a tough spot. It’s an LGA 1156 socket board, and those are impossible to find these days—and even when you do, they cost a fortune.
Kimberly Gomez34 Kimberly Gomez34 Regular
686 messages
joined Jul 2009
#13 ·
If you’ve got two drives, I assume you’ve already tried installing an OS on both? If you have, then I seriously doubt both disks died at once. It’s much more likely that your motherboard kicked the bucket. That’s the only reason I’d even consider replacing this entire setup. Finding reliable parts for these older platforms is like searching for a needle in a haystack, and honestly, dumping money into used, vintage motherboards from who-knows-when is just bad business.
blueheron24 blueheron24 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Dec 2017
#14 ·
You don't necessarily have to overhaul the entire platform. If you're dealing with SATA HDDs and DDR3 memory, the selection out there is actually incredibly vast. 😉 I'm no specialist when it comes to that specific socket, so...
Robert Rodriguez2 Robert Rodriguez2 Regular
353 messages
joined Jul 2015
#15 ·
Joseph Allen71 said:If I can scrape together maybe $500-$600, I’ll fix it. If not, I'll just let it run until it dies, then grab something like this or whatever after New Year's. Honestly, mentally I'm already committed to Intel. 😳
SSD could have waited for better days.

The power supply... it's an MS PRO 550W ATX P4 and it's about 5 or 6 years old. Don't kill me, I don't remember exactly when the warranty expired, but I dug through all my paperwork. Either way, if it starts screaming at me, I was planning to "sell" it to the local scrap yard.

Pre-built rigs are a hard "no" for me.
Better to build from parts. Most shops will throw in free shipping if you spend over $1000. Only reason I'd suggest an Intel PC right now is because their CPUs have integrated graphics, whereas those Ryzen chips don't.
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#16 ·
Alright, folks and trolls alike, thanks for the advice and for being willing to help an IT-illiterate idiot like me.

As soon as the trash can started acting up, my first thought was just to haul it straight to the local landfill—thanks again for showing me that I actually had it right for once.

I’m just going to let this thing run until it dies; there’s no point throwing money at old junk. Now that I've got a taste for it, I've been eyeing this other thread. If any of those bins are still for sale after New Year's, I'll finally get this headache sorted out.
If they aren't, expect another one of my "help me" posts. 🙈

*Yeah, Trinitron, that goes out to you. 😛
mellowtiger83 mellowtiger83 Regular
466 messages
joined Aug 2014
#17 ·
@Joseph Allen71/">@@Joseph Allen71, you should probably reset the BIOS to factory defaults, try plugging the hard drive into a different SATA connector, or even just disconnect the drive that doesn't have Windows on it.

Perform a fresh installation of Windows by completely formatting the drive and recreating the partition—actually, go ahead and create two partitions this time.

One of those steps might do the trick.

Don't mention it.
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#18 ·
mellowtiger83 said:Joseph Allen71, try resetting your BIOS to factory defaults first. Then, try plugging the drive into a different SATA connector. If that doesn't work, just unplug the drive that doesn't have Windows on it and see if it boots.

If you want to do a fresh Windows installation the right way, don't just hit "reset." You need to wipe the slate completely clean. Format the entire drive, kill the old partition, and build it from scratch. I’m talking about creating two separate partitions this time—keep your OS on one and your data on the other. It’s much cleaner.

Maybe some of this could actually help.

Don't mention it!

Thanks for the effort, man, but I'll pass on that one.
I’ll have to foot the entire bill at the shop for everything you just listed. I know how this goes—it's like being Mary in a courtroom, always the one left holding the bag.
I'm just too exhausted and honestly too lazy to sit around studying stuff I never wanted to learn in the first place. Look, if you really need my help, I’ll wire up the electricity for your entire house, but don't expect me to touch anything under 220V. That's just not my speed.
What can I even tell you? You start talking about resetting the BIOS, and all I hear is incoherent mumbling—exactly like those kids in Philadelphia. Peanuts They’re listening to us adults talk. 😉
mellowtiger83 mellowtiger83 Regular
466 messages
joined Aug 2014
#19 ·
Joseph Allen71 said:I appreciate the effort, man, but I’ll pass.
Everything you just listed is stuff I’d have to pay a pro to handle, because let’s face it—I’m about as useful as a broken Mary when it comes to this kind of thing...
Besides, I’m just too lazy and too unmotivated to start learning something I never had any interest in to begin with. If you need me, I can wire up the electricity for the whole house, but anything involving less than 220V is simply out of my league.
What can I say? You mention resetting the BIOS, and all I hear is incoherent mumbling, much like how kids at Peanuts perceive adult conversation. 😉

Look, buddy, bring it over to my place in Philadelphia and I'll fix it for free if you just buy a coffee for the girl working the counter at the local deli🙂.

That's the only catch! Honestly, I don't drink that egg coffee crap—only dreamers believe in that!
Grace Wood5 Grace Wood5 Active MemberOP
116 messages
joined Aug 2010
#20 ·
🤣 Coffee with milk has always been better than that egg coffee nonsense. How does your schedule look from Tuesday onwards? 🙂

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads