CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Culture & Entertainment › Music › Brit Floyd - Best Pink Floyd concert at Madison Square Garden, Washington, D.C.

Brit Floyd - Best Pink Floyd concert at Madison Square Garden, Washington, D.C.

Started by Morgan Chase4 · · 👁 7 views · 40 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Morgan Chase4Tyler DoyleMelissa Hughes28Henry Adams3Sean Bishop22Dana Reed3Grace Lewis6Kenneth Peterson4Andrew Castillo86rustymaker5bluescout63Nancy Nelson55Megan Edwards4velvetfalcon522Carol Garcia5Andrew Roberts3crimsonsailor15Rachel Turner2
Tyler Doyle Tyler Doyle Newcomer
5 messages
joined Jun 2010
#21 ·
That was actually pretty incredible 🙂
Sound quality was spot on. I’d be complaining if I hadn't been there.
It's honestly eerie how much those two male vocals mimic Roger Waters and David Gilmour. 😁 I can't even imagine the amount of practice they put in to nail that.

A massive virtual facepalm for the guy next to me who shouted, "Alright, now play something we actually know!" right after Pink Floyd 🤦
bluescout63 bluescout63 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Nov 2013
#22 ·
I’m a massive Pink Floyd enthusiast—I’ve been to over 20 shows, ranging from the original lineup to various tribute acts. To my mind, two Brit Floyd shows stand alone as the absolute best live performances I have ever witnessed. Honestly, they surpassed even the original Pink Floyd set in Vienna and Roger Waters's performance of The Wall at the Arena. They are simply phenomenal. I’m already counting down the days until they return.
Nancy Nelson55 Nancy Nelson55 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Oct 2008
#23 ·
I was seriously blown away. I’d heard nothing but good things about them, especially regarding the vocals, but man... this blew all my expectations out of the water. It was a perfect ten. The way they performed High Hopes was just phenomenal—that little guitar solo? Pure bliss. The lighting setup was incredible, and those lasers during the second half were spot on too; everything felt so perfectly timed. Sound was great overall, though if I had to nitpick, maybe a tiny bit too much bass for my taste, but honestly, it was an amazing show😉

I'm really hoping they make another stop here next year, just like the guitarist mentioned at the end of the night.
rustymaker5 rustymaker5 Regular
352 messages
joined Mar 2008
#24 ·
Pure insanity, they were absolutely phenomenal! I was right there in the front row, standing on my feet for four hours straight, but honestly, every single second was worth it... 👍
Tyler Doyle Tyler Doyle Newcomer
5 messages
joined Jun 2010
#25 ·
bluescout63 said:I'm a massive Pink Floyd fan—attended over 20 shows, ranging from the original lineup to various tribute acts. Honestly, two Brit Floyd shows were hands down the best concerts I've ever seen. They actually beat out the original Pink Floyd in Vienna and Roger Waters's The Wall at the Arena. They’re just phenomenal to me. Can't wait for their next tour.

Hold on, what do you mean? 😁
Which specific concert?
Sean Bishop22 Sean Bishop22 Newcomer
5 messages
joined Nov 2012
#26 ·
So, through some stroke of pure luck, I actually ended up making it to the concert, and honestly? It was a win. 😁 Third time's the charm, I guess. It was miles better than the previous two times I caught a show like this, even if I still have a few nitpicks. I’m still going to argue that the price tag of $73 is just plain ridiculous. And seriously, if you’re one of those people trying to compare Pink Floyd, David Gilmour, or especially Roger Waters to Brit Floyd, please, just get real. 🙂 For anyone who missed out on the show, my advice is simple: don't let the next one pass you by under any circumstances.
Megan Edwards4 Megan Edwards4 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jan 2014
#27 ·
I know it’s not really an apples-to-apples comparison, but compared to seeing Roger Waters in Miami, this sound setup was pretty amateur hour—honestly, I left feeling kind of let down. Especially since they kicked things off with The Wall.

The second half of the set was way better than the first, particularly those last few songs (they absolutely killed it with the OOTD). As for the light show, it was basically the same thing as last year, which didn't really do much for me.

If you ask me, last year was actually better. Sean Bishop22, you hit the nail on the head there—the ticket price is definitely too steep for what you actually get, especially when I remember paying the exact same amount to see Waters. I mean, credit where it's due, they were on stage for almost three hours.

But I still can't wrap my head around the fact that they didn't play a single thing from the Barrett era. Not one. It's honestly embarrassing.

Oh, and one more thing... the promoters... The concert is supposed to start at 8 PM on paper, but they don't even open the damn doors until half an hour before. 🙄

All in all, it was a decent enough night, but I seriously doubt I'll be going to a third one of their shows.
velvetfalcon522 velvetfalcon522 Member
10 messages
joined Aug 2013
#28 ·
Mine was the $33 😁 it was incredible—they played and sang their hearts out, and I even managed to snag some autographs 🙂 if they tour again in the coming years, I'm definitely going back!
Carol Garcia5 Carol Garcia5 Newcomer
1 message
joined Dec 2013
#29 ·
Saw the bio at the concert—those guys were phenomenal... respect.
bluescout63 bluescout63 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Nov 2013
#30 ·
I was there back in '94 for the Pink Floyd concert in Vienna, and again in 2011 at the Madison Square Garden show for Roger Waters's The Wall. I’ve been listening to almost nothing but Pink Floyd for over 25 years—I know their catalog inside out, owning nearly every live recording, documentary, and book out there. In my honest opinion, the original lineup just didn't carry that same raw energy they had in their prime—an energy I actually felt much more intensely during the Brit Floyd concert. No offense intended, it's just how it felt to me...
rustymaker5 rustymaker5 Regular
352 messages
joined Mar 2008
#31 ·
Anyway, let me try my luck here too... I managed to snap some absolutely insane photos on my phone from right in the front row, but then in a total moment of stupidity, I accidentally wiped them all out. 🙂
Does anyone happen to know how to fix this, or maybe someone would be willing to help me get them back? 🙂
I’ve already tried messing around with it myself, but nothing is working... 😢
Sean Bishop22 Sean Bishop22 Newcomer
5 messages
joined Nov 2012
#32 ·
rustymaker5 said:By the way, let me try this here too... I took some absolutely insane photos on my phone from the front row, and then in a total moment of stupidity, I accidentally deleted all of them. 🙂
Does anyone here actually know how to fix this, and would be willing to help me get them back? 🙂
I've already tried doing it myself, but I'm just getting nowhere...😢

Go ask Madonna. ☕
velvetfalcon522 velvetfalcon522 Member
10 messages
joined Aug 2013
#33 ·
I've got a few photos, but the quality is pretty terrible...
Andrew Roberts3 Andrew Roberts3 Active Member
51 messages
joined Aug 2010
#34 ·
That was an incredible show—honestly, I think it actually topped last year's performance, even though I wasn't even sure if I felt like going in the first place. But man, from those very first notes of "Outside The Wall," my mood just completely shifted... total game changer. When they hit "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" and "Comfortably Numb," the crowd just lost it. They absolutely crushed those. My only real gripe? "Mother." All that extra vocal gymnastics with the backing singers felt totally unnecessary. That song is supposed to be this raw, intimate dialogue between a mother and her son; you don't need all those vocal flourishes getting in the way of the emotion. And seriously, why on earth didn't they play "Hey You" or "Learning to Fly"? Those two are basically staples at these shows... you almost expect them to be part of the setlist. It’s not like I sat there feeling empty without them, I’m just pointing out they were missing. Also, such a bummer that Algie didn't take flight... I'm not sure if they usually let him soar, but maybe the small arena just felt a bit too cramped to pull that stunt off.
Megan Edwards4 Megan Edwards4 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jan 2014
#35 ·
https://fbcdn-sphotos-e-a.akamaihd.n...40194455_o.jpg
crimsonsailor15 crimsonsailor15 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Dec 2013
#36 ·
Sean Bishop22 said:Just ask Madonna. ☕

I honestly can't wrap my head around it. It’s wild how someone like Madonna—who, let's be honest, can be a total clown—can move 15,000 tickets for a concert in such a short window, yet when it comes to The Wall, the sales were practically non-existent. Even for those legendary fans... it just doesn't add up. $33Dear Miami!!!
Hey everyone.😛Are we seriously comparing Pink Floyd to some pale imitation? I have to wonder where that kind of audacity comes from. Do you actually know who David Gilmour and Roger Waters are, or are you just talking big about some Brit Floyd concert? The Wall is Waters's life's work, and nobody—absolutely nobody—is ever going to perform it quite like him. Not in a thousand years. And Brit Floyd? Who even is that? Have any of you actually been to a massive show at Madison Square Garden or Dodger Stadium? Honestly, Algie fell down because of the embarrassment you're all causing.
Alright, go ahead—start stalling. I know that’s exactly what you're planning to do.
Melissa Hughes28 Melissa Hughes28 Newcomer
1 message
joined Apr 2013
#37 ·
crimsonsailor15 said:blah blah blah...David Gilmour...blah blah blah

Wait, do you mean David Gilmour?
crimsonsailor15 crimsonsailor15 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Dec 2013
#38 ·
Edward Williams54 said:Are you talking about David Gilmour?

Yeah, okay, my bad... I think I’ve had one too many stouts tonight. I can already feel the ten negative marks coming my way. In America, that's at least ten points! The admin clearly has a crush on me, haha.
crimsonsailor15 crimsonsailor15 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Dec 2013
#39 ·
🙂
Edward Williams54 said:you mean Gilmour?

Aren't you one of us too, Brutus? Reading through your points, I actually thought we were on the same page here.
Let's not waste our energy bickering over the parasites living off someone else's legacy, don't you think?
Rachel Turner2 Rachel Turner2 Active Member
53 messages
joined Sep 2022
#40 ·
I'm feeling it again. Really hoping they bring the tour back to St.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads