CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Miscellaneous › Feedback & Suggestions › Isn't that a bit overkill?

Isn't that a bit overkill?

Started by Gerald Hill2 · · 👁 4 views · 2 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Gerald Hill2ambermason16
Gerald Hill2 Gerald Hill2 MemberOP
15 messages
joined May 2008
#1 ·
I've been posting here for 10 years now.
And honestly, just in the last two weeks since I started posting in the soap opera sections, I've racked up more warnings than I have in my entire history on all the various American message boards combined.

I should probably mention that the moderators have been patient, and I’m sure they’ve looked the other way a few times too. I’m pretty new to this specific part of the site, so I really didn't know the rules—especially since they were updated recently, maybe back in December.

I don't have anything against the mods; people are fine, and they're just following the rules.
But I just don't get why the rules in the soap opera sections are so incredibly strict??? 😕

I mean, we're talking about soap operas, for goodness sake. 😁 😳

Couldn't those rules be loosened up just a little bit?
What would it even take?

So, I just got my latest warning because of a post where I was discussing the plot of a series alongside some real-life events, specifically regarding local customs in a certain part of the country, and I also suggested someone reach out via private message to another user who clearly knows their stuff.

I genuinely don't understand what's so wrong or punishable about that. Why would that even be against the rules? 🤔
It just doesn't seem to make any sense.

I totally get the restrictions on sharing piracy links, and I get the ban on quoting posts that include images—though, I guess, I did miss one tiny little image and got flagged for it, so I see the logic there. I also get the rules about spoilers, specific TV shows, and actor info.
But splitting hairs over whether you can talk about a custom related to a show on the "culture" board or wherever... breaking a single show discussion into ten different forums and sub-forums just to follow every single rule feels a bit much.
It's hard to keep track of everything, plus most people watching the actual show aren't hanging out in those niche culture boards, and since it's part of the show's setting, I just don't get why we can't discuss it right there in the main thread...
I feel like more warnings are handed out here than in the politics section, which is usually the most controversial area on any forum. 🤣
To me, it just doesn't add up. It doesn't fit the vibe of the sub-forum at all (I mean, come on, soap operas 😁) and it's just way too strict.

Or is it just me? 🤔
ambermason16 ambermason16 Active Member
213 messages
joined Apr 2009
#2 ·
You’ve racked up three warnings here. Based on how you're acting, it feels like you've been banned a hundred times already. 🙂

You earned this strike because—despite the moderator warning you on the previous page—you decided to drag the conversation back to those draconian laws in Islamic countries, stories about little girls being killed just for suspected dating, and all that nonsense. This thread is about a Turkish drama on the NBC network. That kind of debate has absolutely no business being here. Especially when it's presented in such a sensationalist, wildly misinformed way. Not to mention, it’s downright offensive.

I should probably point out that the moderators have been patient and likely let a few things slide since I'm new to this section of the forum. I truly didn't know the rules, especially since they were updated recently—back in December, if I recall.

It's very likely we did let things slide, but it's also very likely you could have avoided this strike entirely by actually reading the rules. It's January 26th; it's not like you didn't have the time. 🙂

Regarding the volume and strictness of the rules: the Soap Opera sub-forum has been around for ages, and every single rule exists for a reason. Some are general rules that apply to all the sub-forums, while others were created over time because they were clearly needed. If you take a moment to actually sit down and read them thoroughly, you'll see there's nothing exotic going on here. Every rule follows a logic.
Gerald Hill2 Gerald Hill2 MemberOP
15 messages
joined May 2008
#3 ·
I don't really think I was treated unfairly regarding any of my warnings.
I probably should have received even more, honestly, given how strict the rules are in this subforum.

And even though I didn't catch a moderator's warning on the previous page, I guess that doesn't excuse me from getting a strike if those are the rules; whether I see the warning or not, I should probably just be reading more carefully.

Still, the fact remains that without any arguing, being stubborn, or having any bad intentions, I ended up with three strikes—and who knows how many others were just forgiven 🙂—all in just a few days (I'm not sure what counts as "a lot" to everyone else, but to me, this feels like a lot, especially since I only had two strikes in ten years).
Based on some of the reactions here, I get the impression there are other users who feel the same way, like they're constantly walking on eggshells just waiting for a strike to hit. That's just my take on it.
I even noticed some people couldn't access the forum for a couple of days (I'm not sure how many strikes it takes to trigger that).

Regarding what was mentioned...
The mere fact that there’s specific tracking for this kind of offense suggests it's recognized by authorities in other countries too.
Nick didn't say that all Black/Asian/Hispanic/White people are a certain way; we were just discussing what happens in the show and what the series itself explores, pointing toward a very specific part of the country.

So, I'll say it again: I'm not complaining about the strikes, and I'm not complaining about the moderators (in fact, I'm not even sure exactly who moderates everything, but I'm sure they've been lenient with me a few times). It just seems to me that the rules here are much stricter than in other more serious sections of the forum.

I get why we need rules, but maybe there should be a bit of common sense involved. You can't expect that within a thread about a TV series, we can discuss the legal aspects on the Law forum, or the cultural and traditional parts on the Culture forum—as if every single segment of the show needs its own separate thread in a different section... like discussing gutting intestines? For what purpose?

This is just one series I'm following, and once it's over, I'll probably be gone from this part of the forum anyway.
But this all feels a bit much... generally speaking, and especially considering we're talking about soap operas. 😁

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads