CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Miscellaneous › Feedback & Suggestions › Moderation rules on the NYT forum

Moderation rules on the NYT forum

Started by Olivia Stewart2 · · 👁 3 views · 8 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Olivia Stewart2Amanda Hughes37driftingtinker
Olivia Stewart2 Olivia Stewart2 MemberOP
17 messages
joined May 2024
#1 ·
I’ve recently been hit with a series of completely bizarre bans on the Politics board that defy all common sense. First, I was banned for criticizing feminism as a concept, accompanied by this explanation: "Misogynistic trolling regarding the Abortion debate." What exactly did I write that was misogynistic?

I was critiquing feminist ideology and feminist activism as whole movements. Does that somehow violate the forum rules? Is this platform intended exclusively for people with a progressive worldview, where freedom of speech and the critique of progressive-leftist ideologies are strictly forbidden? Then there was a second ban stemming from what I consider a very well-argued critique of Eric Adams and Coco Vandeweghe, but apparently, a certain moderator didn't appreciate the tone and slapped me with a ban for "stupid trolling."

I would appreciate some guidance on how to avoid being labeled a troll on the Politics board, as my goal is simply to avoid further bans in that subforum. However, reading other users' posts leaves me quite confused and sends nothing but mixed signals. To put it mildly, the guidelines aren't exactly clear. In my humble opinion, the general standard of communication is at least several levels lower than mine; one only needs to read the comments of certain regulars who dominate the discourse with their fixations—take McAfee and his cronies, for example—and they remain protected like grizzly bears despite their shameless trolling, constant instigation of arguments, insults, and personal attacks. That duo checks every single box for what defines a troll or a spammer, yet they have managed to survive on this forum for years. Is there some kind of premium tier I haven't been informed about? Do you just pay a fee to do whatever you want? Or are they simply sycophants who align perfectly with the moderators?

So, I thank you in advance for any constructive suggestions...

From my perspective, the current moderation seems pointless because the mindless bickering between users has no real impact. Nobody reads it except for the people involved in the spat itself...
Amanda Hughes37 Amanda Hughes37 Active Member
145 messages
joined Apr 2016
#2 ·
I just took a penalty for trolling—which is exactly why I’m coming to you...
One of my posts vanished.

Back when I was a fan of Zeke, I always felt at home on Politics. If I went a bit too far, I’d just get a private message from a moderator or a warning card, nothing major.

But since I stopped following Zeke, things have changed. I don't support scrapping the reputation system for veteran users, and I have some thoughts on abortion—not that doctors are monsters, per se, but Eric Adams is a total disaster... honestly, I feel like it’s better if I just stay away from there altogether.
driftingtinker driftingtinker Regular
372 messages
joined Jan 2019
#3 ·
Or maybe just don't bother posting this kind of nonsense in the first place:
I'm just waiting until they start installing those water filtration systems right next to the maternity wards, so if we spot an issue, we can deal with it on the spot.

?
Amanda Hughes37 Amanda Hughes37 Active Member
145 messages
joined Apr 2016
#4 ·
driftingtinker said:Or just don't post this kind of nonsense in the first place:

?

Right... look, the forum is full of sentences... What’s next?... some wild exaggerations, I guess. This was actually what bothered you?
Strange.

Did you hand out a red card to our friend Ego when he suggested Chavajda could grow a little ficus in a jar once he has a kid?
driftingtinker driftingtinker Regular
372 messages
joined Jan 2019
#5 ·
You got a link to that post?
Amanda Hughes37 Amanda Hughes37 Active Member
145 messages
joined Apr 2016
#6 ·
No.
driftingtinker driftingtinker Regular
372 messages
joined Jan 2019
#7 ·
Probably just another post that got nuked for no reason at all.
Amanda Hughes37 Amanda Hughes37 Active Member
145 messages
joined Apr 2016
#8 ·
driftingtinker said:You think that post was deleted for no reason, too?

I don't know if it was deleted—I just know it existed, and I already mentioned it.

If you wiped it and handed him a warning, then fine... great.
driftingtinker driftingtinker Regular
372 messages
joined Jan 2019
#9 ·
Yeah. We are.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads