Michael Mendoza7
Newcomer
3 messages
joined Mar 2018
I’m not really feeling the non-linear timeline, and honestly, the way they push the racial themes and feminism felt a bit forced to me. That being said, the actresses are absolutely STUNNING and did such an incredible job! I didn't exactly picture Emma Watson when I imagined Meg, but she actually nailed the role. My one big gripe with the cast is that they used the exact same actresses for both time periods. You'd expect to see some aging, right? Since the girls are supposed to be around 12 to 16 at the start, but the actresses look like they're already 20. Especially Amy—she's meant to be the youngest, but even when she's supposedly 12, she sounds like a chronic smoker! (Kidding, obviously, but seriously, there wasn't a hint of a child's voice there). Timothée fit the role perfectly, though he looks a little too old standing next to the girls, especially later on, since he's supposed to be a young adult. It also bugged me how they stuck to the book word-for-word in some parts but then totally veered off in others; whenever they improvised, it just threw me off. Specifically, the scene where Jo meets the old gentleman felt off, and they completely skipped the part where Meg defends her John. Plus, the romance felt forced during the quiet moments and was missing exactly when it was needed most. The movie was visually gorgeous, though! 😁