Laptop issues and repair advice

So, here’s the deal with my Dell Inspiron. The keyboard completely died on me, so obviously, it needs a replacement. But there’s this other annoying issue when I try to boot up—macOS just won't load. Instead, I get these constant, high-pitched beeps coming from the machine. It’s super unpredictable; maybe once every ten tries, the OS actually boots up without any drama. I took it into a local repair shop to get a diagnosis, and they told me the keyboard was broken... which, hello, I already knew that! I literally told them that when I dropped it off. They also claimed the OS loads perfectly fine, which is just flat-out wrong based on my experience. Now, they want to charge me about $320 to install the new keyboard they’re ordering.
I’ve got a few things on my mind: Is that a reasonable price just to swap out a keyboard?
And why on earth would the computer be acting up during startup like that?
Also, do I really have the right to refuse paying that diagnostic fee since they didn't actually *do* anything besides state the obvious?

Sent from my 9005X using Reddit

The price is fair for anyone willing to pay it—if you don't like it, no hard feelings! I can't just start swapping out parts via $167 without your green light, so feel free to keep looking elsewhere.
As for everything else: what was the actual issue you reported when you brought it in? Everything from the diagnostic fee to the final bill depends on that.
Proper lifting should be demonstrated right then and there, so is this really just a case of "he said, she said"?

what is wrong with my Samsung

I'm wondering if this price is actually fair. I noticed another repair shop down the street charges $25 just for the labor to swap out a keyboard, especially since you can easily grab a replacement online for about $50. When I dropped it off, I made sure to mention that the keyboard is dead and that nine times out of ten, the laptop won't even boot up the OS. It just sits there emitting these constant, piercing, high-pitched beeps. Honestly, it sounds like some component just totally fried itself.

Sent from my Samsung using Reddit

That keyboard is used, but they’re offering you a brand new one. At that price point, there's no way they'd be installing your old one; plus, they don't offer any warranty anyway.
If the laptop is running fine, just boot it up a few times while you're still at the shop...

what is wrong with my Samsung

I actually tried firing it up a few times right in front of them. Which basically means they skipped the full diagnostic entirely, even though I gave them a super detailed, step-by-step breakdown of exactly what was going on. So, $212 a new laptop keyboard plus $50 the labor—does that sound like a fair deal to you guys?

Sent from my Samsung using Reddit

Have you actually taken a look at what these kinds of keyboards are going for online lately? They aren't even remotely $212. Honestly, you won't find them for even half that amount.

So $33 you can find a keyboard on eBay, but they’re mostly standard US layouts...

What I did was just pop the letters for the special characters off my old one and stick them onto the new one—plus I fixed up the colon, semicolon, and those symbols at the top to match an American layout. It's honestly just a 20-30 minute job if you have the patience...

edit

Just make sure you check first whether your keys actually come off or not... mine were fine, but you never know. Just look up some tutorials on YouTube to see how it's done before you start prying things apart.
I'd much rather just spend $33 swapping out the keys from my old board than shell out $167 or more
for a whole new setup...
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S series using Reddit

Nathan Cooper80 said:Have you actually checked what those keyboards go for online? They aren't even close $212. Not even half the price.

Man, seriously. People don't want to mess around with their laptops themselves—maybe they can't or just won't—so they take it straight to an authorized service center. Those guys give you a quote for a keyboard sourced through official channels and stick to their sticker price.
A keyboard like that could easily run you $150 or more. You're paying for the labor hours, the fact that it's a professional shop and not some guy in a garage, plus sales tax. That's why the price is what it is.

Is it too much?
Yeah, it is. Just like everything else with laptops—they sell them cheap just to rip you off on maintenance later. It’s basically the same racket as inkjet printers and stuff like that.

@Keith Lee94/">@@Keith Lee94
The price is "fair" because it's transparently stated, so hey, it's your call. Nobody is forcing you to use official channels, but those channels come with a premium.
Your other option is hunting on eBay or Amazon, where you can grab used or refurbished ones for maybe $25-$30 including shipping... then you just install it yourself, if you actually know how...

>selling it way below market value

>The price is "fair" because it’s clearly stated, so take it or leave it.

Nothing actually sells below cost. You see margins of maybe 1-10% here and there, sure, but selling something for less than the wholesale price plus a tiny profit? No. The price for the keyboard and the labor is just way too high for an old laptop. It’s not worth it, regardless of whether the repair shop has to deal with a mountain of taxes, rent, and payroll—that’s hardly their concern, is it?

Honestly, just take the laptop to a different shop. These guys are incompetent and overpriced. Worst case scenario, find some local IT guy who can knock it out for $200-$100 including the part.

As for the diagnostic fee, you don't have much of a choice. If you don't pay, you aren't getting your laptop back. They want $100-$50? They probably cracked the casing, checked the connections, and gave you a quote for the fix. And regarding that other issue... maybe they just couldn't replicate the glitch?

Got a question here—and look, I don't have all the specifics because I'm asking for someone else, but I can dig up more details if needed.

Basically, this Dell Inspiron with an i5 that's maybe two years old got sent in for repairs. Someone spilled water all over the keyboard, and now the LCD connector on the motherboard is fried along with the LCD cable. The repair shop is talking about replacing the whole motherboard and a new LCD cable.

How bad is this damage actually, and is it even worth fixing? Like, do they seriously need a brand-new motherboard or is there some other way to patch it up? Anyone got any advice on this mess?

Thanks in advance.

The motherboard usually costs about as much as a brand-new laptop anyway... and a keyboard? Hmm, you could probably find one on eBay for $100. Honestly, it’s just not worth the headache to fix it—especially since you mentioned some water got inside. You never really know if there's more damage lurking under the surface...

My advice? Just sell whatever parts are still working for scrap. Use that cash to grab a new laptop instead.
Still, go ahead and ask them for a quote, just out of curiosity... see what they'd even charge you.

At the end of the day, desktop PCs are different—if a component fails, it's easy and cheap to swap out. Laptops are a whole different beast. Every single model uses its own specific motherboard, and you're stuck buying the exact one from the manufacturer. With desktops, you've got tons of different brands competing, which keeps the prices down.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S series via Reddit

Thanks a ton for the tip. 👍