CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Culture & Entertainment › Movies › George A. Romero: The Legend of the Living Dead

George A. Romero: The Legend of the Living Dead

Started by briskhound2 · · 👁 6 views · 29 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants briskhound2amberfalcon172Donna Gray4Kate Harris4Matthew Anderson4Christian Taylor3Chris Hall47Chloe Reed37rustyscout34Arthur Parker53Chloe Nguyenbriskbison41Gary James88Chloe Palmer2Rebecca FosterLawrence Booth2silverotter2Jessica Morris6Dennis Hall41
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#1 ·
image image image
image imageimage
image imageimage

George A. Romero Wikipedia

So, I was thinking back to *Night of the Living Dead*... you know, that 1968 masterpiece by George A. Romero. It’s wild how much that one film basically laid the groundwork for everything we consider "zombie" today—it’s like the blueprint for the whole damn genre... even if people get all pedantic about what a real zombie actually is now. But man, watching it today, it still hits different. There's just this raw, gritty tension that modern big-budget stuff struggles to replicate... it doesn't need a massive studio or crazy CGI to make your skin crawl. Just some tight camerawork, a claustrophobic setting, and that feeling that things are spiraling out of control... yeah. Definitely a classic.

So, I was thinking about Dawn of the Dead... you know, the 1978 version. It’s funny how much people still talk about it, even decades later. It’s just one of those definitive pieces of cinema that sticks with you—that specific blend of social commentary and pure, unadulterated dread that only John Carpenter really nails like that... It’s not just about the gore, though God knows Tom Savini's work makes it pretty visceral, but there's this underlying sense of consumerism gone wrong that feels almost prophetic now. Just watching them barricade themselves in that mall... it hits different when you realize how much the world has changed since then, yet somehow stays exactly the same. It’s such a classic... definitely a cornerstone of the whole genre.

Day of the Dead... honestly, if you're looking to dive into the deep end of the genre, this is where things get really gritty. It’s that classic period where the practical effects were just unmatched—I mean, nobody did gore quite like Tom Savini, and he absolutely kills it here. It's got that specific, claustrophobic tension that only a well-executed underground bunker setting can provide... just people trapped with their own neuroses while everything outside falls apart. It doesn't have the same polished feel as some of the later stuff, but there's something so raw about how it handles the breakdown of social order. Just pure, unadulterated survivalism mixed with that signature sense of dread... definitely worth a watch if you want to see the genre at its most visceral.

So, I finally sat down to revisit the 1990 remake of Night of the Living Dead... and man, what an experience. It’s definitely one of those movies that sits in a weird spot in your brain—it’s clearly trying to pay homage to the original masterpiece, but it’s also carving out its own path, which isn't always easy when you're dealing with such a massive legacy... It’s got that classic vibe, obviously, but there's a different energy here—more polished, maybe a bit more "Hollywood" than the raw, gritty feeling of the original, if you know what I mean. You can tell they were aiming for something visceral, and in some ways, they hit the mark. The tension builds in a way that feels familiar yet strangely fresh, even if you already know where the carnage is headed... I found myself thinking about how much John Carpenter or even someone like George A. Romero would have looked at this differently. It’s interesting to see how the genre evolves—how the gore and the pacing shift over the decades. There are moments where it really captures that sense of dread, that feeling of being trapped while everything falls apart around you... though it doesn't quite reach those heights of pure, unfiltered terror that the classics do. Still, it’s a solid watch if you're looking for something that respects the roots while offering a slightly different flavor of the apocalypse... just a thought.

So, I was just thinking about that 2004 remake of Dawn of the Dead... you know, the one where they basically reinvented the whole vibe for a modern audience. It’s funny how people react to remakes—some folks just can't stand them if they aren't the original, but honestly? This one actually holds its own... even if it feels a bit more frantic than what we're used to from the classics. It definitely leans harder into that visceral, high-octane energy, which is a far cry from the slower burn you might get with some other horror legends, but hey, it works for what it is... turns out, sometimes a fresh coat of paint on a classic idea isn't the worst thing in the world...

So, I finally got around to revisiting Land of the Dead... just sat down with it the other night. It’s funny how much you forget about the vibe of these later entries until you actually sit through them again. You know, looking back at Romero's whole run—from the absolute legend that was Night of the Living Dead all the way through the stuff like Day of the Dead—it’s clear he was playing a totally different game by the time we hit the mid-2000s. It's definitely a different beast than the classics. When you think about the pure, raw energy of the early films, or even how someone like John Landis handled the genre, this one feels more cynical, maybe even a bit more tired... which I guess is kind of the point? It’s all about that decaying urban landscape and that sense of inevitable collapse. It doesn't have that same tight, claustrophobic tension you get in the original Night of the Living Dead, but there's still something there... something gritty. I mean, compared to the body horror mastery you'd expect from someone like David Cronenberg, or even the sheer stylistic punch of a film like Dawn of the Dead, it's definitely leaning harder into that social commentary side of things. It’s less about the terror of the individual zombie encounter and more about the systemic rot of the world they're living in. Even with Tom Savini's influence hanging in the air, it feels more like a commentary on class warfare wrapped in a layer of gore... if that makes sense. Still, it's worth a watch if you're a fan of the era. It's not quite reaching the heights of the masterpieces, but it’s far from a total wash. Just a weird, messy, unapologetic look at a dying world... typical Romero, really...

So, I finally sat down to check out that 2006 3D version of Night of the Living Dead... honestly, it’s kind of a trip. You know how it is when they take a classic and try to give it that modern "pop" for the theaters? It’s definitely an experience, even if it feels a little different from the original vibe... just one of those things where you wonder why they felt the need to add the extra dimension to everything. Still, it’s worth a look if you’re into seeing how they tried to breathe some new life into the legend... though I guess some things are better left untouched...

So, I finally sat down to revisit Diary of the Dead... and man, it’s definitely one of those movies that leaves you scratching your head a bit. It’s clearly trying to capture that specific, gritty vibe Romero was known for—that raw, documentary-style feeling—but it doesn't quite hit the same high notes as the classics like Night of the Living Dead. It feels a little more self-aware, maybe even a bit meta, which can be a double-edged sword. You get that sense of being right there in the middle of the chaos, which is cool, but sometimes the whole "found footage" approach makes the tension feel a bit thinner than what you'd get from something like Dawn of the Dead. It’s got its moments, sure, but it lacks that certain lightning-in-a-bottle magic that made the original masterpieces so terrifyingly real... just my two cents, anyway.

Day of the Dead

When you’re talking about the Alpha and Omega of the zombie genre—where the undead actually run the show—you have to give credit where it's due. When one guy lays down the foundation and keeps that momentum going for four straight decades, he definitely deserves his own spotlight... Just a little nod to the legend himself. We're talking about a filmmaker who, alongside guys like John Carpenter, John Landis, and David Cronenberg, basically reshaped the entire horror landscape. He took a lot of heat early on and had to wait a good couple of decades to finally get the respect his work demands, but his legacy is pretty much cemented by that original trilogy—Night of the Living Dead, Dawn of the Dead, and Day of the Dead. Of course, his filmography isn't just those three—he’s got plenty of other solid stuff under his belt too, even if they don't quite hit that massive global cult status like Carpenter's flicks... I think I'll skip over those for now, though I should probably mention he tackled one of the best Stephen King adaptations out there—Cell... So, I was thinking about The Dark Half (1993) again... you know, that weird little corner of Stephen King's brain where things get messy. It’s definitely one of those movies that sits in this strange limbo—not quite a full-blown horror masterpiece, but too trippy to just call a standard thriller. It’s got that specific mid-90s vibe that feels almost nostalgic now, though maybe not for the reasons you'd think. It’s interesting how it handles the whole "split identity" thing. You have that tension between the protagonist and his shadow self, which honestly feels like it could have gone in a much darker direction if they hadn't played it a bit safe. It lacks that raw, visceral punch you might get from a classic Romero flick, but there's a certain psychological creepiness there that lingers... even if it doesn't always land perfectly. I guess it's just one of those films that makes you wonder what else might have happened if they had leaned harder into the surrealism. It’s a bit of a cult curiosity at this point, isn't it? Just a strange, moody ride through a fractured psyche... turns out, even when dealing with stuff inspired by King, things can get pretty unpredictable. It’s really all about that friendship—the one that inspired Stephen King to dedicate his novel *Cell* to Romero specifically—and how it mostly centered around those classic films about the walking dead...

So, back in the day, Romero basically botched a business deal regarding the original *Night of the Living Dead*—he lost all say over how it was edited or distributed, and word on the street is he hasn't seen a single dime from it since... which is just wild. Because of that mess, the sequel was actually originally titled *Zombie*, only being rebranded as *Dawn of the Dead* after some international distributors stepped in, realized the sequel had actual legs, and decided to tie it back to the first one to capitalize on the brand. It’s funny, though—kind of like what happened with Carpenter—their films always seemed to carry more prestige over in Europe than they did right here in the States... they were treated more like "artists" there, I guess. Anyway, once he wrapped up his trilogy, Romero jumped back into the genre mostly out of pure spite—and because his buddy Tom Savini, who was in *Dawn of the Dead*, reached out. Part of that spite comes from the fact that the original film basically became public property at this point; anyone can edit it or broadcast it whenever they feel like it, which isn't ideal for the creator. But he was also down for Savini’s idea to finally do things in color, plus he actually had creative control this time around... and getting to work with someone who truly understands the genre doesn't hurt either...

So, after the 2004 remake of *Dawn of the Dead* actually pulls in some decent reviews and cash—you know, following that classic Romero line about how the movie is solid, but it’s hard to really sprint when you're technically dead—he starts filming a new chapter for his own saga. He stays totally silent on that 2006 3D version of *Night of the Living Dead*... which was supposedly based on some script he wrote back in '68... and just moves forward from *Diary of the Dead*. It feels a bit like he's trying to race against all these other remakes, especially since a new version of *Day of the Dead* is right on his heels. Honestly, neither of those follow-up remakes quite hit the mark like *Dawn of the Dead* did, but Romero gets credited as the mastermind behind the whole concept for all of them. I guess he's finally cashing those checks... so he's basically everywhere you look as this genre evolves...

It’s wild that there’s still more to say about this—another chapter in the Zombie saga is coming our way soon. We'll just have to see if the quality actually holds up to that original trilogy, or if we're stuck with that downward slide... because let's be honest, the newer stuff just doesn't hit quite as hard as those first few entries.

image (the poster is still using a working title)

Survival of the Dead (2009)

Survival of the Dead "Sneak Peek" George A. Romero new Zombie movie

George A. Romero talks about premiering Survival of the Dead

I stumbled onto this documentary completely by accident, but it's a solid watch if you're looking for something... I couldn't find it all in one single video or anything, but it's pretty cool seeing all the legends of American horror—you know, guys like Carpenter, Romero, Landis, and Hooper—talking about their own films and the massive footprint they left on the whole genre. So, if anyone's interested...

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 1

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 2

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 3

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 4

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 5

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 6

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 7

THE AMERICAN NIGHTMARE Horror Documentary Part 8

So, here's the question... what's your absolute favorite Zombie movie?
amberfalcon172 amberfalcon172 Member
27 messages
joined Sep 2003
#2 ·
It’s kind of a bummer you framed this whole discussion around nothing but Romero's zombie flicks—I mean, don't get me wrong, they're classics, but personally? I've always found his vampire stuff way more interesting. Martin.

Honestly, when it comes to the whole zombie thing, I really feel like they should've just called it quits after that first trilogy. Seriously—*Land of the Dead* was such absolute garbage that it completely killed my drive to even bother sitting through any of the later sequels.
Donna Gray4 Donna Gray4 Active Member
58 messages
joined Feb 2010
#3 ·
For me, nothing beats the 1978 version of Dawn of the Dead, so that’s my vote right there.

If we’re really doing this, shouldn't we be including both the original Night of the Living Dead and the Dawn of the Dead remake?

Oh, and honestly? I'll take Romero over Carpenter any day of the week. Plus, you totally glossed over the fact that King actually adapted those great flicks like Creepshow—another killer poll if you ask me.👍
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#4 ·
amberfalcon172 said:It’s kind of a bummer you framed this whole discussion around nothing but Romero's zombie flicks—personally, I’ve always found his vampire stuff way more interesting... Martin.

When it comes to zombies, I honestly think the whole thing should’ve just wrapped up after that first trilogy. *Land of the Dead* was such absolute garbage that it pretty much killed my drive to even bother with any of the later sequels...

You could talk about his entire body of work, I guess, but since this poll and intro are mostly focused on that specific stretch of his filmography—and I already brought up Dark Half, so let's not get bogged down by the title being narrow—we can branch out a bit... Truth be told, Land of the Dead was a letdown for me too, but it doesn't even touch the disappointment I felt watching Diary... I mean, my first thought was just, what the hell is this? It was a terrible movie, honestly just boring, maybe one decent scare in the whole thing, but strangely enough, some of my buddies swear by it like it’s some masterpiece... so now I'm actually kind of terrified to check out this new release because I don't want them judging me for hating the rest of his stuff. As for his Dawn of the Dead... easily his best, especially the director's cut, though even the remake isn't much of a departure...
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#5 ·
Dennis Sullivan46 said:Yeah, honestly... I've always felt Romero hits harder than Carpenter. Also, you totally skipped over the fact that when you bring up King, you’ve gotta mention he actually adapted that killer *Creepshow*—which is great, by the way. Another solid poll, too...👍

thanks for remembering... 😁 I remember that one, but honestly, "Cell" feels much closer to what this poll is actually about—it’s basically just one big, massive tribute to these movies... the world goes insane, everyone turns into zombies, and a small group of regular people just tries to survive the chaos. Word on the street is they might turn it into a limited series soon, but I can't help thinking it would be way better if King teamed up with Romero again... if those two could actually get together, they'd make something legendary. I mean, how much can two masters of horror even mess up?
Donna Gray4 Donna Gray4 Active Member
58 messages
joined Feb 2010
#6 ·
briskhound2 said:Thanks for remembering. 😁 I remember that one, but honestly, *Cell* feels much closer to what we were discussing in the poll because it’s basically a massive tribute to those classics... the world goes insane, everyone turns into zombies, and a small group of regular people just tries to survive the chaos. Word on the street is that it might get adapted into a limited series soon, but I can't help but think it would be way better if King teamed up with Romero again to do it right. I mean, how much could two legends of the horror genre actually mess up?

I really hope they don't blow it, because this could actually be something special. If they pull off that mini-series format you mentioned—and if the quality hits the level of The Stand—then I'll be more than happy.😉
Kate Harris4 Kate Harris4 Member
48 messages
joined Jul 2009
#7 ·
Dammit 😠

I can't even vote, for crying out loud—half of these movies aren't even on my radar 🤷
Matthew Anderson4 Matthew Anderson4 Regular
598 messages
joined Jun 2013
#8 ·
Night of the Living Dead 3D is definitely the first 🤣🤣
Who even are these ghosts? They’re always winning those polls for the worst movies, I’m genuinely curious
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#9 ·
Matthew Anderson4 said:Night of the Living Dead 3D is convincingly the first 🤣🤣
I honestly have no clue who these ghosts are—the people constantly voting for these bottom-tier movies in most polls... I'm genuinely baffled...

I was actually just about to type out how much I regret that there wasn't an option to make the poll public. I seriously can't believe that such a terrible movie is sitting at number one...
amberfalcon172 amberfalcon172 Member
27 messages
joined Sep 2003
#10 ·
Honestly, I feel like we’re being played at this point. It’s like those guys over at Cycling sat down and made a pact—"Hey, let's just drive everyone crazy by rigging the film voting so nothing but ultra-leftist movies ever win the polls." 🙂
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#11 ·
Paul James62 said:Can't really vote, man—haven't even seen half of these flicks🤷

Don't let it get to you. Looking at the votes... plenty of people haven't watched some of these either...
Christian Taylor3 Christian Taylor3 Active Member
213 messages
joined Jul 2010
#12 ·
Dawn of the Dead 😍 This was actually the first movie I ever watched on VHS (a shiny new JVC model, the first one in town—my dad brought it back from his trip to Germany 😁). To this day, I can still vividly picture that afternoon; half the neighborhood gathered around, screaming their heads off because they were so terrified (Tricky/Tihomir actually jumped through a window, and my grandma nearly had a stroke right then and there)... Man, I'd give anything to go back to those days for just a second (though maybe not to bring Tihomir back, since he was lost in the war in Vukovar back in '91. As for Grandma, she’s better off where she is, if you ask me). Anyway, here it is (still sitting proudly on my attic shelf), my beautiful:

image

And for dessert—caramelized corpses 🙂

image
official websites

fan of the dead is an amazing 52 minutes road-movie documentary revealing the filming locations of Night of the Living Dead (1968 & 1990 remake), Dawn of the Dead (1978) and Day of the Dead (1985), with exclusive interviews with the cast of the George Romero's trilogy.

Nicolas Cage, a French fan of the original Living dead trilogy, went to Pennsylvania to find All The Secret places where The films were Shot. Roaming, day and night, the steep roads of a sometimes lugubrious Pennsylvania countryside, he found and explored the coveted places: house, cemetery, mall, private airport, military base, underground facility... and much more!

image

p.s. briskhound2, thanks for remembering this little trip down memory lane 🙂

:idepojvcnatavan:
Chris Hall47 Chris Hall47 Member
19 messages
joined Jan 2023
#13 ·
Personally, I’d say Shaun of the Dead takes the crown for me—it’s just such a brilliant dark comedy. Honestly, most of those zombie flicks are hilarious, though I suppose Dead Set might be the exception to that rule...
Chloe Reed37 Chloe Reed37 Member
22 messages
joined May 2006
#14 ·
amberfalcon172 said:It's a shame you framed this discussion around nothing but Romero's zombie flicks. Personally, I find his vampire work, Martin, far more compelling.

Well, Martin is a great film; I can't disagree. 👍

By the way, my vote goes to Night of the Living Dead . Leave out that 3D nonsense, please.🙂
rustyscout34 rustyscout34 Active Member
110 messages
joined Aug 2009
#15 ·
Dawn of the Dead (1978), of course 😍
Arthur Parker53 Arthur Parker53 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Sep 2004
#16 ·
So, I was chatting with my sister the other day about how back home, you still see dead people showing up on voter registration rolls, which totally made us think of Romero... and she just goes, "Forget all that UUUUU crap, over here the zombies have actually evolved—they show up at the polls and vote for some president who’s gonna lead us straight into 3 p.m." 🤣
Chloe Nguyen Chloe Nguyen Member
36 messages
joined Aug 2008
#17 ·
I suppose I must apologize, but any "of the dead" poll simply feels incomplete without mentioning Shaun of the Dead 😉
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#18 ·
Christian Taylor3 said:p.s. briskhound2, thanks for remembering this trip down memory lane 🙂

Same here. Honestly, that doc is a solid recommendation—I’d actually forgotten the whole thing existed... it feels a little surreal seeing the cast from "Dawn of the Dead" just living their lives in the old haunts, but it's pretty cool to see how fans still basically make pilgrimages to that shopping mall today. Man, the place hasn't changed a bit, which probably means Romero got some kind of massive thank-you note from the locals for basically turning the area into a landmark...
briskhound2 briskhound2 RegularOP
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#19 ·
Gregory Wood41 said:Sorry, but you can't have an "of the dead" poll without including Shaun of the Dead... it just wouldn't be complete. 😉

I was actually thinking about throwing him into the poll, but Romero didn't really have much pull there—other than the fact that he eventually hung out with the guys, told them the movie was killer, and even offered them a cameo in Land of the Dead... so he kind of slipped through the cracks of the "competition." Still, this entire list is basically built on his shoulders, whether it’s his actual directing or just the scripts everyone else ended up ripping apart and reworking, so it wouldn't feel right to leave him out. Maybe he belongs in a separate poll for black comedies instead... because honestly, it's a great flick...

Dawn of the Dead documentary... such a cool little look at how they pulled it all off. A little quick clip about the movie...
briskbison41 briskbison41 Active Member
145 messages
joined Sep 2009
#20 ·
Land of the Dead, Diary of the Dead and Day of the Dead.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads