Favorite Nick Cave song?
Started by stormyviper11 · · 👁 12 views · 151 replies
#103 ·
Alexander Diaz8 said:Slowly goes The Night... eh...
Finally, someone actually brought this up. If I were the one putting together an all-time favorites list, she’d be right at the top for me. But since we're picking just one, there's really no debate—it's gotta be Knocking. Though, honestly, I could go on forever with Slowly goes The Night , Carny, Something's gotten hold of my Heart , Mercy , Mercy Seat, City of refuge, Fo, Nobody's Baby now , do you Love me, Tupelo, and a whole bunch of others that I won't even bother listing here...
Or am I wrong?
#104 ·
sundog said:...I'm just sitting here waiting for the know-it-all Amanda Palmer3 and her Nettlica trash to chime in with their "expert" takes on Nick Cave's songwriting. I'm especially waiting for Amanda Palmer3 to send Cave a formal letter of protest demanding he stop photographing him altogether..
$undokane, quit trying to flex those numbers with that passive-aggressive attitude. Based on the old-school standards set by a certain grumpy individual, you don't even fit in with our crowd to begin with.😉
Just keep pushing your ego, like Sisyphus grinding his way up Mount Veneris and beyond, until your font size finally grows large enough to actually qualify for some other montage.😛
And regarding Nettlica—she’s never once acted like a true connoisseur of Cave, not even a little bit. Quite the opposite; she’s spent her time using those sharp little jabs to undermine the very icons that quietdriver and I have been working tirelessly to uphold!
Now, why don't you go ahead and crop out that face of yours—the one looking like a character from a Kusturica film—from all those photos of your failed attempts at greatness...
#105 ·
stormyviper11 said:Something's gotten hold of my hand,
Or did it?
Nope. 😛
Just a second ago; Something's gotten hold of my gland 😂
Besides, using the same title isn't really his own creative genius, so it doesn't count! 🙂
#106 ·
wasted said:Aggression is one of the seven deadly sins, plain and simple. 😈
Wouldn't it be just perfect if the two of you woke up together on a train headed for New Orleans?
Watch out, or the three of us might wake up in some sketchy pink hotel right in the middle of St. Petersburg. The passcode? *Catherine the Great. 😉
Czars: Little pink house 😍
#107 ·
Amanda Palmer3 said:Nah. 😛
just now; Something's gotten hold of my Heart 😂
anyway, that whole "title track" thing isn't even his own creation, so it doesn't even count! 🙂
There, fixed it. Total Freudian slip on my part... guess I stood too still during the national anthem with my hand over my heart and just lost my bearings... 😁
I know he didn't write it, but his performance is hands down the best. Plus, I've always been obsessed with Licking against The bricks (intentional typo there, couldn't help myself... 😁 ) and it sucks that nobody nominated anything from that album.
#108 ·
stormyviper11 said:I know he didn't write it, but his version? Absolutely unbeatable. Plus, I’ve always been obsessed with Licking against The bricks—sorry, I just had to go there... 😁—so it's a real shame nobody stepped up to nominate anything from that record.
Alright then, here you go... by the time I get to Phoenix.
#109 ·
stormyviper11 said:Finally, someone actually brought her up. If I were putting together a list of all-time favorites, she’d be right at the top. But since we're picking just one? It’s definitely Knocking, Joe, or Slowly goes The Night , Carny, Something's gotten hold of my Heart , Mercy , Mercy Seat, City of refuge, Fo, Nobody's Baby now , do you Love me, Tupelo, and plenty of others I won't bother listing here.
Or is it?
I honestly never understood the hype surrounding Tupelo or Carney.😕
#110 ·
Daniel Booth88 said:Alright, fine, if that's what you want... "By the time I Get to Phoenix."
👍
#111 ·
vividharbor38 said:I honestly never understood the hype surrounding Tupelo and Carney.😕
The songs are killer, though. Probably. 😉
#112 ·
Amanda Palmer3 said:watch out that the three of us don't wake up in some sketchy pink hotel right in the middle of St. Petersburg, code word; *Catherine the Great 😉
np - Czars : Little pink house 😍
honestly, I don't really care where I wake up, as long as I'm waking up in my own underwear. I hate it when I realize someone dressed me in someone else's clothes.*
code word; a friend's farewell party
🤣
#113 ·
stormyviper11 said:I know he didn't write it, but honestly, his version is just so much more convincing than anyone else's. Plus, I’ve always had a huge soft spot for Licking against The bricks (yeah, I went there, I couldn't help myself... 😁 ) and it's kind of a bummer that nobody put anything from that album up for nomination.
all tomorrow's parties
#114 ·
vividharbor38 said:I honestly never understood the hype around Tupelo and Carney.😕
I guess they just see it as a way to mess with your head. 😕
#115 ·
quietdriver3 said:all tomorrow's parties
I actually just had this playing as my victory anthem after crushing it in those high-stakes, super intense matchups... you know, the ones against your own brothers. Doesn't matter if it's football or some backyard game. It felt even better knowing they can't stand Cave, though I did end up listening to him once or twice in the meantime...
#116 ·
stormyviper11 said:There, fixed it. Total Freudian slip on my part—I guess I stood there too long during the national anthem with my hand over my heart and just lost my grip on reality for a second... 😁
😬 👍
Just imagine me without any sarcasm; honestly, even Pitney sounds better than me. Probably because of that lush, retro, lo-fi vibe, despite his creepy leprechaun voice. 😱
#117 ·
Melancholy Beaver said:Honestly, I don't care where I wake up, as long as I'm waking up in my own damn underwear. There's nothing worse than realizing someone dressed me in someone else's clothes.*
The password? My buddy's farewell party.
🤣
🤣 🤣 🤣
#118 ·
dmj said:I actually just played this track as my victory anthem right after winning some high-stakes matches against my brothers. (Doesn't matter what game we were playing. It felt even better knowing they couldn't stand Cave... though I did end up giving him a listen once in the meantime...)
Yeah, it definitely has that anthemic vibe 🙏
although Nico gives me even bigger creeps 😲
#119 ·
klinkovichka said:little 😎
hey, I just caught your quick little reply-post 😁
*Amanda Palmer3 knocks on wood 😉
#120 ·
quietdriver3 said:the same logic applies to pride🙂
Of course you wouldn't get it; we're talking about vanity here, not actual pride. 🙂
i don't know what you just said, but i don't like the way you said it 👎
You clearly just can't handle my Christian alter-ego. 😕
You’re picking a fight with me when Amanda Palmer was practically ready to perform an exorcism on you. 😛
ps
What's going on?
Nothing worth mentioning. 😢
🙂
yuuuck 😁
Amanda Palmer3 said:watch out, or the three of us might wake up in some shady pink hotel in downtown St. Petersburg, password: Catherine the Great
Ha! Why not? And let the beaver play the crucified martyr while we're at it.
np—and i think it's perfectly clear i'm in the wrong band
🔗 Similar threads
- All-time favorite songs? in Off-topic · Mar 29, 2023
- The mental grind of the "favorite" vs. the "underdog in Fans · Jul 30, 2026
- The "Sell High" dilemma: When do you let a fan favorite walk? in Fans · Jul 29, 2026
- The heartbreak of being the favorite and then having it all snatched away in Fans · Jul 29, 2026
- Why do certain songs just refuse to leave the airwaves? in Music · Jul 29, 2026