CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Lifestyle › Health › Doctor stories: What are your experiences with diagnoses?

Doctor stories: What are your experiences with diagnoses?

Started by Alex Collins26 · · 👁 5 views · 216 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Alex Collins26Justin FoxAHarold Mendoza3Lisa Rodriguez84Keith Nguyen7Kimberly NguyenCarol Lee4gentlelynx26Edward GreenNicole Morales12nimblestag31Arthur Ruiz2Noah Vaughn3Zachary Thompson9boldsailor52Andrew Campbell4swiftscout8Angela Bailey30Benjamin Murphy2Chris Wright4feralorca2brisknomad6Aaron Gonzalez4 …
Alex Collins26 Alex Collins26 MemberOP
13 messages
joined Nov 2006
#1 ·
I’m starting this thread mostly because of what happened to my mother yesterday... basically, she ended up at Mayo Clinic because we suspected gallbladder issues (back pain, fever, and she hasn't been able to eat for two days), but after all the tests—urine, blood work, X-rays, and doctor consultations—they actually concluded they have no idea what's going on. The doctor says he suspects cancer, but then admits he doesn't know for sure, and then he calls my husband over just to ask him a question. My husband mentions that Mom has had this darker mole on her leg for quite a while, so the doctor calls her back in to show it to him. After seeing that, he suddenly gives a cancer diagnosis (of what, who knows?) and tells her she has two years left to live??? I mean, seriously? They’re keeping her in the hospital for more tests, yet they won't even do a biopsy to figure out what the mole actually is until next week... I guess, what kind of normal specialist makes a claim like that before a biopsy? To tell terrified people one minute they don't know anything, and the next that there are only two years left? 👎
And honestly, about a year ago, my brother was diagnosed with a brain tumor and everyone was offering their condolences, only for it to turn out to be a simple, harmless cyst a week later... now he’s healthy, happy, and back to his usual self 🙂

I don't have anything against doctors personally—my sister is a physician—but where is the compassion in today's medical field? Or tact? I guess, why do people even bother studying medicine if they couldn't care less about the patients...
Justin Fox Justin Fox Active Member
110 messages
joined Jan 2006
#2 ·
Alex Collins26 said:Look, I have nothing against doctors personally—my sister is a physician—but where is the empathy in today’s medical field? Where is the tact? Why even bother going through med school if you couldn't care less about the actual patients...

I don't have anything against medical staff either, at least nothing particularly effective. You shouldn't view them as absolute authorities; frankly, many of them just lie or make careless mistakes. You have to monitor them as much as possible. Educate yourself on your own condition so you can treat doctors as consultants or executors rather than the sole source of truth. Ask one, then go get a second opinion. If someone suggests invasive surgery, check for alternatives first. You always have the right to a second opinion.

As for what actually works against doctors, you try your best to make sure they realize you aren't some mindless idiot, but an intelligent human being. If they refuse to acknowledge that and treat you like a slab of meat instead, you usually have to be difficult. Either act rude so they want to get rid of you quickly to stop the headache, or start filing complaints with their supervisors, then those supervisors' bosses, and so on. Or threaten them with lawsuits. You need to know your rights and how the system actually functions. That "hypocrite" oath and all that nonsense should probably just be renamed the Hippocratic oath, because most people are dragging the once-noble reputation of this profession through the mud. Nowadays, it’s just a business. And no, I'm not saying they're constantly being dragged through the newspapers for scandals.
A Anonymous Veteran
3.6K messages
joined May 2005
#3 ·
Honestly, I’ve seen plenty of cases where patients actually knew more than their doctors... it’s just that some doctors are too stubborn to admit they're wrong and would rather insist they're right no matter what.
Harold Mendoza3 Harold Mendoza3 Member
10 messages
joined Jun 2006
#4 ·
Alex Collins26 said:I’m starting this thread mainly because of what happened to my mother yesterday... she ended up at Mayo Clinic because we suspected gallbladder attacks (she had back pain, a fever, and hasn't been able to eat for two days). However, after a series of tests—urine, bloodwork, X-rays, and various doctor consultations—they actually concluded they have no idea what’s going on. The doctor mentioned he suspects cancer, but admits he's unsure, so he called my husband over to ask him a few questions. My husband mentioned that Mom has had a darker mole on her leg for quite some time now, so the doctor called her back in to take a look. Upon seeing it, he immediately gave a diagnosis of cancer (though he doesn't know exactly what kind) and prescribed...

I realize I might be tilting at windmills here, but I feel compelled to respond to this post.
I understand that when a family member is admitted to the hospital, it is an incredibly stressful situation. It's difficult to follow the process, and even harder to truly grasp everything a doctor is saying. We are terrified for our loved ones, and sometimes we struggle to answer the simplest questions ourselves—let alone process a mountain of technical medical jargon and expert advice that feels completely foreign to us. But...
There is always a "but."
We have to remain mindful that doctors are not omnipotent (regardless of how much some might wish they were) and they don't possess a crystal ball that can instantly reveal a patient's specific condition or their remaining time. That knowledge belongs to a higher power, not the physician. Consequently, I find it difficult to believe that anyone should be throwing diagnoses around so casually, offering grim prognoses at first glance or counting down someone's days. Yet, people always want to ask—"What's the prognosis?" Providing a prognosis before a definitive diagnosis is even established is futile. That is precisely why all these various tests are performed. Similarly, providing a prognosis based solely on initial findings is equally senseless. Every person is an individual; some handle illness one way, others differently. A doctor is not a fortune teller, nor should they attempt to be one.
Harold Mendoza3 Harold Mendoza3 Member
10 messages
joined Jun 2006
#5 ·
Justin Fox said:hypocritekritova The whole concept of an oath and all that nonsense really ought to be rebranded as something Hippocratic.kratovu Take an oath, because most people around here are busy dragging the reputation of what used to be called "humanitarian professions" through the mud.

You’ve got your wires crossed on this one. It isn't that "most people" are acting in bad faith; it’s just a small minority causing the trouble. There are parasites in every field, no matter how legitimate. Just like in any other profession, the hardest part is always weeding out the rot from within your own ranks.

At this point, it’s strictly a matter of business.

What isn't a business opportunity these days? As far as I can tell, they haven't quite figured out how to monetize the fact that we all breathe for free.
Lisa Rodriguez84 Lisa Rodriguez84 Active Member
175 messages
joined Jul 2006
#6 ·
A hypocrite is just a phony, right?
Hippocratic is the father of medicine.
Alex Collins26 Alex Collins26 MemberOP
13 messages
joined Nov 2006
#7 ·
Harold Mendoza3 said:That’s why I find it so hard to believe that someone would just toss diagnoses around like they're nothing. At first glance, they come out with these grim outlooks and start counting down the days for people. But I suppose people always want to ask—they want to know the prognosis. Giving a prognosis before you even have a diagnosis feels pretty futile to me. That’s why all those different tests exist in the first place. And honestly, giving a prognosis after the results come back feels just as pointless. Every person is an individual; some handle illness one way, others differently. A doctor isn't supposed to be a fortune teller, and I guess they shouldn't try to be.

That's exactly the issue. I honestly can't wrap my head around how he could even suggest a diagnosis before the biopsy was done. And as for saying there's maybe only a year or two left... I don't know why he even said that when nobody even asked him...
Keith Nguyen7 Keith Nguyen7 Member
40 messages
joined Nov 2007
#8 ·
Remember when they almost sent me into surgery because they mistook my severe gastritis for appendicitis? Thank God a smarter surgeon showed up for the shift, gave me some Pepto, and sent me straight home.
Kimberly Nguyen Kimberly Nguyen Regular
543 messages
joined Jul 2009
#9 ·
Harold Mendoza3 said:Look, I’m going to be blunt here: we are talking about an incredibly high-stress situation. It is overwhelming, plain and simple. When you're in the middle of all that chaos, trying to follow what a doctor is saying is nearly impossible—let alone actually understanding half of it. We are terrified for our loved ones. We’re sitting there, hearts racing, and honestly? Sometimes we can barely even process the simplest questions ourselves. Like, if someone asks us a basic question—something as trivial as "What's your name?"—our brains just stall out. How on earth are we supposed to digest a mountain of complex medical jargon and technical advice that sounds like a foreign language? It's exhausting, it's scary, and it's completely unrealistic to expect people to stay composed under that kind of pressure.

At the end of the day, doctors are actually supposed to be here for us. But let’s be real—especially if you’re dealing with the big-city hospitals in places like New York or Chicago—it feels like the whole system is rigged just to get us out of their sight. Unless you happen to stumble upon one of those incredibly rare exceptions who actually gives a damn, the entire goal seems to be rushing patients out of the exam room or discharging them from the hospital as fast as humanly possible. It's frustrating as hell.
Look, let’s be real: people get confused in situations like this. It’s completely normal. Most folks don't have a clue what all those technical terms and Latin medical jargon actually mean—and honestly, why should they? That’s exactly why doctors need to step down from their ivory towers for a second, show some actual empathy, and explain things to us in plain English, almost like they're talking to a toddler. But me? I’ve never experienced that kind of compassion. Actually, wait, that’s a lie. I did have one experience once. I was at Mount Sinai getting my sinuses cleared out, and there was this one young, absolutely stunning doctor who actually took the time to make sense of it all... 🙏 I still remember when our little one was dealing with those awful, swollen lymph nodes in their legs—it was such a stressful time. 🙏 🙏

Harold Mendoza3 said:Look, we really need to face reality here: doctors aren't gods. I don't care how much some people want them to be omniscient, but they don't carry around some magic crystal ball that can pinpoint every single ailment or tell you exactly how many days you have left on this earth. That kind of ultimate knowledge? It isn't in their hands. It belongs to something else entirely. That’s why it absolutely infuriates me when I see people throwing diagnoses around like they're handing out candy. You see these types who immediately jump to the darkest possible conclusions, tossing out grim prognoses and practically counting down someone's remaining days before the ink on the chart is even dry. It’s reckless, it's arrogant, and frankly, it's hard for me to wrap my head around how anyone can act with that much unearned certainty.

Look, nobody is out here expecting them to perform miracles every single day, let's get that straight. But what we are seeing lately is becoming an absolute joke: doctors handing out diagnoses left and right without even bothering with a full workup or looking at basic lab results. It’s happening more often than it should, and frankly, it’s infuriating. I was at my appointment last week—and I shouldn't have had to fight this hard just to be heard—but it feels like the entire American healthcare system is buckling under its own weight. You see the reasons everywhere. Sometimes it’s just a doctor being burnt out and checked out because they’re overworked, and other times it’s much more cynical—it's the bottom line. Between the massive staffing shortages in our hospitals and the way insurance companies squeeze every cent out of providers, the incentive to actually *investigate* a patient instead of just guessing is disappearing. We’re trading thorough medicine for speed and cost-cutting, and the patients are the ones paying the price for this negligence. It’s sloppy, it’s lazy, and it’s dangerous.

To be honest, the last decade has been an absolute nightmare for my family when it comes to health issues. We’ve dealt with a string of brutal medical situations—some turned out okay, thank God, but others... others were just pure tragedy. It hits you in a way nothing else does. There is absolutely nothing that cuts deeper or leaves you more broken than when you're standing there realizing your own child needs help and you're just praying for a miracle.

So, here’s the situation:
When our son was just a little over three years old, out of nowhere, these round, plum-like bumps started popping up all over his legs. At first, we were convinced it was just something he picked up at preschool—you know how kids are, always touching everything. We even went to his teachers to ask if they’d seen anything, but they swore they hadn't noticed a thing. Finally, we took him to see his pediatrician. She wasn't like those doctors you see today; she was the real deal, a true professional. Honestly, if it hadn't been for her, I don't know what we would have done. She gave him one thorough look, realized this wasn't just some playground rash, and immediately handed us a referral for the Mayo Clinic.🙂 And she told me she’d seen this exact thing before. Apparently, in her experience, they almost never find anything significant with these kids—nothing more than a minor iron deficiency. She mentioned that it usually just lingers for about a year and then clears up on its own, but she still insisted we go through with the full battery of tests just to be safe. Better to be thorough, I guess, even if it feels like we're chasing ghosts.
So, we headed over to the Mayo Clinic the other day. We were there seeing a specialist, and things took a turn I wasn't prepared for. The doctor tells me to take off his shirt—so I do, just following orders—and then she just... stares at him. She doesn't draw blood, she doesn't order an X-ray, she doesn't even take a photo. She just looks at him with this completely blank expression and says, deadpan, "Your child has leukemia."
I can’t even begin to tell you how much my blood froze in that moment. I looked her straight in the eye—after my husband had basically lost his mind trying to convince me I was just overreacting—and asked her, "How on earth can you be so sure?" And she just sits there, completely deadpan, telling me those spots could only be leukemia. I didn't even argue. I just gave her a sarcastic "thanks for your incredible expertise," grabbed the kids, and stormed out of the office.
We finally tracked down this wonderful doctor, Dr. Horse, who used to work over at Salat—though honestly, I can’t stand that place. Just being near there brings back all kinds of childhood trauma, so let's just move on. Anyway, we went through the absolute ringer with him. We're talking over a million tests; they drew blood, and then more blood, and then more blood again. I lost count. There were times we were sitting around waiting for test results for an entire month, just hanging in limbo, only for the big reveal to be... nothing. Absolutely nothing. Turns out, it was just a tiny bit of iron deficiency. All that stress and all those needles for a minor tweak? It's infuriating.
After talking things through with his doctor, we finally hit on the real issue: the diet he was following—which basically consisted of everything under the sun *except* eggs, cheese, and meat—wasn't providing the essential nutrients his body needed to maintain iron levels. It turns out, that was likely the culprit all along. His pediatrician also mentioned that the spots should eventually fade away over time, giving us a window of about a year at most. And honestly? That’s exactly what happened. 🙂
Carol Lee4 Carol Lee4 Active Member
58 messages
joined Jul 2006
#10 ·
I had a deeply personal experience dealing with a loved one who passed away from cancer:
- The lead oncologist handling the treatment was at a major metropolitan hospital (where bribery in blue envelopes is just standard practice—those days of polite gift-giving are gone; they’ll look you right in the eye and tell you they expect cash)
- We would take the exact same test results, but because we insisted on seeing more than one doctor, we'd ask for second and third opinions. Every single time, the diagnoses were completely different, despite looking at the same bone scans, X-rays, mammograms, or ultrasounds...
My personal takeaway? Aside from surgeons who actually perform "tangible" procedures, everyone else—from GPs to specialists—seems incapable of saying, "I don't know." Instead, it's always, "It could be..."
- It was ALWAYS, ALWAYS the case that they openly asked for money. Everyone, except for the local family practitioner, from the big hospitals all the way down to the surgeons, was looking for a payout.
gentlelynx26 gentlelynx26 Member
16 messages
joined Apr 2006
#11 ·
So, a girl I know from my university classes in San Diego was getting contact lenses at the clinic. The doctor told her they need to be swapped out every two months, so she ended up buying a 12-pack to cover the whole year.

Fast forward one year later: her eyes start hurting like crazy. She does some digging online and realizes those lenses actually need to be replaced every two weeks (honestly, that doctor probably just wanted to pad her own pockets), and when she finally went back for an exam, her prescription had tripled compared to last year!! She went right back to that same clinic to demand answers, but they wouldn't even tell her the doctor's name or anything else because they all "stick together" to protect each other. 😲 😲 😲 😲

I swear, if that had been me, I would have absolutely lost it.
Edward Green Edward Green Regular
335 messages
joined Sep 2008
#12 ·
She went back there again, acting all lost because they wouldn't tell her the damn doctor's name.

Seriously? She's such an idiot, she doesn't even know her own doctor's name?

Anyway, if she wore two-week contacts for a month and a half past their expiration date, she’s a freaking medical miracle. Her eyes didn't get cloudy or irritated at all? Unbelievable. 🙏 🙏
gentlelynx26 gentlelynx26 Member
16 messages
joined Apr 2006
#13 ·
Edward Green said:Is this idiot seriously unable to remember her own doctor's name?

btw, if she was wearing two-week contact lenses for a month and a half past their expiration date, it’s a damn medical miracle they didn't cloud up or make her eyes feel like they were on fire. 🙏 🙏

Of course they stung and hurt, just not immediately. It took a while before things went south. And since they keep shuffling patients around at places like Mayo Clinic, she probably didn't catch the name... I don't know anything about contacts myself since I don't wear them, but that's what she told me.
Edward Green Edward Green Regular
335 messages
joined Sep 2008
#14 ·
How on earth were they supposed to know who her doctor was?
Did the doctor even give her a diagnosis or anything?
Look, whenever I go to a clinic, I make sure I know exactly which doctor I’m seeing. I’ll call ahead and say, "Hi, I'd like to book an appointment, can I see Dr. Smith?" People always tell you it's possible.
Get this: I toss my three-month contacts a few days early if they start feeling uncomfortable. But she wore those two-week lenses four times longer than she should have? And did that for an entire year?
Nicole Morales12 Nicole Morales12 Newcomer
9 messages
joined Apr 2006
#15 ·
Back when my mom was in her early twenties, she was dealing with an echinococcal cyst. My dad happens to be a doctor, but after just one quick, superficial look, he told her—completely stone-faced—"Just stay strong, it's cancer and she's done for." And he said this right there on the hospital stairs, just passing through. Naturally, the family wasn't having any of it; they gathered everyone up, grabbed her, and drove her straight to a specialist clinic in Chicago. There, they successfully removed the cyst and assured us there wouldn't be any lasting issues or complications. Thankfully, everything turned out perfectly fine, just as they promised.
Kimberly Nguyen Kimberly Nguyen Regular
543 messages
joined Jul 2009
#16 ·
Speaking of ophthalmologists... about four years ago, I went to this private clinic—honestly, I can't even remember the name right now because they're doing renovations—but the specialist there was Skegro, who is Spanish.
I already knew I had a slight prescription, but I hadn't bothered wearing glasses until recently when my computer work started really straining my eyes.
So, I book an appointment and head in. She’s lovely, very professional, explains everything clearly... nothing to complain about there. It turns out my prescription isn't massive, but I do have astigmatism. Well, whatever, right? I ended up buying a pair of glasses from them, which cost me $0.83 (nice frames, cylindrical lenses, all that good stuff)
She warned me it would take some time to adjust. Three months later, I’m back because I still couldn't get used to them. She checked me and the glasses again, basically telling me, "Look, you just need more time." And honestly, it took me ages, but eventually, I got used to them.

Fast forward: my company organized a routine physical for all employees, which included an eye exam. They put me in front of that machine, look at my glasses, ask where I got them made... and suddenly, according to him, I don't even have astigmatism (???) He starts explaining the readings from the machine to me, and I ask if it can be cured. He says no. So, I just brushed it off; I only wear the glasses at work anyway, and I can't function without them.
Then, during this year's corporate physical, I see an ophthalmologist again. Once more, I'm in the machine, and once more, he tells me I don't have astigmatism. But here's the kicker: I've become so dependent on those cylindrical lenses that I practically can't do my job without them now.
That private practice is closed right now because they're renovating and expanding. It looks like it'll be a long, drawn-out process before they reopen, and honestly, what am I supposed to do? I'm stuck.
Edward Green Edward Green Regular
335 messages
joined Sep 2008
#17 ·
Open your head with your teeth. 😠
Edward Green Edward Green Regular
335 messages
joined Sep 2008
#18 ·
to doctor. 😁
nimblestag31 nimblestag31 Member
26 messages
joined Sep 2005
#19 ·
Man, there’s just so much going on—it’s honestly hard to believe... I know this one cardiologist in my area who basically picks one day a week to prescribe the exact same medication to every single patient he sees... 😲
even if those patients don't even have the symptoms that the drug is meant for... it's enough to drive you crazy. Then, people show up at their local family doctor feeling totally confused, and the GP tells them, "Hey, don't take that, just stick to your regular prescription," but I guess some folks still end up trusting the specialist more than some random general practitioner over there...

And who knows, maybe the guy is getting a kickback from some big pharmaceutical company like Pfizer or something... it's wild. Sometimes I almost feel like just walking up to him and asking what his deal is—but yeah, I doubt anyone would actually listen to me.
Arthur Ruiz2 Arthur Ruiz2 Active Member
115 messages
joined May 2005
#20 ·
About six months ago, a woman went in for a routine checkup, and her doctor spotted a mole during the exam. He looked at her and said, "Spit on me if this isn't cancer!!!"
Turns out, it was.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads