Nosy banks

electricorca3 said:Look, I don't know the specific statute off the top of my head, but I can bet my life that somewhere in the fine print of some massive law or one of those internal policy manuals we all blindly signed when we opened our accounts at Chase or Bank of America, there's a clause covering this. It basically boils down to us being legally obligated to respond to their requests and provide whatever info they ask for—whether it's updating our ID info or confirming if we moved our tax residency to another state or something. You might know for a fact that your records are current and you haven't changed anything, but from their perspective, they've got thousands of people who move or change status without telling them, so they get paranoid. Personally, I don't care about the paperwork side of things, but what really gets under my skin is the sheer nerve of them asking such invasive, personal questions under the guise of "compliance." It feels incredibly shady and just plain low-down.

I checked my contract once before. It states I am obligated to notify them of any changes to my data. However, if nothing has actually changed, I see zero justification for receiving these letters.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

Steven Rivera76 said:I checked my contract once before. It states I am obligated to notify them of any changes to my data. However, if nothing has actually changed, I see zero justification for receiving these letters.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

But wait, how are they even supposed to know you haven't updated anything if you don't tell them? It's kind of a catch-22, right? I bet thousands of people just ignore this stuff entirely. There must be a huge crowd of folks out there who don't even realize their driver's license has expired until they're standing at the DMV trying to get everything sorted.

electricorca3 said:But wait, how are they even supposed to know you haven't updated anything if you don't tell them? It's kind of a catch-22, right? I bet thousands of people just ignore this stuff entirely. There must be a huge crowd of folks out there who don't even realize their driver's license has expired until they're standing at the DMV trying to get everything sorted.

Since I had some intense dealings with my bank relatively recently,
they already have a photocopy of my ID, which is fairly new.

Personally, it bothers me that my bank—one I've used for quite a while—is being this aggressive with their threats. Though, honestly, I only signed up with Zabiti out of habit, and I could switch banks this instant if I wanted to.

Steven Rivera76 said:Since I had some intense dealings with my bank relatively recently,
they already have a photocopy of my ID, which is fairly new.

Personally, it bothers me that my bank—one I've used for quite a while—is being this aggressive with their threats. Though, honestly, I only signed up with Zabiti out of habit, and I could switch banks this instant if I wanted to.

Oh, but the real question is whether you actually *can* leave. I was scrolling through Reddit earlier and found this one user describing how she walked into her branch at Chase to close her account, only for the teller to tell her she needed to "fill in some gaps" in their records first. It makes you wonder what kind of nonsense they’ll pull out of their hats once you show up in person—how much they can try to blackmail you or pressure you into staying. The whole system feels totally predatory...

electricorca3 said:Oh, but the real question is whether you actually *can* leave. I was scrolling through Reddit earlier and found this one user describing how she walked into her branch at Chase to close her account, only for the teller to tell her she needed to "fill in some gaps" in their records first. It makes you wonder what kind of nonsense they’ll pull out of their hats once you show up in person—how much they can try to blackmail you or pressure you into staying. The whole system feels totally predatory...

I’d gladly hand over my info—they already have it anyway. Then I'd close my accounts and brag about it on the "Why Wells Fargo is losing customers" thread.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

@ Spinster

You wouldn't even be able to open an account at another bank without handing over all those same details.
If you feel like your rights are being violated, you can always file a formal grievance, and the legal department at any bank will have to provide a response. Honestly, if you truly believe they don't have the right to ask for certain information, you could just sue them.
Regarding data updates: if a client repeatedly ignores these requests, the bank will simply close the account for failure to comply with terms of service. If there are funds available, they’ll tell the client to come pick up the balance—minus any applicable fees. Or, if there are outstanding loans or debts, they’ll just send everything to collections at once. If that isn't paid, they move straight to wage garnishment or legal seizure.
What Chase is doing by freezing withdrawals is just the final step before they shut the whole thing down.

wiredlynx28 said:@ Spinster

You wouldn't even be able to open an account at another bank without handing over all those same details.
If you feel like your rights are being violated, you can always file a formal grievance, and the legal department at any bank will have to provide a response. Honestly, if you truly believe they don't have the right to ask for certain information, you could just sue them.
Regarding data updates: if a client repeatedly ignores these requests, the bank will simply close the account for failure to comply with terms of service. If there are funds available, they’ll tell the client to come pick up the balance—minus any applicable fees. Or, if there are outstanding loans or debts, they’ll just send everything to collections at once. If that isn't paid, they move straight to wage garnishment or legal seizure.
What Chase is doing by freezing withdrawals is just the final step before they shut the whole thing down.

I'll say it again: they already have the data. It isn't an issue for me to provide it to another bank, but my issue is that JPMorgan Chase is threatening me. I filed a grievance, but I haven't received a response yet. Once I hear back, I will forward the correspondence to the appropriate authorities.
The rest of what you wrote is incorrect.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

Let’s be real here—this should just be about the obligation to provide updated info. Are they seriously expecting everyone to rush down to their local Chase branch to prove nothing has changed? There's always a massive line whenever I show up anyway. And what’s with this whole residency question? Are they just assuming we're all foreign residents by default—like, specifically non-US residents—and forcing us to prove otherwise? Give me a break...

Sent from my iPhone 8 using Reddit

Steven Rivera76 said:I'll say it again: they already have the data. It isn't an issue for me to provide it to another bank, but my issue is that JPMorgan Chase is threatening me. I filed a grievance, but I haven't received a response yet. Once I hear back, I will forward the correspondence to the appropriate authorities.
The rest of what you wrote is incorrect.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

Since I’m not a Chase customer, I can't say for sure what their exact process is for closing an account when a client doesn't respond, but most other banks would have pulled the trigger long before this.

wiredlynx28 said:Since I’m not a Chase customer, I can't say for sure what their exact process is for closing an account when a client doesn't respond, but most other banks would have pulled the trigger long before this.

Give me a break. Did your bank actually do that? There hasn't been any mention of such a thing. Provide some

Who cares, anyway? I’ll just move my money elsewhere and be done with it.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

So, they want to call in the entire loan just because you closed your account? I mean, that’s pretty much the end of the discussion right there. That's wild. 🤣

When you're actually opening an account, they don't really grill you on anything besides your ID. I know, because I literally just went through it yesterday at JPMorgan Chase. 🍿

I received a circular notice as well... I wonder if any bank other than Bank of America is being quite this aggressive with their clients?

rowdypilot19 said:So, they want to call in the entire loan just because you closed your account? I mean, that’s pretty much the end of the discussion right there. That's wild. 🤣

When you're actually opening an account, they don't really grill you on anything besides your ID. I know, because I literally just went through it yesterday at JPMorgan Chase. 🍿

Look, it’s a complicated situation. If you have credit lines tied to an account that isn't operating according to its terms, closing that account triggers the closure of those linked credit lines, making the entire balance due immediately. 👍

There are always people who try to fight everything—even their own best interests—only to end up screwing themselves over in the end.

When opening an account at JPMorgan Chase, they will ask for FATCA information. Usually, it's just a simple "yes or no" regarding US citizenship, and that's the end of it.

electricorca3 said:Actually, if you ask me, they might actually have some ground to stand on here, unfortunately. They’re claiming they need to request info under the Anti-Money Laundering Act, alongside various administrative cooperation laws and the Internal Revenue Code, plus all their specific regulations. That basically means they can demand stuff like updated ID, employment status, why you’re even using the bank in the first place, tax residency details, and so on. So, yeah, it’s pretty easy for them to legally justify making our banking relationship contingent on providing that kind of data.

But, you know, it’s worth pointing out that they aren't mentioning that whole mess from last year where they were digging for stuff like marital status, how many kids you have, political affiliations, how many people live in your house, etc. It feels like the public outcry back then really forced them to draw a line between what’s actually required by law and that initial shady attempt to harvest data they weren't even entitled to—you know, information that was more about satisfying the bank's own curiosity for questionable reasons than anything legal.

It’s all just smoke and mirrors and fear-mongering. Like I said in my last post, it's a scam. Honestly, I got one of those notices yesterday too; if it were any better quality, I'd use it to wipe my ass.😁

@Regarding those "FATCA obligations," banks are supposed to be collecting data on individuals with accounts seeing more than $50,000 USD in annual turnover, and for legal entities, anything over $250,000 USD (check out the FATCA presentation and its application in America on the Internal Revenue Service website).

Here’s a question for Bank of America, and really for all these banks: who are you actually spying on when you run these "interrogations" on account holders—individuals moving less than $50,000 USD a year or businesses doing less than $250,000 USD?

Steven Rivera76 said:Give me a break. Did your bank actually do that? There hasn't been any mention of such a thing. Provide some

Who cares, anyway? I’ll just move my money elsewhere and be done with it.

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

Bank of America has been paying out my pension for over 10 years now. They've never bothered me for anything. All they ever do is try to push those retiree loans 😁 or offer me whatever overdraft limit I want.👍

wiredlynx28 said:Look, it’s a complicated situation. If you have credit lines tied to an account that isn't operating according to its terms, closing that account triggers the closure of those linked credit lines, making the entire balance due immediately. 👍

There are always people who try to fight everything—even their own best interests—only to end up screwing themselves over in the end.

When opening an account at JPMorgan Chase, they will ask for FATCA information. Usually, it's just a simple "yes or no" regarding US citizenship, and that's the end of it.

Don't overthink it, because that’s just not how it works.

They just ask if you’re a US citizen, and that’s really it. This whole thing doesn't even relate to the topic at hand, and honestly, I don't see what you have to do with these nonsense arguments anyway.

As for the other people asking questions... did any of you actually see anything related to this? Because none of that has anything to do with what you're saying.

rowdypilot19 said:Don't overthink it, because that’s just not how it works.

They just ask if you’re a US citizen, and that’s really it. This whole thing doesn't even relate to the topic at hand, and honestly, I don't see what you have to do with these nonsense arguments anyway.

As for the other people asking questions... did any of you actually see anything related to this? Because none of that has anything to do with what you're saying.

It's a good thing you're an industry expert, since you clearly know everything. 👍

If you actually work in this industry, man, I just feel for you. God, it’s such a grind.

wiredlynx28 said:Look, it’s a complicated situation. If you have credit lines tied to an account that isn't operating according to its terms, closing that account triggers the closure of those linked credit lines, making the entire balance due immediately. 👍

There are always people who try to fight everything—even their own best interests—only to end up screwing themselves over in the end.

When opening an account at JPMorgan Chase, they will ask for FATCA information. Usually, it's just a simple "yes or no" regarding US citizenship, and that's the end of it.

I don't see an answer to my question—has your bank actually been closing accounts because of this questionnaire, and has anyone had their loans called in full because of it?

Sent from my iPhone using Reddit

Laura Chavez93 said:I received a circular notice as well... I wonder if any bank other than Bank of America is being quite this aggressive with their clients?

I wouldn't call it a threat, really—more like they're just letting you know what's coming 😉... It's kind of like how you aren't obligated to do business with them, and they aren't obligated to deal with you either...