analoghawk13 said:There are definitely people who would be classified as depressed due to organic medical issues.
But the idea that > the depression and stress leading up to it absolutely wrecked your nervous system < is impossible to prove. The notion that depression destroys the nervous system on a hardware level? That's ideology. At best, it's correlation.
What actually matters is a person's life situation. And a situation is made up of facts, interpretations, perspectives, and mood.
Plus, you have external demands on how you're supposed to function. You "Must Not Be Depressed." And that’s where the vicious cycles start.
> psychiatry is just quasi-help for the symptoms <
Sure, there's some truth to that, but there's also the fact that quick quasi-therapy often just permanently locks you into a low state. How often does one single, heavy-handed label—like, "You Just Have Anxiety-Driven Depression"—create the whole reality? Suddenly, you're forced to interpret, feel, and act based on that label just to defend yourself.
Every intense emotional state leaves its mark, obviously. Every illness has a root cause, and for most, that stems from severe stress or heavy emotional burdens—that’s nothing new.
Then, the chronic issues and pain that arise from that—both physically and mentally—create a feedback loop. Those states impact your functions, which feeds back into the cycle, causing symptoms to flare up and fade away periodically. Depression absolutely wrecks a person's life, their behavior, their thought patterns, their relationships, and their drive to live.
analoghawk13 said:There are definitely people who would be classified as depressed due to organic medical issues.
But the idea that > the depression and stress leading up to it absolutely wrecked your nervous system < is impossible to prove. The notion that depression destroys the nervous system on a hardware level? That's ideology. At best, it's correlation.
What actually matters is a person's life situation. And a situation is made up of facts, interpretations, perspectives, and mood.
Plus, you have external demands on how you're supposed to function. You "Must Not Be Depressed." And that’s where the vicious cycles start.
> psychiatry is just quasi-help for the symptoms <
Sure, there's some truth to that, but there's also the fact that quick quasi-therapy often just permanently locks you into a low state. How often does one single, heavy-handed label—like, "You Just Have Anxiety-Driven Depression"—create the whole reality? Suddenly, you're forced to interpret, feel, and act based on that label just to defend yourself.
You're theorizing more than stating facts now, but okay, I get what you mean. Just let's not talk about mental illness in such broad, abstract terms; I was simply offering my opinion to him, not making an absolute claim.
My point in reaching out to the guy is this:
I hope he isn't experiencing mania, because when someone goes through a manic episode—whatever kind it may be—they can feel enlightened, like they're Jesus or God. We all know people like that, and there's nothing wrong with it. But afterward, those lower moods tend to follow because the brain functionally and hormonally "burns out." Much like a drug, it exhausts its normal resources and falls into a deficit, leading to states that are just another form of "spending," only much more unpleasant. — Of course, it doesn't have to be intense, and I'm not claiming that's exactly what's happening in his case; in fact, I really hope it isn't.