Jonathan Brown5
Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jun 2011
It isn't fair for anyone to use blackmail against you, whether it comes from your parents or from your wife.
Of course, it is the duty of an adult to become independent and, once they have established their own family, to ensure that they are the primary focus of his care and responsibility. Naturally, I also believe that your place is with your child: everyone’s place is with their children, just as children should grow up alongside their parents. However, regardless of how many people advise you that your place is by your wife and child's side, I do not know how much faith a man can place in a woman who resorts to coercion and demands that he renounce his parents—treating them poorly while her own parents are, of course, deemed "perfect" (I am always skeptical of such black-and-white distinctions). At the same time, these "perfect" parents of hers are disparaging you, the husband their own daughter chose for herself.
He ought to resolve the issues within his marriage; I do not know the exact circumstances, but first and foremost, he needs to discover through honest conversation what she actually wants: does she truly love him and desire his happiness (because a woman who wants that must realize how ugly and selfish it is to use force and blackmail to alienate a husband from his parents—demanding he be only by her side, even if it leaves him unhappy because he lacks 'access' to his parents), or does she simply want a pushover by her side who will cater exclusively to her whims and—of course—admire her "ideal" parents, while simultaneously disrespecting his own because she simply doesn't like them.
If she does not get along with your parents, she does not need to embrace them or see them constantly, provided that any meetings occur with a minimum level of politeness and courtesy; however, she has no right to demand that you disown your parents just because she finds them disagreeable.
On the other hand, he should explain clearly to his own parents that he holds a responsibility toward his family, his wife, and his child, and that he needs to determine if his marriage has any chance of survival, as he wishes to provide his child with a stable childhood free from conflict, hatred, and manipulation. He should make it clear that in a situation that is already difficult, he cannot be subjected to further pressure via threats of being stripped of parental rights. He should tell them that he requires their parental guidance, support, and understanding during this trying time... and if they are true parents, I believe they should understand him... and offer him their support.