Angela Wright said:And you, sweetie, clearly aren't reading with any actual comprehension or attention. Your implication that I obviously haven't found myself in a similar spot isn't fair. People deal with all kinds of chaos on a daily basis, and nobody has the right to claim their problems are somehow different, bigger, or harder than anyone else's. For your information, if you actually looked at my profile, you'd see I deal with one particular, highly traumatic situation quite frequently, working with people and their families from the very moment they receive a diagnosis.
Like I said before, and I’m repeating it now: she doesn't need clinical treatment; she needs guidance on how to carry herself through this entire crisis. Other people have reached out to her with that exact kind of support.
I have no idea what specific psychologists or psychiatrists you're citing, because I don't know what questions you actually asked them. It’s pretty clear you were asking them about treatment, rather than guidance on how to handle things right now. For God's sake, crisis intervention centers weren't dreamed up by accident. They were designed by experts for a very specific purpose. Look at American movies based on true stories, like those dealing with school shootings. Crisis teams of psychologists and therapists arrive on the scene immediately to work with the survivors, talk through everything, and facilitate support groups. Why do you think that is?
And please, just accept once and for all that psychologists and psychiatrists aren't just there for people with chronic mental illnesses; they exist to prevent those very illnesses and disorders from developing out of intense, high-stress situations. That’s why getting that help and guidance as early as possible is absolutely critical.
The girl came looking for advice and she got it. She made her decision fully informed. She says she feels better, which is great—let's just hope that holds.
I feel like you aren't really listening here because you've been acting incredibly arrogant and condescending from the start.
I'm just reporting what the psychologists told me when I called them regarding this exact same situation she's facing right now.
I only called because, from the second it happened, everyone around me started hysterically screaming for professional help (not because of me, but because of my brother, who witnessed everything).
And the clinicians and other specialists told me exactly what I've written here.
Unless there's an immediate pathological condition, they said there's no need to rush to a psychologist—sometimes a person just needs time to process everything mentally.
They told us to check back in a few months.
So, we're talking about a crisis situation involving a traumatic event... the experts knew the situation and gave me the advice I'm simply quoting.
So, don't attack me. You can disagree with how certain psychologists work, sure, but don't make this personal.
And being "ill" and committing suicide are definitely not the same thing... when someone is truly ill, it's a completely different trajectory that a person has to navigate to accept.
You can prepare for what's coming, you have free will in how you face the problem, the family is involved in the process, and so on.
This is a totally different type of issue, and trying to lump it all together is just lazy, sweeping guesswork about an unknown situation.
P.S. I've lived through your version of this too, so I know exactly what I'm talking about.
Maybe ask my brother if the feeling is the same whether a parent dies of cancer or takes their own life... I'm sure he'll have something to say about that.