Another $5k down and the big debate: Leasing vs. Auto Loan🙄
For an individual, Leasing is a total scam. There are a million reasons why it makes zero sense. Business owners? That’s a different story—they run the math and make it work.
The only possible reason you'd ever touch Leasing is if you can't get an auto loan from a bank because you don't have any collateral, and even then, only if the Leasing company doesn't demand a co-signer for the same asset.
Now, I'm not exactly up to speed on how much banks actually care about co-signers versus just holding the title until the final payment is made...
Look, if you have a co-signer for a standard loan, there's no reason to overthink it. Taking a car on a lease where you don't have
buyout rights at the end (or even if you do) is just plain stupid for a regular person. Plus, just like a loan where the bank holds the title, you're stuck with mandatory full coverage insurance until it's paid off, mandatory servicing at authorized dealerships (keep that logbook perfect), and all that other fine print... It might sound trivial to some, but full coverage costs way more than a standard registration, so it hits your wallet hard.
Bottom line: You buy a car so YOU can own it. So YOU decide on the insurance, the service, and whatever else... not the other way around.
neontiger4 said:I'm looking at buying a car as an individual, though I'd probably pull $40 from a loan to cover the down payment. My main banks, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo, only offer auto loans in dollars. Is it actually worth looking into operational or finance leasing with a residual value option?
Anyone got some advice? A standard loan seems like the best bet financially, but since they're only offering them in dollars, I'm a little paranoid about currency fluctuations given everything happening in the USA lately. I don't want to get caught in a depreciation trap.
Honestly, leasing is a bad move.
First off, if you pick up a traffic ticket, my guess is it goes straight to the leasing company, and then they just tack it onto your bill. That means you end up paying sales tax on top of the fine.
Second, leasing makes sense for companies that put massive mileage on their vehicles—they know they need high turnover, so they just swap for a new lease once the old one is worn out. As an individual, I highly doubt you're putting in that kind of mileage. The whole point of leasing is easy asset replacement. In the US, they push it on individuals mostly because it's easier to qualify for than a traditional loan, especially for people with shaky credit or low purchasing power. It’s easier for the bank to get their money back if you default because they technically own the car and can just come grab it.
Third, leasing usually comes with those annoying currency adjustment clauses.
Fourth, the late fees for missing a payment will absolutely kill you.
Fifth, stay far away from that "residual value" thing. Don't kid yourself thinking you'll just have a nice chunk of cash sitting there at the end of the term. You'll likely just end up having to take out another loan to cover the balance or fall for some "clever" deal the leasing company tries to pitch you.
Sixth, for heaven's sake, don't go buying such an expensive car in 2012. The worst is still coming over the next couple of years. Save up some cash if you can and buy used, or if you already have a car, just drive it until it finally dies on you.
With Leasing and the various versions companies like Ford Credit offer, every little headache, maintenance task, or repair falls on the lessee, but strictly according to their contract rules. If you cause a wreck, yeah, you pay the fine. If it's a total loss and insurance doesn't cover everything, the leasing company decides how much you owe. Honestly, just walk away. It's too much of a headache, and once you sign, there's no turning back...
neontiger4 said:I'm looking at buying a car as an individual, though I'd probably pull $40 from a loan to cover the down payment. My main banks, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo, only offer auto loans in dollars. Is it actually worth looking into operational or finance leasing with a residual value option?
Anyone got some advice? A standard loan seems like the best bet financially, but since they're only offering them in dollars, I'm a little paranoid about currency fluctuations given everything happening in the USA lately. I don't want to get caught in a depreciation trap.
Honestly, leasing is a bad move.
First off, if you pick up a traffic ticket, my guess is it goes straight to the leasing company, and then they just tack it onto your bill. That means you end up paying sales tax on top of the fine.
Second, leasing makes sense for companies that put massive mileage on their vehicles—they know they need high turnover, so they just swap for a new lease once the old one is worn out. As an individual, I highly doubt you're putting in that kind of mileage. The whole point of leasing is easy asset replacement. In the US, they push it on individuals mostly because it's easier to qualify for than a traditional loan, especially for people with shaky credit or low purchasing power. It’s easier for the bank to get their money back if you default because they technically own the car and can just come grab it.
Third, leasing usually comes with those annoying currency adjustment clauses.
Fourth, the late fees for missing a payment will absolutely kill you.
Fifth, stay far away from that "residual value" thing. Don't kid yourself thinking you'll just have a nice chunk of cash sitting there at the end of the term. You'll likely just end up having to take out another loan to cover the balance or fall for some "clever" deal the leasing company tries to pitch you.
Sixth, for heaven's sake, don't go buying such an expensive car in 2012. The worst is still coming over the next couple of years. Save up some cash if you can and buy used, or if you already have a car, just drive it until it finally dies on you.
Haha, kind of funny, but there's a lot of truth in that. Unfortunately, that's just how it is today.