Hello everyone...
I must admit, I have read through this entire thread from the very beginning☕ looking for someone facing a similar issue to mine, but regardless, I will lay out my own situation here in the hope that a kind soul might offer some guidance.🙏
I am currently a college student, and I have never once been cited for any legal violation before now.
A little less than three months ago, I was driving around at about 3:00 AM while heading home after work. Traffic wasn't particularly heavy, so I suppose I was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time when I was pulled over. The officer’s conduct was quite professional. After I provided my driver's license and registration, and after stating clearly that I had not consumed any alcohol, I agreed to take the breathalyzer test, which yielded a reading of 0.08. The officer then wrote up the citation, and I signed the report where he noted that I had consumed one beer.
Today, I received the notice from the municipal court stating that I am being found liable and will be fined $400 plus $77 (court costs). I have the right to appeal this within 8 days.
Under the law, the fine should range from $167 to $500, so it strikes me as somewhat unusual that I am being penalized—at least for now—with an amount closer to the maximum than the minimum, especially considering that I am a student, that I acted respectfully during the encounter, and that this is my first offense in my entire life...
The legal statute states
"A driver shall be fined between $500.00 and $500 if they have alcohol levels up to 0.50 g/kg, or milligrams per liter of exhaled breath, in their system.
In addition to the fine, a point may be assessed against their license."
I was planning to file an appeal, so I would truly appreciate some help...
Option 1: Not disputing the accuracy of the breathalyzer results, but rather disputing the actual consumption of alcohol. In the appeal, I could argue that the reading was caused by eating some fruit pastries and a headache I was experiencing. Because of the headache, I took some medication (like Aspirin or something similar) and I signed the report without reading it closely because I just wanted to get home and go to bed due to the pain...
Goal: To try and settle for a mere warning... I would value your advice on how realistic it is to expect this and what the potential consequences of such a move might be.
Option 2: Admitting guilt, expressing genuine remorse, and emphasizing my status as a student...
Goal: A minimal fine (and I wonder, is it even possible to receive just a warning with this approach?)
Any advice would be most welcome...
Also, I am curious about this purely hypothetically...
"(9) For a driver of a motor vehicle, streetcar, or driving instructor who, within a 24-month period following the date of the violation, has been legally convicted two or more times for violations under this section, the court may impose a jail sentence of up to 60 days along with a protective measure prohibiting the operation of a motor vehicle for one to two years, and assign five penalty points.
" If an individual is convicted twice within a 24-month window for driving under the influence, does the loss of their license for one or two years happen automatically alongside the fine, or does the court decide on that? Furthermore, if someone already had one point on their record from a previous incident and now receives five, bringing the total to six, do they still retain their license?