Susan Green2 said:I agree that the scope of the issue is much broader; the tendency of the West to meddle in the domestic affairs of other nations is often the catalyst for these crises. However, it isn't fair to lay the entirety of the blame at the feet of Westerners alone. Many of the terrorists and criminals we see dominating the news cycles lately hail from countries that haven't seen a single day of war and have never been the target of Western intervention.
Look, I'm not blaming all Americans. I'm not saying there isn't an issue on the streets either, and I definitely don't deny that a huge chunk of those problems comes down to "cultural differences"—if you want to put it politely. But I think there are two things that are really important to consider if I'm trying to look at the bigger picture, I guess.
I guess Merkelica’s decision to help those people—and basically putting herself at risk to do it—really matters when you think about how safe we feel individually. It’s pretty clear why so many people are upset. Where I live, there’s been this rise in thefts and attacks lately, mostly just people getting jumped on the street. There used to be no neighborhoods you had to avoid, but now there are definitely some. Most of the people involved are Afganistanac, Somalijac, or something like that. I mean, only a total fool would ignore that. But I still look at all of this as a symptom. Personally, I’d be happiest if those folks could just have an education and a decent life back home where they came from. I’m all for cultural exchange, obviously, but maybe just on a scale that’s a bit more compatible than what we're seeing right now. I suppose wanting to move from a place with a lower quality of life to one with a higher one is just one of those oldest, most natural things about being human.
I guess it’s really important to look at what actually caused all this, maybe just so future generations don't repeat the same mistakes. To find those roots, we kind of have to look back at the last few hundred years—times when huge chunks of the world were under imperial rule, where people were treated like they didn't even matter, denied an education, divided up, and had their resources stripped away while wars were forced on them. Whether it was the British, the French, the Soviets, the Americans, or the Chinese... it doesn't really matter. And then there are times when nobody did anything to help at all. You only have to look at the last few decades to see how dictators were supported, weapons were sold, and coups were organized. I suppose the West has been much more destructive than constructive. So, honestly, looking at everything we have today, I don't think anyone should be surprised.
Another thing I’m thinking about is this whole clash between rural, tribal mindsets and urban ones. Like, if you look at a place like Afghanistan, it’s organized around these different tribes where the concept of law just means something totally different than what we’re used to here in the States. It’s the same with education levels or how people view women. I guess you can't just hand someone a flyer and expect them to know how to act in Germany, especially if they're always staying in tight-knit groups. But, maybe it's also a bit silly to lump everyone together. Even in Afghanistan, there are definitely urbanized, "civilized" people, even if they're hard to spot. Or take a place like Syria—they have a huge urban population, too, but the cultural gap there feels similar to the difference between New York City and a tiny town in rural Appalachia. The way women, LGBTQ+ folks, or minorities live in NYC is just worlds apart from those rural areas. Honestly, I’ve met some Americans whose views on basic human rights and respecting others are so different from mine that they feel more foreign to me than someone from Morocco. I don't mean I'm comparing Parisians to extremists or anything, just talking about fundamental respect for people.
All in all, I guess there were some huge mistakes made regarding how these migrations were managed and controlled. We can argue about whether Russia or America started this just to weaken the West, but there were definitely failures on our end too. Still, we really need to talk about what actually caused this. It wasn't just Angela Merkel's policies. It bothers me that things were mostly stable until we started meddling, backing rebels, selling weapons, and toppling dictators who actually kept things steady... it was a disaster. And somehow, nobody is being held accountable for that; they just point fingers at Merkel.