Casey Thomas4 said:To all you forum regulars who actually know your way around a combat sport, I have a few things I'm chewing on... I’ve spent my entire life on the soccer field, but a few months back, I stumbled upon a guy teaching a specific style of self-defense and decided to give it a shot. It was centered heavily on blocking strikes, using various levers, and disarming techniques. Honestly, I loved it... but things have hit a bit of a snag lately regarding the cost, so I’m looking for a new direction. Ideally, I want something just as effective—though I should mention my previous instructor used to train guys over at the local SWAT teams... I've been looking into Wing Tsun or maybe Aikido. Since I don't really have a background in martial arts, I could use some guidance or a nudge in the right direction. From what I’ve gathered reading through these threads, every discipline seems to have its fair share of people claiming to be experts when they really aren't, and I'd really rather not end up wasting my time with some charlatan... Thanks for any help, everyone...
How exactly did you go from being an instructor for the Army to practicing Wing Chun and Aikido?🤷 What does what those cops over in Lučko practice have to do with Wing Chun or Aikido? It’s a fair question... I mean, if you look at how those tactical units operate, it seems like a world away from the fluid movements of a traditional dojo...😕
Building on what Sam Roberts suggested, I’d also throw Bujinkan into the mix—assuming you’re actually interested in weapon work. My only gripe with them is their unconventional setup; they tend to run this intense selection process through an initial group that filters people out so aggressively, half the students never even make it to the actual "ninjutsu" or the specific skills that drew them to the school in the first place... Plus there are a few other Jiu-Jitsu clubs worth looking into as well.
If you’re actually serious about getting into Aikido, you should probably head over to Zafranović. He’s a true practitioner—a real aikidoka—and he carries a level of Dan ranking that’s pretty rare to find around here...
I'm guessing you're from the Chicago area or somewhere nearby...?
Wing Chun—and honestly, if anyone tries to steer me elsewhere, they can just keep walking. I’m staying biased on this one...
Just because someone calls themselves an "aikidoka" doesn't mean they actually have a clue how to practice the art. Honestly, he probably thinks his technique is the absolute best in the entire country, but then again... that’s a long story, and it really doesn't matter...