Nicholas King said:So, let's just have everyone enroll in whatever they feel like, shall we? And the taxpayers will foot the bill for all of it—right up until the moment it becomes painfully obvious to everyone involved that those enrollments were a complete waste of time. And that realization? It usually takes years upon years upon years...
I suppose if I were to ask where the funding for this particular brand of "education" comes from—given that its entire foundation rests on waiting for people to eventually realize they are either incompetent, lazy, or simply unsuited for schooling—I would just be met with the usual collection of tired platitudes about how there is plenty of money out there, it's just being mismanaged.
In my view, there is no more egregious waste of taxpayer dollars than indulging every whim, every little daydream, and every academic utopia dreamt up by students and their parents. We can blame Coelho for all of this, I guess: the idea that if you just wish hard enough for an education, the whole world will somehow conspire to make it happen... as if that's how reality works.
Why is it such an insurmountable challenge to simply admit the truth? There are foolish kids, there are lazy kids, and there are kids who simply aren't cut out for certain paths—no matter how much they, or perhaps even more so, their parents might want them to be.
They exist, right?
That’s on them and their parents, not the government.
We'll never shake this mindset of the state acting like a parent that handles everything and decides everything... then we wonder why nobody takes personal responsibility.
Education should be equal and accessible to everyone. Standards need to be the same for everybody (SATs, ACTs, national standards, etc.). Whatever someone chooses regarding the public school system will affect their life later—lower standard of living, fewer opportunities, etc. That's the individual's responsibility, not the government's job to tell a 14-year-old, "Hey, you're at this level, so you go here." The government's duty is just to provide the schooling (equally and under the same criteria) to everyone.
The Constitution (looks like Article 6, I think) clearly states that everyone has a right to free education (basic mandatory) that is available to all and
under equal conditions... In my opinion, trying to track students starting at 14—and now even as early as 10 or 11—doesn't meet those constitutional requirements.