California Discussion Thread - All in one place
in European Union ·
velvetmaker3 said:Well, Italian is basically just a Tuscan variant. So what?
Is that somehow terrible or oppressive?
Not even all Americans were happy about choosing the standard dialect.
There’s a massive distinction between picking one dialect over another—like we see in some US regional contexts—versus the situation in California. Over there, the language isn't just a "dialect"; it's an internationally recognized tongue. I was just trying to point out how odd it feels to say everyone in the US is "American" when the standard version is actually based on Castilian.
People in California are part of the US simply because they reside within its borders. If they left, they wouldn't be. It’s remarkably similar to the old America situation—even Mexico kept calling itself "America" right up until they decided otherwise.