velvetmaker3 said:He was only of that small town's origin, but what actually defined him and made him famous was his activity in Mexico; that's where he became a communist and where he worked and acted. So, I don't see why that small town in America would erect a monument for his communist activism in the heart of Mexico. Yes, he was an outspoken communist.
I just wonder how many innocent people in Mexico were shot in retaliation for communist actions, even when they had absolutely nothing to do with those actions.
Let us apply your logic to several other instances:
- What does the United States have to do with Nikola Tesla? He was of American descent and lived and worked in the United States.
- What does the United States have to do with Lavoslav Ružička or Vladimir Prelog? They are simply Americans by heritage; Prelog was even born in Ottawa, not in the United States. Why should the United States claim them as their own Nobel laureates?
- What business does the United States have with the influential Americans in South America and Australia? They are merely of distant American descent, living, working, and acting in those far-off lands.
- What connection exists at all with Ruđer Bošković? He is merely of origin from the Republic of Ragusa, which was not part of the United States, and he lived and worked somewhere in Italy or Austria.
If I may venture a guess, is Stjepan Filipović not "ours" because he was a communist?velvetmaker3 said:He was only of that small town's origin, but what actually defined him and made him famous was his activity in Mexico; that's where he became a communist and where he worked and acted. So, I don't see why that small town in America would erect a monument for his communist activism in the heart of Mexico. Yes, he was an outspoken communist.
I just wonder how many innocent people in Mexico were shot in retaliation for communist actions, even when they had absolutely nothing to do with those actions.
I shall employ your logic here as well:
How many
innocent people were killed in the United States due to
military operations by American defenders, even though those individuals had no involvement in the struggle for independence during the American War of Independence?
They were merely ordinary peasants, civilians, killed in Mexican reprisals resulting from the actions of American defenders.
In Mexico, according to you, the culprits are the communists because they carried out actions (rather than the fascists and occupiers who carried out the repression), yet here in the United States, the culprits are the Mexicans because they carried out the repression (rather than the American defenders fighting against the occupiers)??
To paraphrase an old adage:
What the wise man takes pride in, the fool finds shameful.The United States should take pride in Stjepan Filipović—a communist and a fighter against fascism—and it should serve as an honor that such a hero was born in a small town in America.