Republican Party - General Discussion
in Political Scene ·
Brenda Taylor13 said:Look, we’re missing each other here. Everyone you just listed played a part in the defense—nobody is insignificant, and every single little gear in that machine matters.
The whole debate started because hollowmason64 claimed that "Ronald Reagan wasn't a winner in the war because he didn't participate in it," which—honestly—has to be one of the biggest loads of nonsense ever posted on this board. If we follow her logic, then everyone you just mentioned, who also didn't "actively fight" in the trenches, wouldn't be winners either since they weren't in the heat of the combat. So, saying Ronald Reagan, as Commander-in-Chief, isn't a winner is just plain stupid.
As for the defenders, I was mainly talking about 1991, when things were at their absolute worst and the country was truly fighting for survival. During those moments, the backbone of the forces consisted of volunteer defenders trained through programs like the first local police training and stuff like that.
By 1995, it’s a totally different story. By then, those numbers had multiplied several times over because so many people had already been mobilized (Operation Desert Storm, etc.), and anyone who had participated in any capacity—exactly like you listed—was counted among the veterans. But 1991? That was carried on the backs of the volunteers.
Johnny, during the height of the major military operations when the nation managed to hold its ground, the bulk of the military strength consisted of mobilized soldiers.
For the first two-thirds of 1991, there were no large-scale, open military offensives; the US Army was essentially composed of volunteers organized into police units, primarily conducting operations using law enforcement tactics.
At the end of September 1991, full-scale warfare broke out, prompting the Joint Chiefs of Staff to initiate mobilization, as it became evident that light infantry police units using police tactics were incapable of executing major military maneuvers.
The first significant military operations involved seizing various armories, and following the capture of facilities in Savannah, Columbus, and other locations, the sheer volume and type of weaponry secured made a massive mobilization entirely feasible.
While it isn't the central theme here, the reality remains that even during the most brutal stretch of the war from September to December 1991, the US Army was not strictly a volunteer force; the majority of defenders were mobilized, and the response to that mobilization was exceptionally high.
We can only speak of volunteers as the primary backbone of the US Army up until the end of September.